238
...do you want to create a Jewish nationalism? The evolution of humanity leads to the disappearance of small nationalities and their merging into a few large nations; do you want to work against this evolution and put one more little nation into the world? Should that be the end of our four-thousand-year history? Should our fathers have been glorious martyrs for their faith and their ethics for two thousand years, only for their late descendants to finally land as a tiny little people in a remote corner of the earth and there continue to vegetate in obscurity?
That sounds very fine and very profound. I would like the philosophers and idealists to present this objection to the wandering Romanian Jews and the millions of Russians and Galicians who will soon follow them on their path of suffering. I hear the answer of the homeless: “Dear Sir, we are deeply moved by the high opinion you have of us. We are proud that you demand for us a grander destiny than a modest life as a people in Palestine. But before we set about realizing this grand destiny, we must fulfill a small formality. You see, we must eat. That is indeed very prosaic, but if we neglect this formality, it would become very difficult for us to justify the great expectations that you are so kind as to hold for us. And since we have the experience that we can never eat regularly for long elsewhere, you must forgive us for returning to Palestine, in order to wait there, with daily meals and in submission, for it to please God to give our two-thousand-year martyrdom the glorious conclusion that alone can satisfy your aesthetic need.”
But why continue to illuminate and refute these objections? It is a futile undertaking. It is a waste of time.
