The Maccabaean
in the Vienna Congress there are a number of persons whose Zionist bona fides are beyond question, but there are also a large number of persons whose Zionism was of that superficial character which is attributed to American Zionism generally, who went to the Congress because they wanted the honor, or out of curiosity. It is noteworthy that out of all the thirty-one American names in the roster of the Vienna Congress only three recur in the roster of the recent Conference, although the latter list contains the names of many who attended previous congresses, including the first.
Meanwhile, and for reasons that are familiar, America has attained the premier position in the movement. Eighty per cent of all the money raised for Palestine, and for the movement, during the preceding year was raised in the United States. From a weakling with a strength (generously estimated) of 12,000, it had grown to a giant with an enrolled membership of over 150,000. The American delegation was composed entirely of conscious Zionists, with a deep understanding of the fundamentals and imponderabilea of the movement, and included many whose names in this country are as synonymous with Zionism as the names of some of the European leaders are synonymous with Zionism over there. But nothing dies so hard as preconceptions and prejudices, and the European delegates to the Conference could not be persuaded as to the true character of the present delegation.
The normality of the American delegation, its freedom from the mental complications and confusions that have beset Europe, counted against it. This was defined as a cold-bloodedness, as a lack of enthusiasm, a lack of zeal for the cause. Its unwillingness to involve itself in the various "wendungen" and its resolute adherence to a purely Palestinian program was cited as proof of its Zionist superficiality—that its Zionism was merely a manifestation of benevolence, of a philanthropic desire to relieve the misery of European Jewry. Its recently acquired strength, numerically and financially, was recognized, but with mixed emotions, in which the fear that because of its financial strength it would demand a preferred position in the movement predominated. Its demand that the Conference deal only with concrete plans, its insistence that nothing should be considered that could not stand the acid-tests of life and the needs of Palestine, that talk for the sake of talk and theorizing for the sake of the theory, should be dispensed with was called "bossing the show"; its demand that efficiency be introduced in the Palestine operation and in the conduct of the organization was denominated "dollar dictatorship."
When, finally, the American proposals were laid before the Conference, they were received with dismay and with hostility. The American proposals were unquestionably revolutionary. They broke with many Zionist traditions, they looked to the removal from their present posts of men who were regarded by themselves and their enthusiasts as sacrosanct, and they paid no heed to the "welt anschauungen" and "wendungen" of the existing factions and fractions in the process of birth within the movement. Nor did they include any consideration for the "gegenwarts arbeit," which, in the eyes of so many European Zionists, has assumed the paramount position in the operations of the movement. To sum these plans up tersely: they provided that all Zionist efforts be directed toward the development of Palestine as the National Jewish Homeland; that the organization be so conducted as to produce the maximum
effort and maximum support for this development; and that the whole operation be conducted efficiently and by men whose very names would be a guarantee that the operation would be so conducted. So far, so good. But the plan, as originally broached, provided that as some of the men best qualified for the great tasks ahead were not within the rank and file of the organization, the Conference should agree to go outside of Zionist ranks for these men. Some of the men had already been found, and though, for the most part, they were avowed Zionists, one or two were not, though they had evinced a sincere desire to co-operate with the Zionists in their endeavors to establish the Jewish National Home in Palestine.
Taking the various elements of the Conference into consideration, it is easy to understand why the revolutionary character of the American proposals could not do otherwise than to create dismay and arouse hostility. Proposed by any other than the American delegation it could not have lived for a moment; and even if proposed by the American delegation without the prestige of its leadership, and the eagerness of the whole Conference to win the prestige of the American leadership for the whole movement, it would have been shown scant courtesy. The personality of the author of the plan, and the significance of that personality in terms of world-Zionism, compelled the serious reception which it was accorded. But the traditions of the movement both as to methods and personalities were rallied for the strong fight that was waged against the American proposals.
* * *
Since the impression seems to have been created that the American delegation suffered defeat, it is necessary to dispel that impression. It is very true that the record will show that on this or the other resolution the Americans were outvoted; that at times the tide ran absolutely against them. However, when the Conference is summed up, it is quite apparent that the Americans came out victorious. Their plan, the storm-center of the Conference, had to yield, in some of its details, to the traditions of the movement. But in its essentials, it prevailed. Under certain conditions, which the American delegation could not meet, the plan would have been adopted in its entirety. At any rate, the justice of the demand for "efficiency" was recognized in the end, and, if the Americans had so chosen, they could have taken over complete control of the movement. But this was beyond the wish of the Americans. They wished only their rightful place in the movement; the privilege of fighting shoulder-to-shoulder with Zionists the world over for the opportunity vouchsafed to us and our worthiness to the Jewish people."
The Zionists of Europe misunderstood the Zionists of America; the Zionists of America misunderstood the Zionists of Europe. Certainly, the differences of opinion at the Conference were enough to have wrecked a score of other conferences, at which the same differences might have existed. But they were not strong enough to wreck the Zionist Conference. Sober second thought, the return of normal conditions in Europe, the new impulse which the movement will receive from the introduction of "American efficiency," the rapid strides of the Palestinian development, will bring about a closer accord, a better understanding, a keener co-operation. On the solid foundation of the Basle program all Zionists are one, and will remain one.
