237
Objection: Turkey will never consent to the Jewish people resettling Palestine with the right of self-government. And even if Turkey itself were to consent, the Jewish people could not hold their own in Palestine amidst the rivalry of the Great Powers, who have designs on the Holy Land. Our friendly critics, who speak so confidently in the name of Turkey, will permit us to reply that we respectfully and thankfully decline to receive the Sultan's decision from their mouths. We prefer to receive this decision from the Turkish government itself. If it declares to us that it will not open Palestine to us under any condition, then we will believe it. So far, however, it has declared nothing of the sort to us. And as for the rivalry of the Great Powers, I would just like to remark on this: Belgium is also the object of the most jealous surveillance by at least three neighboring Great Powers. For 70 years, however, precisely this mutual jealousy has proven to be the best guarantee of the independence of the Belgian people, who are no stronger than the Jewish people would be in Palestine after the completion of the settlement work.
Now the sociological objection: it is impossible to transform a people of city-dwellers, a people of merchants, shopkeepers, and intellectual workers, into a people of farmers. We admit that it is difficult. On a small scale, this transformation has actually succeeded in Russia, Palestine, Argentina, and Canada. If a few thousand Talmudic students, brokers, and artisans could become capable farmers and winegrowers, then it is not unreasonable to conclude that millions could also do so.
The historico-philosophical and sentimental objection: the curse and the shame of the century is nationalism.
