Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
2printed page
scan 16 of 434

worked in a more composed mood? Or did he count on no one reading the 43 pages with attention in their entirety?

On page 24 he demonstrated, “that the modern emphasis on the national is... utterly contrary to the spirit of the Torah, the Prophets and Psalms,” while on page 41 he states that the Jews in Babylon were “instructed to consider themselves Babylonians in all respects, except for their faith, and the Jews in the Diaspora have always adhered to this instruction. Those in Spain called themselves Spaniards, those in France, Frenchmen, those in Germany, Germans.” Herr Dr. Güdemann thus finds it right for the Jews to emphasize a national identity, while at the same time assuring that this emphasis on the national contradicts the spirit of the Scripture. It is praiseworthy for the Jews to be a national Babylonian, Spaniard, Frenchman, German; the only nationality one may not profess without violating the spirit of the Torah, Prophets and Psalms, is the Jewish one.

On page 41, against the endeavor to rescue the Jews from persecution by fighting for their national independence, he puts forward the fabulous argument: “that would have appeared as an interference in God’s guidance, in whose wise plan the Diaspora also occupies its predestined place,” and on page 42 he already remarks: “Every man must know what his duty and his right is. If the latter is denied him, he must fight for it, win it by struggle. That also applies to the Jews.” Which of his two recommendations does Herr Dr. Güdemann now wish to see followed? Should one “fight for, win by struggle the denied right,” or is this “fight” and “struggle” “an interference in God’s guidance,” in “whose wise plan” the denial of rights also “occupies its predestined place?”