The Maccabaean
gress. These were the men who had been either the “politicals” or the “practicals” of the early congresses, and who have won an undying fame in the annals of the movement. For them Zionist “tradition” has a tremendous significance, and albeit they may find themselves in opposition to one another, they are united by a strong mutual affection—the kind of affection that can come only from long association and mutual striving and mutual sacrifice for a common ideal. They are men whom every Zionist Joves. Their work during the long years of Zionist striving has resulted in the development of that Jewish self-consciousness which is the foundation-stone upon which the national edifice is reared. Their rare singleness of purpose, the extraordinary selflessness of so many of them, their devotion to the great Jewish ideal during all of the years, has been an inspiration to thousands who will hold their names in everlasting gratitude. Their names are graven deep in countless Jewish hearts and will be writ in letters of gold in the records of the Homeland which they have made possible. Their names are names that Zionists have conjured with and some of them have already, in parts of Europe, if nowhere else, become legendary, though the bearers of the names are still in the land of the living. One may go further and say that some of these names are almost synonymous with the effort to win Palestine for the Jewish people.
In the success which the movement has achieved, in all of the events of the past twenty-four years, and even longer, if we go back to the days of the Chovevi-Zion, have led, logically, to San Remo, each has played his part. Some of them, like the German contingent, have even played heroic parts. And San Remo is their reward.
They came to the Conference, some modestly, some self-assertively, each according to his own human characteristics, but all with the consciousness of San Remo and the share they had in San Remo. They came with the consciousness of leadership, even those who in the long ago were the sharpest critics of Herzlianism, even those who had led the fight of the “practicals” against the “politicals.” They came also with the feeling that having maintained the movement intact while every other structure of civilization had been carried down in the general crash of Europe, they were now called upon to carry the movement forward along its second, along its realistic phase. Because they had been the successful propagandists, because they had been the successful diplomats of the first phase, they had the feeling that they were, beyond the peradventure of a doubt, the ablest administrators and executives and financiers of the new Palestine. The hegemony must not pass from their hands, they felt; and, be it said to their honor, that they felt this, not out of vanity, for the most part, but out of their zeal for the great purpose to which they had dedicated their lives.
It is understandable, therefore, why they resented criticism, though they made a show of courting it, of either themselves or of any or all of their comrades of the years of storm and stress. They themselves might criticise one another; that, indeed, had been their wont in the congresses of that long-time ago. But criticism was their monopoly and must not be indulged in by the newcomers, even such criticism as they were willing to concede, privately, was warranted by the circumstances.
That mutual affection (to which there was one marked exception which had better not be discussed), that adherence to the traditions of the movement and its congresses, added to the difficulties of the complex and was the underlying
motive of some strange alignments of the veterans sometimes with the "right" and sometimes with the "left"—the Mizrachi and the Poale Zion—sometimes with both against the "center," the generality of the delegates.
Into this bewildering heterogeneity came a new force— the Americans.
In considering the position of the American delegation at the Conference several factors have to be considered. One is the general European attitude toward America, and secondly the position of American Zionism before the war.
Europe has no love for America. America is regarded as the land of opportunity, to be sure, but its people are denied the possession of any idealism. The average European regards the average American as a “dollar-chaser” and arrogant in the degree of his success in overtaking the dollar. During recent years the American has been conceded philanthropic instincts, but even this concession has carried with it the imputation that his philanthropy, actuated by a superficial sentimentality, is tainted by an overweening desire to dictate to the whole world. The European Jew shares the opinion of Americans that is held by all Europeans. He has always denied to his American brother the possession of scholarship, of understanding of the depths of Jewish spirituality. His benevolence has always been regarded as a duty entitling him to no credit and imperfectly performed. The average European Zionist. is prone to regard American Zionism as superficial, as merely another form of philanthropy. as an expression of. a liehtlv-felt sentimentality.
The pre-war weakness of American Zionism and the light regard, one is tempted to say the contempt, in which it was held then is another factor. At the time of the Vienna Congress the Zionists of America did, in truth, play a very insignificant röle in the development of the movement. The platitudinous character of the oflicial communications from the leaders to the American Zionist conventions indicates how little they expected, or hoped for, from this country. They sent no messages, in the real meaning of the word, because they had the feeling that real messages would elicit no response. So they sent words of encouragement and exhortation. At the time of the Vienna Congress the American Federation counted approximately 5,000 memb£rs. Counting the membership of the Order Knights of Zion (the Western group) and the Order B’nai Zion, the strength of the movement in this country approximated in the neighborhood of 12,000. Adding the membership of the Poale Zion would not appreciably increase that number. The total shekel collection for the preceding year was #3,247.25, and this includes many 25-cent pieces collected rather promiscuously. The total income of the Federation of American Zionists (the National Fund not included) was $17,794, including a special collection for a “Central Fund” raised through the stimulus of the presence in this country of Nahum Sokolow. The American Convention was participated in by delegates from less than ninety societies, with a membership ranging from eighteen to one hundred, but averaging about twenty-five. Considering these facts, it is easy to understand why the European leaders, and the rank and file, held American Zionism in such disesteem.
The records of the Vienna Congress show that it was attended by thirty-one American delegates; that is, by persons who actually came to the Congress from America and not including the Europeans to whom American mandates had been given. In the list of Americans participating
