Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
274printed page
scan 288 of 434
Facsimile · scan 288 of 434
Scan of p. 274
English · AI translation, not yet checked

274

If it is only Zionist in order to maintain twenty small colonies in Palestine, then it is not Zionist at all. Then it will not fall away from Zionism, but rather it does not know Zionism at all and has never understood it. For a few colonies in Palestine do not redeem the Jewish people, do not improve their lot, have not the slightest influence on their fate at all.

But if the Jewish people are Zionist in order to redeem themselves, then they have no reason at all to fall away from Zionism because Zionism does not support the colonies with money. For they must understand that the maintenance of the colonies does not mean the redemption of the Jewish people.

The downfall of the colonies would be disastrous for Zionism in only one case: if it were to prove that Jewish agricultural colonies in Palestine could under no circumstances be sustained, that the soil of the Holy Land is not at all suitable for economically independent colonization. But that is not the lesson that emerges from the history of the colonies.

The colonies are close to ruin: first, because the first colonists were completely inexperienced and approached their new occupation of farming like children; second, because they immigrated to Palestine without rights and had to spend almost everything they earned even in good years on baksheesh and usurious government levies; third, because they partly lived beyond their means; fourth and mainly, because they fell into the hands of so-called benefactors, who one day, due to a billionaire's whim, suddenly abandoned them.

To this fourth point I would like to add a few explanatory words.