The Maccabaean
British good-will toward the latter is based upon more solid considerations than the echoes of Scotch divinity in the heart of a kindly old ex-member of Mr. Lloyd George's cabinet.
While “Palestine” argues and wrestles with unreason in a spirit of calm confidence, other Anglo-Jewish press-organs, under the nervous strain of the eleventh hour, are "getting restive and glum-tempered. Thus the London Jewish Chronicle after setting forth our Palestinian claims and hopes, continues, in a spirit of pardonable exasperation over the reticence of both the Gentile and the Jewish Versailles. as follows in its issue of Februarv 13:
Frankly, we are not proud about the necessity for thus speaking at this moment. The Balfour Declaration was made more than two years ago, and long before now the world should have known its exact purport and the policy whereby it was to be made effectual. It is quite true that the final decision in regard to that policy would in any case rest with the Peace Conference which is only now approaching the subject. But England made the Declaration and upon her, primarily, the responsibility for formulating its policy rests, especially since she is also to be the Mandatory in Palestine. But there is another body upon whom the responsibility has rested for declaring its policy in relation to the Declaration; and that is, of course; the Zionist Organization. From the leaders of the Zionist Movement, however, we have even till now heard not a word of detail—not a word about the frame or form of the plan they suggest as adequate for the purpose in view. As late as last week-end, two leaders of the Movement made what were announced beforehand to be important declarations. Dr. Nordau pronounced an eloquent eulogy upon that splendid National Jew, the late Dr. Tschlenow; but he did not altogether confine himself to the immediate subject of his oration. He roamed, in his magnificent and interesting way, over a wide area of history, tracing for his hearers the genesis of the Zionist Movement. He showed the working within it of the two main streams—Chovevi Zionists and Political Zionists, and he assured us that these streams had now merged. But at this most alluring point in his remarks, the great orator was somewhat disappointing; for he did not tell us—varying the allegory— which of these two sorts of Zionists, in his ripe judgment, had performed the part of the tiger in the well-known Limerick, and which had played the röle of the man who took the fatal ride upon that animal. However, of more consequence is it to note that Dr. Nordau, speaking at the moment he did, said not one single word that could enlighten the public as to Zionist policy in relation to Palestine and its future in reference to the Balfour Declaration. We do not blame Dr. Nordau. He has always been loyal to the leaders of the Movement for the time being; and we have little doubt that he took his cue of reticence from them. .
During the month of February and the first week of March, the general press of Europe and America paid little attention, in the immature state of Conference dealings with Turkey, to the Palestinian angle of its deliberation. Five weeks, pregnant with potential history-making, passed, before this branch of the Near Eastern aspect gained serious newspaper-actuality. Once in the forezround of editorial discussion, the boundary-question gave rise to severe strictures upon Allied fumbling, funking, and secreting in the matter. In its issue of March 10, the New Republic (N. Y.) made the opening plea on the side of the well-informed and well-intentioned part of the American press:
There impends a decision involving the fate of Zionism. The Council of Prime Ministers is at the point of fixing the northern boundary which will mark the frontier between the zone of the British mandate for Palestine and the zone of the French mandate for Syria. Publicly all the Allies are committed to the complete establishment of the Jewish Home. Privately and actually they are caught once again in the snare of a secret treaty, which threatens to dismember the Jewish state and cause enduring friction in the Near East.
The secret treaty is known as the Sykes-Picot agreement. It was entered into while Tsarist Russia was still at war, and it provided for the arbitrary division of the Turkish Empire. Among these arbitrary divisions is a line marking the northern boundary of Palestine. It was drawn accidentally and ignorantly by two diplomatic agents who happened to be in Egypt at the time. One of them, Sir Mark Sykes, is said to have regretted it deeply just before his death. The line starts about four miles south of Acre and is drawn approximately straight east along the northern shore of Lake Tiberias. It was a line drawn by men who were parcelling out lands with a pencil on a map with comnlete irresnansibilitv as tn the ransermmenres.
What the Sykes-Picot line does is to divide Palestine from Northern Galilee, from the headwaters of the Jordan and Litani rivers. On the possession of these headwaters depends the economic future of Palestine. They are the water supply for irrigation and for fuel. The waters which descend from the crests of Hermon are the necessary engineering power for Palestine.e With them, once they are dammed and harnessed, Palestine which now supports about 700,000 can support on a conservative estimate 5,000,000. A territory that can support five million is a national home; a territory deprived of motive power, treeless and dry, is not a national home because it is not a national workshop. It is literally true, therefore, to say that unless Palestine controls the headwaters of the streams which pass through it, the Zionist hope and the Allied promise may be frustrated.
The territory immediately in dispute is the belt Iying between the Sykes-Picot line of the secret treaty and the watershed of Litani and Jordan. In that territory lie Jewish colonies, Lake Meron and the towns of Acre, Tyre and Safed. The French claim the belt. They claim it not only in defiance of the plainest dictates of economic geography, but in defiance also of any reasonable political settlement between Syria and Palestine. If they secure the Sykes-Picot line they will have instead of the natural boundary provided by mountain erests a perfectly meaningless boundary in the plains which they must hold against the inevitable resentment and agitation of the Jews.
Why do the French hold out for the secret treaty? Not for military reasons, because the Sykes-Picot line is absurd from the point of view of strategy. They hold out because they wish to weaken the British purchase on the Near East. That and nothing more than that lies at the bottom of the thing. They are working for what they call a balance of power, and under the spell of this ancient fallacy they have come to think that a contented and prosperous Jewry under British protection is less favorable to them than a frustrated and embittered Jewry convinced that French diplomacy, basing itself upon an ignoble secret treaty, has turned back the Jews when they were in sight of the Promised Land. That would be a poor calculation, and before France commits herself irretrievably she would do well to consider prayerfully just where the same sort of policy displayed from Belgium to Vladivostok has led her in the last eighteen months.
On March 12, the New York Tribune followed suit in an editorial headed "An Unmutilated Palestine":
The map of Palestine is being examined outside the Sunday schools. It relates to current news, and names appear in the dispatches that stir old memories.
The map, with its markings of sea, desert and mountain, shows not only what Palestine was, but why it was and what the new Palestine must be if it is to fulfill the great mission appointed to it these later days.
This integral region, wrecked and depopulated by 2,000 years of tyrannous misrule, the world now agrees should and can be restored by the scattered sons of its descendants, who react to a noble sentiment and who have the resources to make their dream come true.
The Holy Land must be irrigated. This is primary. Yet the sources of the Jordan and the Litany, whose waters are indispensable, are not included within the provisional boundaries of Palestine. This would seem to be by accident rather than design. When Great Britain and France, to provide against possible future wrangling, marked out their respective spheres of influence, the treaty commissioners, instead
