Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
3printed page
scan 17 of 434

3

On page 39 he makes this kind admission: “If one offers those Jews, for whom the struggle for existence in their previous homeland is made all too difficult, the opportunity to settle elsewhere, this is in high degree praiseworthy and commendable.” But already on page 42 he regrets this indulgence and exclaims: “The poor Jews, whom the national movement wants to help, are precisely the strongest and most resilient, who need this help, even if it were one, the very least.” So the national-Jewish movement, which wants to offer the poor Jews the opportunity to settle elsewhere, is “in high degree praiseworthy and commendable”, but the poor need this help, that is, the settlement in the land of their ancestors, “the very least”. (Dr. Theodor Herzl has already pointed out this contradiction in Dr. Bloch’s “Oesterr. Wochenschrift”.)

Yet it is repugnant to me to get lost in quibbles and to follow the wondrous convolutions of Mr. Dr. Güdemann's trains of thought step by step. The gravity of the matter requires, and it corresponds to my intellectual habits, to consider Mr. Dr. Güdemann's polemic from a greater height and with wider-seeing eyes.

Mr. Dr. Güdemann notes with displeasure that in recent times the idea that they are a separate tribe has found numerous adherents among the Jews, who have consistently developed it into the demand that the separate tribe must also obtain its own land and a national structure in which it can live out its existence as a state. “The midwife of this movement was indignation.... To indignation was then added, as is natural, defiance.” But this movement contradicts the essence of Judaism. With a great expenditure of

1*