The Maccabaean
contiguous areas are available. This would be primarily the task of the Zionist Organization. In the areas where Jewish colonies already exist, further operations will be carried on by private initiative as well as by Jewish agencies of the type of I. C. A. On the other hand, in the north (Galilee), we must concentrate on only industrial penetration, which will thus cement the relationship between the two peoples for the everlasting good of the country as a whole. He further points out that we must seek and win the good-will of the Arabs, both of those living in Palestine and of those in the neighboring countries. They must be raised to our own level, in order to make living with them possible. He also lays particular stress on the necessity of inviting the co-operation of elements outside the Zionist Organization and declares that we shall welcome the co-operation of any corporation or individual, who, without accepting our philosophy, desires to work in Palestine."
In conclusion he mentions those who have fallen in the defense of Palestine and the audience rises to its feet. He demands, amid the clamorous approval of the delegates, the liberation of Jabotinsky, the maintenance of the Jewish regiment in Palestine "as we are anxious to participate in the defense of our National Home, and concludes with the words: "Three thousand years of the past and countless generations look down upon us whether we are up to our task."
Mr. M. M. Ussishkin, who spoke in Hebrew, was a third speaker at the opening session. As the head of the Zionist Commission in Palestine, he conveyed the sentiments of Palestinian Jewry at this decisive hour. All the Palestinian Jews, he said, are eagerly awaiting the moment when the great Jewish masses will begin coming to settle the land. He also pointed out that, in spite of prohibited immigration, due to military occupation, not less than three thousand Jews managed to cross the barrier, thus demonstrating once more the anxiety of the Jewish people and internal friction. Mr. Ussishkin is of opinion that this is a condition primarily due to lack of useful occupation. "Give the Palestinian Jews an opportunity to work and all strife will end."
Dr. Bodenheimer, chairman of the Senioren Convent (a new name for the old Permanenz Auschuss, which is the Committee on Rules, on Resolutions and on Nominations, all rolled in one), then announced that his committee nominated Justice Louis D. Brandeis as Chairman of the Conference; Dr. Max Nordau, as Honorary Chairman and Mr. M. M. Ussishkin as First Vice Chairman. Mr. Sokolow called for a vote and the nomination was ratified by acclamation. During the second session the following were elected as additional vice chairmen: Lord Rothschild (England), H. Farbstein (Mizrachi, Poland). Dr. O. Thon (West Galicia), M. Aleinioff (Russia and Caucasus), W. Temkin (South Russia), David Yellin (Palestine), Dr. A. Klee (Austria), Dr. Robinson (Lithuania) and Louis Lipsky (U. S. A.).
REPORTS AND PLANS
According to the official agenda, the first and second sessions were to be devoted to the "Report of the Executive on Policy and Work in Palestine." Only the first part, that relating to policy, was strictly adhered to by the speakers at the first session. Mr. Julius Simon and Mr. Naiditch, who spoke in the afternoon, did not really report. They submitted plans, instead. The delegates were elaborate and patient and heartily assented to a demand made from the floor that digests of these plans be prepared and submitted to the delegates for study before any discussion of their merits begin. On the other hand, some of the delegates became rather disgruntled at the scant information given by the executive regarding its past performances. Even the argument that the decision at San Remo and the appointment of Sir Herbert Samuels as the Commissioner, which close to Dr. Weizmann signifies the setting up of those elements who were sympathetic to keep the Administration to strict accountability for its "sins of commission and omission" in its Palestinian operations during the past two years. This critical attitude manifested itself
quite vehemently during the four following sessions, which were devoted to a general debate. And so it came about that the meagre reports of the executive were greatly amplified by the critics, and accrimonious discussion.
GL ill IVUS UISLUOSIVUFL, The speech made by Dr. Max Nordau at the beginning of the second session, immediately following the opening address of Justice Brandeis, was also in a large measure responsible for the belligerent attitude of the delegates. Dr. Nordau began by saying very emphatically that the Conference was not the Congress and should not arrogate to itself the power granted to the supreme authority of the Zionist movement. He admits that the delegates present are the representatives of the Zionist rank and file. Still, he believes that it is our duty to convene the Congress as soon as possible. He scorns the departure of some of the leaders from the political idea in Zionism and derides what he calls “diluted Zionism” and “mystical Zionism.” The idea of the Jewish State must remain the guiding principle of all our deliberations, of our plans and activities. “The adversaries of Herzl,” he exclaims, “must recognize now that we are a rolitical movement. We must learn to think in the terms of a nation.”
ae = ae ag hr ann vi Bike in and 7 in Di a a a Ta a a a I nF Zn ze To the American delegates at least, this attitude of Dr. Nordau was not entirely new. He had addressed them previously, at one of ıhe many preliminary meetings which the American Delegation had held prior to the formal opening of the Conference. It then became clearly manifest that the veteran leader was, as a whole, in disagreement with the policy of the present leaders because he believed this policy to be tame, ineffective and not calculated to bring about the ultimate aim of volitical Zionism—The Jewish State.
THE GENERAL DEBATE
The two sessions of Thursday and the day following were devoted entirely to what is known in continental procedure as a general debate. There is no resolution before the house. The speakers simply aim to voice their sentiments on the entire business which is likely to engage the attention of the Conference. The speakers, therefore, have a fairly wide range, which they use or abuse as the spirit moves them. Also, there is no quickly smothed attempt to introduce a resolution to the part of the European delegates. They simply refused to have a pet precedent abolished.
Ten minutes after the general debate was opened, Justice Brandeis announced that there were not less than forty-two speakers on the list. The debate lasted for two days. But it seems that a large majority of those who had desired to be heard, discovered that their thunders were stolen by the first speakers. The record of those who actually spoke reveals only the comparatively small number of fifteen.
In response to the clamor for a more detailed report on Palestine, Dr. Weizmann consented to open the general debate with a survey of the work done by the Zionist Commission. He admitted that from the point of view of constructive work the Commission accomplished very little. The only exception was the work in the field of education and even this was not complete. However, there were a number of extenuating circumstances, such as the military regime which frustrated any attempt of the Commission to undertake constructive labors. Also, “the Jews there suffered from hypertrophy and took themselves far too seriously.” He therefore concludes that the want of production was not the fault of the Zionist Commission but was due to circumstances over which the Zionist Administration had no control.
Out of a mass of rhetoric, the following brief statements have been selected as characteristic of the general trend of thought pervading the debate:
The Zionist Commission did nothing to prevent the emigration from Palestine of many Jews.
Students of the schools under the control of the Vaad Hachimuch should not be permitted to desecrate the Sabbath.
The Jews of Palestine, if left to themselves would have been quite capable of arranging matters with the British Administration. But the Zionist Commission came, and instead of acting