The Maccabaean
school of a broader Judaism and so to be fitted to bring their brethren into touch with the congregation of Israel. In New York, indeed, you may find nearly all these types, but there they are in the process of being de-Judaized. . . . Here they are being fused into a new Hebraic community. If New York is, as it has been described, a melting pot for the Jews, Jerusalem is a refiner's hearth which purifies even the dross. . . ."
In these chilly days of waiting, of anxious inquiries and oracular ambiguities, inspiring volumes like that of Mr. Norman Bentwich are doubly welcome. His chapters entitled "War and the Settlements" and "Future of the Land and People" will resolve many doubts, dispel many mists and vapors arising from impatient soulstates and stiffen the national resolution to work for the coming repatriation lest the march of events overtake us. J. F.
Gilbert Cannan’s Venture in Anti-Semitism
Pink Roses. By GILBERT CANNAN. 335 pp. George H. Doran.
More and more it is becoming a regrettable feature of British fiction that the despicable characters of the story are Jews. Especially of late is it the fashion to show Jewish profiteers growing fat on the war. Thus William J. Locke in his recent novel, "The House of Baltazar," paints as the one unsympathetic character in the narrative a mean-minded, ostentatious contractor, whose mother came from Posen and spoke Yiddish.
In the case of "Pink Roses" matters are even worse. Mr. Cannan is a British novelist of some repute, who started out in life as the secretary and later the imitator of James M. Barrie, who became involved in an unsavory scandal with that author's wife, later divorced, and whose numerous novels have steadily degenerated in quality. The present story is one of the war. Trevor Matthew, to his not very great dissatisfaction, cannot go to war. Instead he moons around London, and varies his career as an articled clerk in a solicitor's office by taking up with a young woman whom he meets in a café, and who does her best to teach him something of "life." At the close he gets tired of her and breaks off his acquaintance with typical manliness —he sends her a telegram.
As Trevor sits in the café with his "friend" Cora, a waiter brings her a note. It is from "a handsome Jew with a long, crooked nose and black eyes of an extraordinary brilliance" a few tables away. Trevor wants to know who he is. Cora vouchsafes the information that his name is José Ysnaga. "He wants me to go and play poker," she continues. "But he doesn't play straight. That nose of his can smell money a mile off." Then Trevor, whose own conscience is imperturbably at rest almost asks, "Why isn't he at the war?" But he answers himself with the reflection that "it takes more than a war to divert the Ysnagas of the world from their purposes."
Soon it develops that Ysnaga pretends that he was born in America to save himself from going into service, "though he's got Whitechapel written all over his ugly face. But he does know how to make money. He's got two factories out at Bow, and the Government owes him I don't know how many thousands. He was in prison when the war began."
Ysnaga plays a considerable part in the story, but there are other Jewish characters too. There is Sophina, for example. She is a "strange and exotic" little Jewish girl, who came of poor East End parents. She tells her sordid story of marriageless companionship with the revolutionary Finberg, who later abandons her, and becomes a fashionable and well-fed poet. Then there is the doctor, "a little French Jew with a strictly West End practice. He looked for the symptoms with which he was familiar, and not finding them was nonplussed. He knew nothing of the sickness of the soul, because he had long ago come to the conclusion that there was no such thing. He regarded human beings as greedy animals who were at the mercy of their appetites, and, like every other philosopher, found in the war the grand confirmation of his view. Again, there is Mr. Angel, "a thick-set humble Jew who could hardly speak English." He confides to Cora that the Government "has pay me already twice
for vat it does not owe me." He, too, has "an infallible nose for money."
This Mr. Angel retains some Jewish feeling, it seems. He tells Cora "vat I done for my patriotism. I offered a prize of two hundred pounds for de first Jewish V. C. in de British Navy." It is out of this offer that Mr. Cannan develops some of his most elaborate episodes. But before a claimant appears other things happen or are said. Mr. Angel's extravagance in food and in clothing, his bad manners, his kindness of heart, his inability to meet the eye of any interlocutor, his goodness to Trevor, his equal ignorance of the existence of Moses and of Lassalle, his general scoundrelism, his worship of eveningdress (with the accent on the first syllable), all are dwelt upon with about equal emphasis. Throughout much is said about Sophina, who turns into a "Russian" dancer, although "through her rather pretty foreign accent came the unmistakable thick Yiddish accent of Spital Square." But she is embittered and vindictive, always seeking the chance to get quits with the elusive Finberg. Trevor compliments one of the other characters because he is "the only man in that room besides myself who smelt the Jewess in Carline's Russian." Carline is the person to whom Sophina is—temporarily—attached.
Sophina is a fund of information to Mr. Cannan and his characters about Jews, however. She offers to tell what East End Jews "do to themselves to get out of it"—namely, conscription. Then comes Mr. Angel with the great news that his prize at last has found a claimant—and Trevor makes up his mind to give a party in honor of the first Jewish V. C. in the Navy. Trevor himself has the thought that the word "Jewish" in this connection "sounds so awkward. It never fits into any sentence, suggests the unmentionable, God knows why. Lassalle was a Jew, and so was Karl Marx." At the party Sophina arouses the jealousy of Cora, to whom she appears "the pushing little Jewess, too clever by half for any Christian woman." But Sophina dances "with a Jewish gusto which might well pass for Russian barbarism." She is doing this just at the moment when Mr. Angel and Mr. Ysnaga arrive accompanied by "the first Jewish V. C. in the uniform of a lieutenant R. N. V. R." The young man is beginning to tell the story of how he won the V. C. when "through the crowded room, almost in one bound," comes Sophina.
"Finberg! You dirty sneak!" she yells. With one hand, records Mr. Cannan, "she seized him by the collar and tore it open and wrenched off his black tie, and with the other she pulled his hair and shook his head until it seemed it must surely part from his body." When he manages to release himself Finberg is arrested as a deserter from the army, and Sophina sums him up as "a dirty swindling Yid who crawled out of the East End to write poetry."
To judge from the apparently large part played by the small number of Jews in England, one does not blame Trevor's mother when she insists, a little paradoxically, on being "English . . . We've had enough of being British. It means nothing —just Jews and money and patent medicines and Sunlight Soap."
No one would conclude from Mr. Cannan’s picture of Jews in Great Britain today that many Jews (out of all proportion to their numerical strength) volunteered during the early days of the war in England; that in the United States there was a greater percentage of Jews in the fighting divisions than of Gentiles; that Israel Schmulevitch and at least four others were actually awarded the Victoria Cross, and that many hundreds of others received other British decorations; that a Jew was commander-in-chief of the wonderfully brave Australian forces; that when the Americans entered the war, Russian Jews and the descendants of Russian Jews, as well as Jews from other lands, proved on the field of battle that they deserved the gift of freedom.