The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 10 · December 1919
356printed page
scan 58 of 82
Facsimile · scan 58 of 82
Scan of p. 356
Text · transcribed from the scan

The Maccabaean

ers say that not less than 1,000,000 Hebrews from Europe and America will go to Palestine. . . This is considerably more than the present population. If the expectation is realized, therefore, the political and social problems of the settlers will be simplified by their numerical superiority." The concluding paragraph of the editorial is a cup that cheers but does not inebriate: "Palestine" according to the Republic, "is more like Utah than the ordinary conception of it gained from the Bible. Still, many parts of Utah have been made to blossom as the rose. Perhaps these hopeful Zionists can do the same with Palestine. Certainly in their efforts the good will of all the world will go with them."

In editorially considering the prospects of the yishub, the Dayton, O., News, if wrong concerning the number of prospective American settlers, is right at least in a budgetary estimate:

Out of our large population of those of Jewish birth likely there will be only a small number who would care again to take up their residences in Palestine. It is feared $7,000,000 will go only a small way toward national rehabilitation.

The Chicago Post, in dealing with the Convention, declares its preference for Jews as future custodians of the sacred places: What Christian would not sooner see Palestine, with all its sacred associations for Christians, back in the hands of the Jews rather than in the hands of its present possessors—Arabic Mohammedans under the suzerainty of the cruel Turk?

A Convention editorial of the Chicago News, discussing the political aspects of Zionist strivings, is quite in line with the best-informed opinion of British and other Zionist savants:

Certainly from the political point of view conditions appear unprecedentedly favorable to the aims and ideals of the Zionist movement. The defeat of Turkey and the general feeling that the Turk no longer must be permitted to rule vast territories inhabited by peoples superior in culture to himself have removed an obstacle which heretofore has proved insuperable. In the process of dividing up these territories and assigning them to various powers as mandatories it should be comparatively easy to make the arrangements necessary to give the new Zionist state a chance to take root and expand. It is recognized, of course, that the whole process will have to be gradual, on the political as well as the economic side, since the Arab population of Palestine is large as compared with the Jewish elements now dwelling in that country.

The same circumspect optimism informs the editorial congratulations of the Gloucester [Mass.], Times:

There seems to be no question that a generous expenditure of money can make Palestine blossom like the rose, as it once before did. We know vastly more about irrigation and the use of water power than the ancients did, and should be able far to surpass any of their accomplishments. And there are Jewish people in large numbers who seem to be willing to emigrate to the ancient land and to invest their money and their talents.

At the same time, it should be remembered that all three faiths named have an interest in the country, and nothing should be done which will interfere with the rights of any one of them. Gen. Allenby was exceedingly careful about this, and others must follow him in that. We are sure that this will be so whoever controls the land. And we are equally certain that, as soon as archæologists are given liberty to explore ancient sites, a wealth of information concerning the past will be laid at our doors. Palestine's new day means much to all of us.

Limitations of space only preclude us from quoting scores of similar Convention-greetings, all proving the intelligent and kindly interest of the American press in the present work and future aims of Zionism.

Three Hundred Fifty-six

That the Convention was held at a stage of suspense in international developments, and that its proceedings necessarily bore the mark of a moment of transition, is a fact stressed and over-stressed by a few of our Jewish colleagues. Their voices are all like unto the voice of the Buffalo American Jewish Review, whose Convention utterances will therefore suffice as a specimen:

It may be that many a puzzled visitor or delegate is asking himself, now that the sessions of the convention are over, just what was done besides electing new officers, and just how much nearer the Zionists are toward a realization of their dreams. We do not know. We prefer to sit back and see.

We do not say that the Zionist convention was nothing more than a thing of hurrahs and reports, words of greeting and elation. We believe that it was productive of several features which made the gathering unique.

One feature was the sharp criticism directed from the rank and file at the leaders who were sent to Palestine to spy out the land for the edification of Zionists at home. Delegates asked searching questions in an attempt to achieve democracy in the organization of the Zionists and were reassured by their leaders that their criticism would be put to constructive use.

Another outstanding point in the proceedings was a protest made from the floor, against such exaggerations as were issued in the form of pre-convention Zionist propaganda by the publicity department. The speaker, Abraham Goldberg of New York, in his plea for sanity and honesty, denounced the headlong publication of the amount of money collected and the number of members enrolled in the Zionist organization.

With such tools in hand as resultant better understanding between members and leaders; a clean slate as far as real information regarding Zionist activities is concerned, and a sheaf of ways and means finally devised for the real purpose of the convention, it yet remains to be seen how the rehabilitation of Palestine prospers.

There is, after all, little harm in this lofty attitude of the non-combatant who "waits and sees." A near future, belike, will answer him as the traditional father in the Haggada answers the naughty boy.

In Darkest Poland

MR. MORGENTHAU IN DIFFICULTIES

In accepting membership in a Commission of Inquiry on terms precluding true enlightenment on the Polish situation—terms which to say the least no Jew should have accepted, Mr. Henry Morgenthau deliberately created for himself a false situation in which his usual resourcefulness seems to have entirely left him. In view of the fact that Mr. Paderewski repeatedly and solemnly denied the occurrence of any Polish pogroms of noteworthy extent before the forum of European and American public opinion, Poland's Premier, by inescapable inference, was courting a pogrom-inquiry. The self-imposed limitations of Mr. Morgenthau's mission are therefore a veritable puzzle of needless self-stultification to say nothing of an implied self-abasement. The commissioner's manifest efforts to spread large upon the records, sycophantic utterances of a few Polish maranos as "Jewish public opinion," his out-of-place lectures on patriotism to audiences consisting of the kin and friends of slain, robbed or cruelly maimed people, his partisan stand against Jewish nationalists, are only a few out of a long list of blunders committed by a man whose marvellously keen intellect makes the bill of indictment against him all the heavier. The bill itself is drawn with unsparing detail by the Jewish Press of Poland and elsewhere.

For instance, the Warsaw Hatzefirah writes:

The conversations of Mr. Morgenthau, in which frequently remarks were made against the Jewish nation and against the national demands, which amounted to a justification of the Poles, even these