The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXIII, No. 4 · April 1920
154printed page
scan 36 of 40
Facsimile · scan 36 of 40
Scan of p. 154
Text · transcribed from the scan

The Maccabaean

he sensibly relegates to the foot of each page. There is a concluding chapter on the Possibilities of Palestine, discussing the much-mooted question of boundaries with a scholarly fairness of presentation which may well serve as a pattern to the rasher and less-informed dii minorum gentium among both Gentile and Jewish publicists. To sum up, Dr. Gordon's volume is the only one of its kind which readers will be at all likely to wish longer. Both author and publisher are to be congratulated upon this timely contribution to the Zionist literature of English-speaking Jewries. The illustrations [not all of them well done and many rather blurred in the process of reproduction] are almost superrogatory in view of the picture-getting strength of Dr. Gordon's descriptive prose.

Tabular Views of Universal History

One of the many senseless and bewildering public-school clichés engraven upon the minds of American and European children is the notion that the history of nations is a series of successions, that Greece, for instance, "followed" Egypt, Rome "followed" Greece, and so on. Through stupid methods of teaching, the adolescent brain receives the impression —a lasting one, in most instances—that the historical process consists chiefly in a mysterious appearance and disappearance of nations from the map of human culture—an oversimplification of the concept that some national culture or other was the predominant one, to a varying extent, at each historical epoch. In every retrospect upon history, the average public-school mind becomes in after-life a single-track mind, like that of a certain illustrious statesman. Say to an average American "1860" and you have pressed down, on the keyboard of his mind; a single-note key marking "Secession and Civil War." Say "1860" to a man of comprehensive culture, and you have struck, not a single note but a chord: he will remember, not only the Civil War but Garibaldi's raid, the second Chinese War, the Pope versus the Italian nation, the rebirth of Liberalism on the European Continent, the debut of Darwinism in England—in short, a panorama of human struggles instead of an isolated main-event. One out of every hundred American adults may possibly possess an associative mind of that order.

To help the other ninety-nine to a more comprehensive outlook upon history, there appeared the other day a new edition of an old American classic, viz, “Tabular Views of Universal History. A Series of Chronological Tables Presenting, in Parallel Columns, a Record of the More Noteworthy Events in the History of the World from the Earliest Times to the Present Day, together with an Alphabetical Index of Subjects. Compiled by George Palmer Putnam, A.M., and Continued to Date under the Editorial Supervision of George Haven Putnam, Litt.D., Peace Conference Edition, Revised and Enlarged, with Historical Chart, 9 Maps in Color, and Genealogical Tables, Putnam.” This volume presents a universal history recorded in synchronous parallel columns showing what characters and events of first-rate historical consequence were contemporaneous with each other. As a classical volume of reference and a corrective to the single-track notion of historical sequences this eminently useful new edition remains unsurpassed amonze contemporary publications.

War and Post-War Books

Not the least of the revolutions caused by the World War is the expansion of the provincial American mind. The breaches laid into its confining walls are getting wider and wider, with first-rate books on foreign topics serving for battering rams. Among them we recommend: "India and the Future," by William Archer; 326 pp. Alfred A. Knopf, New York.

This book is the result of a comprehensive survey of Indian conditions. Setting out with an unprejudiced mind, the author gradually formed a very strong opinion that the relations between Great Britain and India must end in a self-governing India, capable of taking her place on terms of equality among the great nations of the earth. At the same time he argues, in a soberly realistic vein, that British rule cannot be dispensed with in the immediate future. The book is a treasure-trove of Indian facts and forecasts, and its beautiful outward appearance is worthy of the contents.

One Hundred Fifty-Four

A highly important part of the War-History of European Labor, overshadowed by the spectacular German and Russian working-class revolutions, is most ably dealt with in Kellog's and Gleason's "British Labor and the War." (Boni & Liveright, New York.) In all European history, we have had in England forecasts of tremendous changes that were coming on the Continent. The English reformation preceded the continental reformation; the English swing to parliamentary government preceded the political revolution on the Continent. For the most part Englishmen did not go through anything like the travail and bitterness which the continental people experienced in running the same course. They did not come out at the same point; but they showed the trend and they showed it in advance. Even so, what has been going forward among the wage-earning population of the British isles has foreshadowed changes which will affect and condition the whole fabric western civilization. A vast folk-movement like the British radical labor-movement cannot be compressed into the channel of single-track reforms. The limited social insights that created, in our country, such movements as the prohibition or the single-tax propaganda are not characteristic of its mental essence. The English labor movement of our days is the expression at a hundred points of great tidal impulses in the life of the nation. The book of Messrs. Kellogg and Gleason serves American readers by telling of a labor-program that will play a big part in the period of reconstruction.

"The Awakening of Asia," by H. M. Hyndman (Boni & Liveright) is a book attuned to the following conclusion in the author's own words\u2014a conclusion supported by lucid, scholarly argument:

"Asia is already far from being the continent which was fair game for adventurous European experiments. New conditions must be dealt with by a new policy.

“Who shall say that the frank abandonment of the fallacious policy of Imperialism will not greatly benefit the countries which boldly enter upon this honorable course? The possession of India has been a curse to England, alike in her domestic and foreign affairs. De mocracy at home has greatly suffered by the maintenance of despotism abroad. The two can never be harmonized nor kept simultaneously in being without danger to the popular cause. The fear of what might happen to the English in India has frequently perverted the action of British policy. In economics also, the tribute from Hindustan, which must be paid, no matter at what price, in salable commodities, has done mischief to the producers of Great Britain as well as to the rvots of India.

"So with France and her Asiatic possessions. What have the French peasants, what has the French bourgeoisie to gain, from any point of view, by retaining provinces that must be defended at the cost of their blood and treasure, and must introduce a dangerous military sentiment into the management of their affairs?

“Happily, the same views as to the madness of modern warfare which are now being forced upon the rest of the world are also making way with Asiatic statesmen. They, too, see that friendly co-operation for common advantage might be of far greater benefit to all than rivalry for power or competition for gain. Freedom of nationalities, equality of rights, respect for treaties and conventions, international arrangements for securing permanent peace are as important for Asia as for any other continent. But the responsibility for adopting them, should the Japanese democratic party prevail and India and China press their demands without violence, rests entirely with Europe. ... No student and no statesman would contend that such a wide policy of justice can be suddenly realized. Yet, if in the near future, public opinion in Europe and America were to endorse such a pro gram, and the nations interested would take the first steps toward its realization, much of the antagonism which is already manifesting itself in Asia might be removed... .. Past injuries cannot now be remedied. The most to hope for is, that in the Asiatic mind, they may be held to balance those Eastern attacks upon the West which belong to a past more remote.” Nr. Hyndman’s volume will espe cially interest the American reader, for he slıows how before ihe war we were the one Western nation trusted by the Chinese. His condemnation of the white man’s influence upon Far Eastern affairs has