The Maccabaean
revolution can, in every instance, be traced back to the denials of the Czarist government. The second revolution was like a great emotional release from unnatural inhibitions. The inhibitors, not the releasors, are to be blamed. Even Mrs. Williams is not so stupid as to miss this point. She understands why Denikin, so loudly heralded in the New York Times by her husband, Harold Williams, failed to win the allegiance of the peasants. Because he assumed it was natural for Russian peasants to be ruled in the old manner and he had not enough force to sufficiently repress and inhibit. He has lived to rue his error. Maybe Mrs. Williams will live to understand and see clearly. She was too close to the scene. She lacked the right perspective. God knows the Bolsheviki offer sufficient material for attacks, but Mrs. Williams was in too much of a hurry.
Honest Interpretation
Musical Portraits. By PAUL ROSENFELD. Harcourt, Brace and Howe, New York City.
The writing of such essays as compose this volume is a distinct temptation to preciosity. It is to the inestimable credit of Mr. Rosenfeld then that he has followed straightly the path of interpretation.
But what I call interpretation must by no means be associated purely with that forbidding quality we understand as analysis. It is far from that. Mr. Rosenfeld is an interpretative critic in the human sense quite as much as he is in the technical sense and in the fusion of human perceptions and interpretative analysis has been created as beautiful a book of criticism as has come recently from the presses. Waldo Frank's "Our America," and Van Wyck Brooks' "The Ordeal of Mark Twain," are the only other volumes that can be accorded such praise, although the latter occupies a somewhat higher level.
To me, music was once characterized as a beautiful glow of color, as unindividualized, one composition from the other, as one rainbow from another. All the varieties of good music drew from me the undifferentiated reaction that different rainbows evoked. Now the more glaring diversities between varieties of music are beginning to be realized in my consciousness. Later on, very likely, if I persist, I shall be able to perceive the more delicate and elusive tints and tones that differentiate types of music and much, much later on I shall be able to perceive music as an expression of the composer and correlate his life, his era and his background with his musical productions.
It is to the farthest point in musical understanding that Mr. Rosenfeld has penetrated. The crowd sees the color; he sees the shade. Jamais la couleur; toujours la nuance. There you have the critic's reaction as opposed to the crowd's. The critic refines upon the gross and commonplace reaction of the mob. The mob says a thing is beautiful. It does not know why. The critic knows not only why it is beautiful, but he knows the type of beauty that spectacle which has evoked the crowd's admiration represents, and he knows by either an understanding or an intuition that approaches infallibility whether a thing is a sham or a reality in the realm of beauty. He perceives also the beauty for which the mob is unprepared and he perceives the false tinsel which the mob has mistakenly accepted as beautiful.
Mr. Rosenfeld speaks of the work of the twenty composers, the study of which makes up this volume, without relation to the mob's judgment or the judgment of other critics. He individualizes every composer in relation to his work in a manner that publishes both his learning and his charm. He writes of Listzt as if he were addressing a kindly reprimand to him. He analyzes the tragedy of Mahler the Jew afraid to speak in his own musical tongue and achieving a hodge podge synthesis of other and alien composers. He writes of Strauss in the most beautiful manner, and speaks of Wagner so iconoclastically that even the so-called musical radicals may be alarmed. But all these essays represent the work of an honest and discriminating critic, no matter how individual and even how erratic that work may appear.
I cannot close this short comment without recording that the publication of this book is, in a way, a record of a triumph of my
own. Many months ago when I was suggesting what books should be got out to a certain publisher, I proposed that he publish a series of Paul Rosenfeld's musical criticisms. I had read some of Mr. Rosenfeld's essays when they appeared in magazines and thought them deserving of book publication. My suggestion was rejected. Not long after, the book came out under the ægis of Harcourt, Brace and Howe. It appears that there was at least one other person, with far more influence in impressing his judgment, apparently, who agreed with me, essentially, in my estimate of Paul Rosenfeld as a musical critic and interpreter. I was glad. PAUL SIMON.
Correspondence
House Building in Palestine
To the Editor:
A book of information published in August by the Zionist Commission in Palestine gives these facts: From April, 1919, to June, 1920 (fourteen months), Jews built in Jaffa 57 houses, in Haifa 6, and in Jerusalem 2. In Tel-Aviv 30 more will be finished by the end of 1920, making a total of 95 in one year and eight months for the entire Jewish city population of Palestine.
Likewise these figures on costs are instructive: For a house of four rooms, kitchen and bath, one floor high, measuring 42 feet long by 38 feet wide by 16 feet high. The cost of erection is £900 to £1,000 ($3,600 to $4,000) in Jerusalem and £600 to £800 ($2,400 to $3,200) in Jaffa.
G. H. D. Cole, with whom I discussed the question of guilds in Palestine, stated that the "group" (Kvootzah) or guild system can be most successfully worked out in Building and Construction Trades. England has given abundant proof.
The lack of housing accommodations in Palestine is a serious problem now. With the expected immigrant influx the trouble will be seriously aggravated. Inefficient methods of construction, obsolete styles of architecture make building today prohibitive to all but the very rich. The very few houses being built in the country are, with some notable exceptions being built by Arabs working for Jewish contractors.
Three prime needs exist—large scale construction, modern efficient methods, workingmen. But no workers (neither Arab nor Jewish) are to be had in Palestine. The suggestion is for the establishment of one or more building guilds outside of Palestine, which when organized and prepared, are to proceed to the country for practical activity.
A group of able-bodied, experienced men is to be gathered so as to include the entire human material for erecting a structural unit —a group, beginning with the architect and general manager, through the bricklayer, carpenter, decorator, roofer, painter, etc., down to the stone-cutter, but excluding the unskilled laborer such as the hod carrier who can be found locally. The group would need its tools and implements, such appliances as platform stays and platforms, small temporary. elevators, a motor. The raw materials are at hand in Palestine in unlimited quantity. This, of course, with the exception of wood. At a building operation on the slope of Mt. Carmel, in Haifa, the stones are chiseled out of rock twenty yards from where the houses are to stand, Everywhere cement components are abundant. As to doors, windows, panels, etc., of wood, these must be brought from abroad. It would be well to leave one member of the group in America or England to take charge of the shipment of materials not obtainable locally. .
For the fitting out of such a group, for its transportation, for its maintenance during the period or work before sales of product begin, a considerable sum of money is needed. This may be obtained as loans, preferably from the members themselves, but since this is unlikely, from bankers and from interested Jewish insti
