The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXIV, No. 2 · August 1920
54printed page
scan 25 of 35

The Maccabaean

where honest men are not afraid to think and say things that are transparently true."

The Jew-baiting organ, The Englishman, finds ready consolation in its own interpretation of Sir Samuel's report. It finds that "British Judaism is disappointed" with the report, because "the pogroms advertised by the Zionist Organization as including the massacre of thousands of Jews consist of the death of some three hundred, the vast majority of which properly come under the heading of military executions permissible under international law, and the rest of the casualties resulting from street fighting between Jewish profiteers and Haller's soldiers, all of whom were recruited outside Poland." For those Jews, perhaps, whose killing was not "permissible under international law," this anti-Semitic organ offers the excuse that they were killed "not as Jews but as Bolshevists. The fact that the Jews are pro-Bolshevist in their sympathies, and deliberately foment the Bolshevist agitation, is the mainspring of the anti-Jewish feeling rife among the Poles."

he dr aaa > a ar = ie Sr rn ze The White Paper includes, in addition to Sir Stuart Samuel’s report, a supplementary report by Capt. Peter Wright, a member of the Mission, and a review by Sir Horace Rumbold, the British Minister at Warsaw. The Jewish Times of London condemns Capt. Wright’s report as anti-Semitic, while the Jewish Chronicle thinks that “Capt. Wright shows as little sympathy with as knowledge of the Jews. His views are prejudiced and offensive, and he appears to know very little of the Jewish religion of which he speaks with such assurance and glibness.” Yet even Capt. Wright does not deny or palliate one single fact of the Commission’s report. Sir Stuart himself savs of his report:

"I have striven to detail and discuss the distressing incidents under investigation with a restraint befitting the official mission with which I have had the honor to be entrusted. I feel bound, however, to place on record the pain and horror with which I listened to the eye-witnesses of these callous and bloodthirsty crimes by which so many innocent and harmless people were done to death.

"I consider that the bare recital of these terrible events is enough to reveal how insecure are Jewish life and property in Poland, and how easily—if the evil causes at work are not speedily removed—excesses may break out again, possibly upon a far more serious scale."

That the evil causes of which Sir Stuart Samuel speaks have not yet been removed, is evident from the manner in which anti-Semitism, fostered by the Polish press, is still rampant throughout Poland. Cables bring daily reports of fresh excesses upon the Jewish population by the retreating Polish armies. Jewish newspapers are being closed, Jewish communal leaders are being arrested on ridiculous charges, and assaults upon Jews at railroad stations have become a daily occurrence.

The London Zionist Conference

The attention of World Jewry has for the last few weeks been directed to London where Zionists met in International Conference for the first time since the Zionist Congress of 1911. The Conference was so numerous and representative that in the opinion of Dr. Weizmann it deserved to be regarded as a Zionist Congress. In view of the San Remo decision the conference was faced with the duties and responsibilities of a Congress; indeed, as Dr. Weizmann put it, "such duties and such responsibilities as no Zionist Congress has had to deal with up till now."

This was practically the first international gathering of

Fifty-Four

Zionists where the American delegation by reason of its number and the strength it represented, was a formidable element in the Conference. Its prestige was due first to the important position which the American Zionists had attained during the war, and secondly to the presence of Justice Louis D. Brandeis, who was elected President of the Congress. The New York Globe thinks that by the selection of Mr. Brandeis as president, the Zionist Organization gained immensely, and says editorially:

“Brandeis is one of the ablest men in public life in the United States, and his leadership is a factor that may easily convert a dificult and doubtful venture into a magnificent success. Out of all the high hopes and rosy dreams of international co-operation that were ours during the war this building of a new Canaan is about all we have left. The League of Nations may function well in time, but our own aloof position has not only crippled it for the present but will also take the keen edge off our pleasure in future participation. Zion, we must recognize, is the one humanitarian aim toward which all great nations are contributing. From it may come a powerful state to dispute for the commerce of the Mediterranean, or, if matters go less propitiously, a mere house of refuge for the most oppressed people of earth. Either is worth having.”

Considerable speculation was current among American Zionists as to the part the American delegation would play at the Conference. Although the Conference is closed, there is as yet no complete story of the proceedings of the Conference and judging by the meagre cable dispatches in the Yiddish newspapers it is evident that the correspondents were not impressed with the rôle of the American delegation. The latter seemed to be mistrusted by the European delegations. In fact, Rabbi Silver, a member of the American delegation, openly complained on the floor of the Conference that proposals brought forth by the Americans were voted down simply because they came from Americans.

The proposal of Justice Brandeis with regard to the future administration of the Zionist Organization evoked the opposition of practically the entire Jewish press. The Jewish Daily News cannot understand "why a Supreme Court justice of a democratic republic, would suggest the establishment of a dictatorial council of three to have unchecked authority in all matters of a Jewish national character." It does profess to understand Weizmann's opposition to the plan, for

"Weizmann is far more familiar with the psychology of the Jewish masses than Mr. Brandeis. Weizmann is a child of the people and has throughout his life maintained an intimate contact with Jewish needs and aspirations. Weizmann knows that the Jewish people are the most democratic on earth and detest nothing quite so much as tyranny and dictation. Weizmann also knows how entirely lacking we are in leading men and forceful personalities to whom we might entrust Israel's future destiny. He does not consider himself even equal to the task of bearing responsibility for the entire Jewish people at this great moment, although there can be no doubt that he has accomplished more than was deemed possible."

The report that Justice Brandeis means to put Mr. Flexner on the committee in his place, is particularly distasteful to the Jewish Daily News. "Dr. Flexner," it says, "is as a Zionist totally unknown to us, although we appear to be familiar with all leading Zionists and Jews generally who take any sort of an interest in Jewish affairs, not only in this country, but also abroad. Perhaps Dr. Flexner is a newly-arisen Jewish Napoleon in the discovery of whom Mr. Brandeis was fortunate enough to have been the first and only one."

August, 1920