Gleanings and Echoes of the Press
Turkey, the Peace Conference, and the Syrian Interlude—Megillath Poland—Mr. Schiff's Conversion to Zionism Greeted in London
THE PALESTINIAN FRONTIER.—SIX WEEKS OF DISCUSSION AND SUSPENSE
A BOUT the middle of February the Peace Conference began to "talk Turkey" in good earnest, both in a direct and in a slangy sense, as appears from rumors of an intended partition of the larger part of Asia Minor between France, Italy and Greece. The negotiations are still proceeding behind barred doors—inevitably so, considering the multitude of tenacious disputes implied. While hollow sounds and rumors were, for six weeks, penetrating to the world beyond from the barred and double-locked gates of the Conference Rooms, the question: How about Palestine? loomed large upon the horizon of the Zionist and general press. It was felt, by all friends of the cause capable of lucid argument, that a hard, sustained, final effort must be made to convince the world of the necessity of granting to Eretz-Yisroel, under definite international sanctions, a frontier-delimitation that would not kill the new birth of the times in its cradle. Our British sister-organ "Palestine" began with its well-reasoned urgencies in its issue of February 14:
Even if it is impossible to effect the complete settlement of Palestine, as the first work of the London Conference, it should surely be possible, without prejudice to future claims, to begin the Conference by recognizing those parts of Palestine as within the British mandate which are indisputably the heritage of the Jews, and sanctioning within those regions the beginning of the work of political reconstruction. The questions of frontier delimitation towards the North and East might wait for settlement, but apart from these, there is a large area of Palestine in which the settlement is certain and is only being kept waiting for purely technical confirmation. This technical confirmation can, and should, be given at once.
A further distinction can be drawn between the actual delimitation of the frontier and the settlement of the principles that should govern that delimitation. We have repeatedly sought to lay down those principles, about which one would think there ought now to be no doubt. The first principle is that Palestine ought to have within itself the sources of economic power. The Conference has recognized this principle in the case of France by the provisions it has made for the tenure by France of the Sarre Basin, and for the tribute of coal to be paid by Germany in compensation for the coal mines she has destroyed in Northern France. Palestine has no coal, and the chief source of power for her economic development must be water. The Jordan will not suffice in itself to supply water power for a country even as small as Palestine to be economically prosperous. All the experts are in agreement that the river above all necessary to the economic future of Palestine is the Litani. The river, useless to Syria, which is on a righer level, is indispensable as a source of power to Palestine. The same principle by which France established her rights in the Sarre Valley holds with regard to the Litani, with this important difference that whereas the Sarre Valley is inhabited by an exclusively German population, the inhabitants of the middle Litani are not French, but are such as can become an integral part of the new Palestine. England supported France's demands in the Sarre Basin, in spite of the objection that its population was German, as a measure of economic justice to France. France, therefore, on her side is bound to support British claims to the middle Litani as a measure of economic justice to Palestine.
This elementary principle of justice established, the detailed delimitation of the frontier may wait, for it will give rise to no difficult
question of principle. With the northern frontier of Palestine giving access to the waters of the Litani, and sweeping round by Mount Hermon to Trans-Jordania, the Eastern frontier of Palestine is also in a sense determined and its delimitation in detail may wait.
On February 21, the same indefatigable British protagonist of Zionist argument reported progress—we know not on what authority:
The Peace Conference in London is now engaged in considering the northern frontier of Palestine. With the northern frontier is bound up also the eastern frontier. We have put the case in "Pales tine" for a proper northern and a proper eastern frontier very often. We have preached it ceaselessly and consistently since our first issue, and we shall continue to advocate it till the only just and enduring settlement is made. The northern frontier of Palestine must include those water sources which are vital to irrigation and power for Palestine —the waters of the Litani and the Jordan and so much of the snows of Mount Hermon as belong rightfully to Pales tine. The precise delimitation of the frontier may well be a matter for a boundary commission working on the spot, but the principles governing such a delimitation must be settled now, and are for the comprehension of every plain man. There is no national conflict here in issue. The territory which is required for Palestine does not belong to the Lebanon, and the territory to the east is peopled by Circassians, who clamor, as those who have investigated matters on the spot know, for inclusion in Palestine. There is no conflict of economic rights. The waters of the Litani, owing to the nature of the ground, can be made available usefully in Palestine only. The waters of the Jordan and the relevant portion of the snows of Hermon are as much Palestine's as of the Hills of Judea. Take away the waters of the Jordan and the Litani and the snows of Hermon from Palestine and give them to some other state, and you give that other state, not the power to enrich itself, but the power to impoverish and cripple Palestine. For a foreign state to hold those waters is for that state to have a strangle-hold on the economic life of Palestine.
With the day of actual enunciation of settlement principles drawing nearer, the realistic basis of the favor which Zionist claims find in British ears, becomes more and more apparent—a refreshing indication that we are done with sentimentalities and that Zionist aspirations, whatever stretch they may reach heavenward, are after all rooted in the solid earth of business-like considerations pondered now by the Great Powers in general and by Great Britain in particular. These business-like considerations show more clearly under the magnifying glass of Lord Rothermere's impracticable suggestion as reported in "Palestine" of March 6:
"Lord Rothermere urges that instead of Great Britain herself taking the responsibility and the charge of the Jewish Palestine, the country should be handed over forthwith to the Jewish people." On this exhilarating proposal, born evidently of the old-time myth of an enormously wealthy, clandestine Jewish freemasonry, our British sister-organ drily comments: "We somewhat doubt whether Lord Rothermere has allowed himself the time to examine all that is involved in this proposal," going on to show its hopeless Utopianism. The concept, however, apart from its impracticability, shows the British drift of mind as regards a Jewish Palestine. It is distinctly comforting to know that
