4
Citing from canonical and interpretive scriptures, Herr Güdemann seeks to prove that the Jews are not a people, indeed are not allowed to form a people. The spirit of their faith, the course of their history since the destruction of the Second Temple, outright forbids them to feel themselves a people, to unite into a unified people. Their mission is precisely the overcoming of the national idea, the leading of humanity out of the narrowness of selfish nationalism into the breadth and freedom of humankind. The brotherhood, not the separation, of peoples is the task of Judaism. The Zion that is promised to the Jews, and for which their longing has sighed for two millennia, is to be understood symbolically. It is another word for the Kingdom of God on Earth. If one gathers Judaism into a people, structures it into its own statehood, one prevents it from fulfilling its mission and sins against the statutes of its faith.
I hope Herr Dr. Güdemann will find that I have honestly reproduced the main arguments of his brochure and can with a clear conscience take the preceding summary of its most essential content as the basis for discussion.
The Chief Rabbi in Vienna would like to wage the fight against Zionism on theological grounds. It would be childish of us to agree to follow him there. Zionism has not the slightest thing to do with theology. It is not a religious movement, but a political, economic, moral-historical, and sociological one. Herr Dr. Güdemann is guilty of petty wordplay when he uses the external circumstance that the name of the movement evokes biblical memories — or mis-