The Maccabaean
conversations have not satisfied Polish journalists and politicians. Morgenthau has not helped but preached, and he has not even called the oppressors to account. On the contrary, he has been known to say things which were very far from being admonitions. At the same time, he preached morality to the Jews, justified past events, and opposed the Jews and their demands. The Jews and he grew continually colder towards each other. Morgenthau had no personal inclination towards national demands. When he came here he simply did not understand our national demands. If the Peace Treaty signed by the Poles had not included a clause protecting the rights of national minorities, Morgenthau would certainly not have asked for hie nratertinn.
This opinion is not to be found only in the Zionist Press. The Moment, for instance, the organ of the Democratic Party, relates the following occurrence: Morgenthau declared in the presence of Polish governmental authorities that he considered the dismissal of Jewish oflicers on account of their acknowledgment of Jewish nationality absolutely justified. The Poles could suffer no oflicers except such as acknowledge themselves to belong to the Polish people. When asked by representatives of the nationalist Jews who were present whether nationalist Jews should only serve as common soldiers, Morgenthau answered “Yes.” The Moment criticises this statement severely, and says that we must assume that Morgenthau could only have said such things in agreement with the leading statesmen of the Entente. But if this is so, it should be openly declared that the Jews cannot acclaim even equal citizenship in Poland. ‘And finally, the Haint quotes a remark made by Morgenthau to the effect that the Jews must make advances towards the Poles, and declares this to be heartrending in view of the events in Vilna. Pinsk. Lida. and Lemberg.
"SIR SCHLOIME" THREATENED
If Mr. Morgenthau has made himself persona non grata, for good and sufhicient reasons, to the Jews of Poland, his fellow-commissioner, Sir Stuart Samuels, has earned the more honorable distinction of being persona non grata to the Polish anti-Semites, some of whom have the audacity to threaten him personally.
On his arrival the well-known anti-Semitic Rozwoy of Lodz had an article on him headed “Sir Schloime Samuel.” The paragraph reads as follows:
Sir Schloime arrived to-day in Warsaw, accompanied by Captain Wright. After his arrival he sneaked up to the Vice-Minister Strzynski, and conferred with him for about an hour and a half. He declared to the Minister Strzynski that he was there neither to act as judge in the Polish-Jewish quarrel, nor to carry out investigations; nor would he make a deep study of the problem of the Jewish pogroms (what generosity!). He wished only to find out what progress had been made towards an agreement between Poles and Jews since the Poles had obtained their independence, and he wished to reassure public opinion in England (which in the Daily News accuses Sir Schloime of Parliamentary bribery). We should suspect from what we know of Sir Schloime that the absence of this gentleman from England will reassure public opinion. On the other hand, we would warn our Government in Warsaw to warn this “Englishman” not to g0 to Lodz incognito. It will be better to warn him for the sake of himself and for the Lodz workers, who, made nervous by unemployment and hunger, might burst out with something silly.
A piquant insight into Polish views—presumably "inspired" ones—regarding the relative status of the two commissioners is afforded by the following paragraphs taken from Czas, a Cracow conservative organ:
We have no objection to the Entente Powers studying the Jewish question in Poland, so long as this is done in a suitable manner. To a very large extent it is our joint concern, seeing that Jewish emigration from Polish countries towards the West (England and America) has been very great, and that it may be assumed, in view of the friendly feelings existing in England and America towards
Jews, that it will certainly not cease, but, on the contrary, be welcomed. In view already of this emigration it is clear that both these Anglo-Saxon Powers wish to get an insight into the Polish-Jewish situation. America has done this in an unobjectionable manner by sending out Ambassador Morgenthau following a special invitation of President Paderewski.
Matters are somewhat different with the British mission which is to arrive here now. At the head of it is Mr. Samuel, about whom reports are current which are very strange.
u dee ee ee Fe - all Reports arrive from London to the effect that he is a member of one of the Jewish parties, i.e., a representative of the Zionists, so that he is without the lack of prejudice towards all Jewish organizations here possessed by Mr. Morgenthau. And, finally, even before he. arrived in Poland, he, or the group to which he belongs, was guilty of gross tactlessness. For, as reported yesterday, a malignant circumstance played into the hands of the Polish authorities in the shape of a telegram addressed to the editor of one of the Jewish Radical journals ordering from London an enthusiastic reception of Mr. Samuel by the Polish Jews. [This clumsy lie was very short-lived, for it was proved immediately after this publication that Sir Stuart Samuel had already been incognito in Warsaw for a few days.] Thus the rumours that Mr. Samuel was going to Poland in a confidential capacity, not so much of the British Government as of the English Zionists, found confirmation, and the statement by the Morning Post that this second Mission was “low, unjust, and insulting to Poland,” would, in view of these circumstances, appear to be covertly, as well as on the face of it. correct.
MR. PADEREWSKI ACCUSES -
In default of any recent press dispatches concerning military moves, it would seem that the bitter war between Poland and the Ukraine about disputed territory is waged now chiefly in the form of denunciations and protests. Asa consequence, Mr. Ignace Jan Paderewski, Premier of Poland, whose popularity, according to metropolitan news-letters, is greatly on the decline, has made his debut as an assailant of Ukrainian pogrom policies. We gather the following news item from the columns of the N. Y. Sun:
Warsaw, Nov. 13 (delayed).—Ignace Jan Paderewski, the Polish Premier, in a long statement in the Diet to-day on the external and internal situation of Poland, described conditions in the Ukraine as chaotic. He declared that murder and pillage raged there and asserted that 10,000 Jews had been massacred pitilessiy. The Ukrainian authorities had kept silence about the massacres, he charged.
Dealing with the war against the Bolsheviki, Premier Paderewski said Poland’s sacrifices had been heavy, but that the effort was indispensable for the security of the present and future generations. It was impossible, he added, to make peace with the Bolsheviki. .
M. Paderewski was loudly acclaimed when he thanked the countries which had assured the independence of Poland-—-France, England, Italy, the United States and Japan—and when he paid tribute to the Poles in America for their aid.
As soon as Messrs. Petluras and Denikine will take the floor concerning Polish pogroms, a fairly accurate supplement to Mr. Morgenthau’s report may confidently be expected.
Mr. Paderewski, however, in his laudable attempt to fall in line with European civilization, does not rest content with calling the Ukrainian kettle black. According to the Chicago Sentinel, he has made an interesting—but by no means unprecedented—move in his foreign policy, as witness the following item gleaned from the columns of our Western contemporary:
POLAND SENDS JEWISH ENVOY TO WIN FAVOR OF ENGLAND
A Jew, named Levenhertz, has been sent here by the Polish Government with the evident purpose of winning sympathy for Poland among the English, who have become alienated on account of the Polish pogroms against Jews. It appears that Levenhertz was chosen to be Poland’s emissary because of his friendship for the English Jew, Namir, who has the oversight of Polish affairs in the oflice of the
