The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXIV, No. 4 · November 1920
137printed page
scan 37 of 44
Facsimile · scan 37 of 44
Scan of p. 137
Text · transcribed from the scan

The Maccabaean

people, fearing or ashamed to speak out, manners having taught them reticence, speak out no less directly through the form of the novel, as John Cournes has so splendidly done in his "The Mask."

It is in Mr. Ravage's book that we find both the idealism of youth on the East Side and the sordid war between the first and second generation most poignantly depicted. Of the fellowship of intellectuals on the East Side, he writes:

"There was in us that apostolic simplicity of speech and manners, that disregard for externals, that contempt of the world and its prizes, that hatred of shams, that love of the essential, that intolerance of the unbeliever which only they who feed on a living ideal can know."

Then:

"How wretched graybeards and perruqued grandmothers suffered at the disaffection of their young! For even in the most advanced households it was a rare thing if the two generations were in spiritual accord; and in the greater part of them 'clodpate' and 'intelligent' dined at the same table and clashed continually—the parents enduring violent agonies over the children's disloyalty to the ancient faith."

And then note this picture of the "emancipated" Gombarovs from "The Mask":

"The Gombarovs were 'emancipated' Jews. Indeed they looked upon Moses not as upon a divine lawyer but as upon a kind of sanitary inspector who had used the name of Jehovah to impress upon as yet a young credulous, malleable people a morality of gregariousness and a sanitary system, the observance of which entitled the observer not to a future life but to a long life!"

And there were those of us to whom the eternal conflict for sustenance furnished the motif. They are the bitter ones. There is Minnie's mother in "Sarah and Her Daughter":

"I am ruthlessly plucked and returned to the rotten soil of poverty to decay. I am no longer fit to make a struggle. Whoever the evil perpetrator of my fate is he has won. Where is the justice? Whose is the guilt? I am broken, wholly broken . . . and how much more than a hair's breadth divides my children from my fate!"

Then there are the rebels, those to whom hunger justifies revolution. There is Elizabeth Hasanovitz who cries:

"If there was an Almighty He should at last turn to us, the insulted ones, the humiliated, the searchers for everyday bread. But there was no such God or else he would not tolerate such misery."

And Marie Ganz in a collected and conservative moment in the hush after battle cries:

"No matter how conservative I may possibly become under broadening influences, I know I shall never be able to recall without bitterness and without a stirring of the old hatreds the hardships and cruelties that darkened our lives."

Nevertheless, they wish sincerely to be Americans, even in the commonly accepted sense. They are not angry because of racial distemper. They are angry because they live in fear and dread, in hunger and weariness. Removed from the Ghetto, entering without awkwardness into the life of those about them, intellectual opportunities freely accessible to them, a career mapped out, they no longer cry out in pain and bitterness.

Miss Ganz sums up this thesis in the record of the shiftings of Ichael Schwartz: "Ichael Schwartz once won a bet on a hundred to one chance in the Honduras lottery, and immediately undergoing a complete change in his political opinions became an eloquent defender of the rights of capital against the foes of law and order. He lost his winnings in another gamble a few days later and was metamorphosed into a noisy agitator against prevailing social conditions."

Merged in the life about them, the immigrants lose that manner and attitude which had cut them off from the rest of the people for observation and patronage and editorial comment. They are no longer cognizant that the world against which they had been projected only yesterday is one which they have accepted in a more or less matter of fact. For the acceptance sometimes involves a surrender, not of the essentials, but of the many observances by which belief in the faith is marked. That surrender, in a degree, marks the compromise, mild as it is, by which success must be tempted. H. S.

November, 1920-

The First Year of the Revolution

From Liberty to Brest-Litovsk: The First Year of the Russian Revolution, by ARIADNA TYRKOVA-WILLIAMS (Mrs. Harold Williams) Macmillan and Company, London and New York.

Mrs. Williams has carried the revolution only over to Brest-Litovsk. History has carried it further. Excellent as is the case she has made against the Bolsheviks up to Brest-Litovsk, what case can she make against them now when they have proven themselves the only stable government in Europe and capable of carrying on nine wars at once, despite a blockade and despite the fact that those Russians who wished to overthrow them had all the opportunities in the world to rally to the banner of Kolchak in Siberia, Denikin in the Southwest and Yudenitch about Petrograd. Instead of which, peasant revolts, arising from conscriptions, disaster, death and routs. The Soviet authority is still supreme and in a world which judges governments not by their methods but by their success in survival, the Soviet authority stands justified. Let him who is without sin cast the first stone.

The understandable interest of Jews everywhere in Russia did not abdicate with either the first or the second revolution but has, instead, become accentuated. The form of government which the Russians will ultimately adopt will have so powerful an effect on Jews in Russia as well as in the countries adjacent that we cannot dismiss the revolution as of a secondary importance. The Jews have suffered at the hands of all factions in Russia which exercised power and are likely to be found in the ranks of all these factions. The Bolsheviki slew many because they were members of the bourgeoisie and the Czarist bands slew many because they were Jews. In Poland the cry of "Bolsheviki" has served as the rallying cry of the anti-Semites against Jews whose other-worldly interests removed them from any possibility of interest in the mildest form of politics. That is why Jews must aim to understand what is happening in Russia, so that wherever his sympathies may lead him, he may understand.

But Mrs. Williams, the reviewer fears, will not help much toward an understanding. Her bias is too evident. To her a second revolution after that which led to the formation of the provisional government was altogether unnecessary. This book is merely a proof, though the author did not intend it as such, of the fact that the first Russian revolution was of the most superficial character. She calls the Cadets the radical party and in that characterization she records her incapacity to deal justly with those radicals, who, whatever their crimes and misdemeanors, carried through the real radical revolution.

She writes: "They (The Soviet) procrastinated for weeks . . . so slightly conscious were they of their ties with the Russian State." But there was no Russian State except that which the people desired to make and the Soviets had as clear a right to demand the intensification of the revolution as the Committee of the Duma had in desiring it not to go beyond its bourgeois political character. The abdication of the Czar was a negative move; the parties of the left, led by the Maximalists, sought to make it positive. Whether the cost at which they achieved their purpose was not too much and the value of their achievement, are things which the historian of the future will have to decide—not the biased and bitter contemporary.

But whom will Mrs. Williams blame if the Petrograd Soviet exercised such greater power than did the Executive Committee of Prince Lvoff. If she will answer that the parties of the left controlled because they were demagogues and the masses ignorant, the answer is that Czarism had made the