The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXIV, No. 2 · August 1920
53printed page
scan 24 of 35

Gleanings and Echoes of the Press

Sir Stuart Samuel's Report on Poland—The London Zionist Conference—The Zionist Demonstration—Palestine Discussed in British Parliment—Anti-Semitism in the British Press—Two Jewish Martyrs

AFTER a long delay, explained by the intention of the British Government to submit it first for consideration by the League of Nations, the report of Sir Stuart Samuel's Mission to Poland, printed elsewhere in this issue, was at last published. News of the publication of this report reached this country by cable to the Jewish Correspondence Bureau early in July, and the full report arrived here about the 22d of the month. Important as were the revelations made in the report of the ill-treatment of Jews in Poland, the American press found it unnecessary to pay more than scant attention to it. Attention is directed to this "strange silence" in a letter published in The Nation and The Freeman, where the writer wonders whether "the Associated Press, the United Press, and the other organs of information had missed the report, or did they, on account of the nature and character of the report, deliberately choose to close their eyes and ears and pass it by in silence."

The New York Times, the publisher of which is Adolph Ochs, a Jew, did find room, however, to publish a denial of any pogroms in Poland by Prince Lubomirsky, the Polish Minister to Washington. For Sir Stuart Samuel's indictment of Poland it had no room. The Day rendered, therefore a distinct public service by inserting in the Times the entire report of Sir Stuart as an advertisement, at a cost to the former of several thousand dollars.

The Times found room also to devote several pages to an article on “Imperialism in Reborn Poland,” in which the writer, Mr. Rupert Hughes, proclaims the virtues of Poland, and also takes occasion for demanding an apology from the Jews of America for abusing Poland. Says Mr.‘ Hughes:

“The charge of imperialism has served at least to give us a brief respite from the anti-Polish propaganda of certain Jews who accused Poland of butchering Jews by the thousand.

“Has everybody forgotten the procession in New York and in other cities where mourning was worn and dirges were sung for the slaughtered multitudes of the Polish pogroms? Has any one apologized to Poland for accusing her of rivaling Turkey in Armenia? I have not seen the apologies, though many eminent Americans exploded a host of lofty eloquence against Poland on behalf of civilization and in protest against the thousands of Jewish slain.

“If.there had been any truth in the charge the eloquence would have been honorable. But an apology would be still more honorable now that the commissions have reported that the thousands of victims are reduced to 285 put to death by one oflicer who lost his head in a captured city. Ambassador Hugh Gibson branded the charges as lies, and Ambassador Morgenthau, himself a Jew, who visited Poland and investigated, gave the quietus to the venomous campaign of slander. The respectable Jewish majority incurs much undeserved hatred because of the vicious activity of a few.”

Perhaps Mr. Hughes will ask Sir Stuart Samuel to apologize for telling the truth about Poland. It is not at all like the report of Ambassador Morgenthau, who "gave the quietus to the venomous campaign of slander." The Jewish Daily News recalls Mr. Morgenthau's report and says:

"Mr. Samuel's report is not colored. It is not a 'diplomatic' document, as was Morgenthau's. It does not attempt to weaken or to smoothen the dreary facts. Samuel's report is pure truth. He calls

August, 1920

everything by its right name. Pogroms are to him 'pogroms,' and not 'excesses,' as they were to Morgenthau."

Sir Stuart Samuel and his Mission spent three months in Poland, arriving there on September 18, 1919, and visited the cities of Warsaw, Cracow, Lodz, Vilna, Lemberg, Lida, Pinsk and a number of smaller towns. He went to Poland, Mr. Samuel says, “to examine the specific charges that have been brought against the Poles of having ill-treated the Jewish population of their country, including any fresh cases of ill-treatment tkat might be brought to my notice whilset mw missinn lasted .”

ee ei At the outset of his report, Sir Stuart Samuel makes an important distinction between “pogroms,” as understood in Poland, and the same word as understood in England or America. In Poland, he says, a “pogrom” is understoöd to be an excess against a certain section of the population, but in England, owing to the experience of previous outbreaks in Russia, the word “pogrom” has become associated with excesses organized by the Government against a portion of the population. The conclusion reached by Mr. Samuel was that the occurrences at Lemberg, Vilna, Lida and Pinsk came under the head of pogroms as understood in Eneland.

The report, finds the London Jewish Chronicle, “is a melancholy and distressing document, which no well-wisher of humanity can read without a feeling of pain and almost of despair.” It was not the number of Jews who were actually killed that is so appalling, but the “savage cruelty and the exquisite barbarism with which these wholesale outrages ‘were perpetrated.” The Chronicle is gravely concerned over the “abnormal and intolerable position of the Jews today,” as indicated by the tendency of Poland’s defenders to point to the fact that even worse pogroms occurred in Ukraine. It sounds this warning:

“Jews farther West may think this is a matter remote and subordinate. Let them reflect that the Polish Jews settled for a thousand years in the land were once as happy as they. They were so intensely patriotic, they so thrilled with Polish feeling from the crown of their heads to the sole of their feet that their loyalty to Poland passed into proverb, and they were as secure in their own view as the Jews of any modern state. Not for nothing was Poland called the Paradise of the Jews. Yet they are to-day condemned, pariahs of the country, the sport of Polish blackguards and criminals, the target for bitter venom and merciless hate of which the Pole is so abundantiy capable. We cannot, knowing these things, fail to ask ourselves where next the ancient schmerz will begin to ache, where next the roseate dream will be blurred, and how a semblance of sanity and normality can be accorded to a people which seems able to do everything but establish itself on settled, ' stable lines.” j

The Chronicle continues to say that the Polish problem is a world problem, and a matter for the conscience of the Christian people. It concludes by saying that

“if the Christian conscience cannot prevent the repetition of the Polish horrors, if it will not end the torture of the Jew, it must bear the responsibility and answer for the consequences in the tribunal

Fifty-Three