Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
273printed page
scan 287 of 434
Facsimile · scan 287 of 434
Scan of p. 273
English · AI translation, not yet checked

273

Zionism bears no responsibility whatsoever in the matter of the Palestinian colonies. If they were to exist and prosper, it would not be to its credit. If they were to perish, it would not be its fault. Today's political Zionism was not yet born when the colonies were established. It has had no influence on their development. It is at once a foolish and unjust demand that it should now atone for what others have sinned.

That is not its task. For that, it currently does not have the strength. I even ask myself whether it would have a right to do so, if it had the strength.

The colonies are the work of a few hundred enthusiastic Zionists of action, who stormed out to Palestine about twenty years ago to immediately realize a cherished dream of their lives. They went without preparation, partly without means, all without professional training, without a definite plan, into the unknown, into the blue; not like coolly calculating, sober people, but like sleepwalkers or like dreamers.

I do not have the heart to reproach these noble enthusiasts. On the contrary, I have admiration for them, but an admiration mixed with deep pity. Far from seeing them as role models, I regard them as deterrent examples. They have not shown the Jewish people how it should be done; they have taught it how it should not be done.

"If Zionism does not stand by our colonists, the Jewish people will fall away from Zionism."

Really? Why?

Is the Jewish people Zionist in order to support a few hundred families in Palestine, or is it Zionist because it is supposed to redeem itself?

18