The Maccabaean
man reminded the delegates that the discussion of the report of the Executive Committee was an important matter and that the delegates should refrain from asking trivial questions which lead nowhere. There were many demands for the floor, which created considerable tumult. There were also heard motions from several corners of the house for the adoption of the report.
When the tumult subsided, Mr. Abraham Goldberg, of New York, was given the floor to address the Convention on the report. He spoke of the vaccilation, "the aimlessness" and lack of initiative of the Administration. He mentioned the case of the American Jewish Congress, where the Administration pursued a policy of "watchful waiting," instead of taking the initiative. On the other hand, he charged the Administrative Committee with usurpation of power, with using the Executive Committee as a rubber stamp and depriving it of authority that rightly belonged to it. In conclusion he pointed out that his criticism was not directed against any persons responsible for the actions or inactions of the Administration, but against a system that needs to be corrected.
Dr. Samuel Buchler, of New York, came to the defense of the Administration. He pointed out the many difficulties the Administration had to cope with during the past year. Dr. Levensohn, of Chicago, spoke on matters relating to the report of the Secretary of Education and emphasized the need for Yiddish and Hebrew Zionist literature.
Mr. Morris Margulies, of New York, was then given the floor. He picked up the thread where Mr. Goldberg left off. He asked for a vote of censure against the Executive Committee for permitting the Administrative Committee to usurp the power that was vested in the Executive Committee. The Administration, he went on to say, was not responsive to the will of the masses. The chasm that exists between the leaders of the movement and the masses must be bridged. If this is done, he concluded, there will be a feeling of trust and confidence and a willingness to follow the leadership.
The floor was then accorded to Mr. Morris Rothenberg. In a comprehensive address he answered all the critics of the Administration. While admitting the weight of some of the criticism, he deplored the fact that not one of the speakers that preceded him gave the Administration credit for the things it had accomplished. As a member of the Executive Committee, he admitted that that body had little to do with the things achieved during the past year. But the organization, he said, was working on a war basis and it had to resort to methods which it would not have adopted had it been working under normal conditions. He agreed that relations will have to be adjusted between the Administrative Committee and the Executive Committee and that the sentiments of the Zionist masses will have to play a greater part in the actual carrying out of Zionist policy. He then went on to review the matter of the American Jewish Congress to which Mr. Goldberg referred. The Administration, he said, was timid in its determination on a definite policy with regard to the Congress because it did not know the mind of American Jewry regarding the question of Palestine. But it is unfair to say, he continued, that the Administration was against the convening of the Congress, while as a matter of fact it was the same Administration that created the Congress. He then called attention to the unprecedented gains in the membership and other fields of Zionist endeavor. In speaking of the difficulties which the
leaders of the movement had to encounter during the past twelve months in carrying out the mandate of the Zionist Organization, in sending envoys to Palestine, and in the political work in Paris, he deplored the fact that the delegates were not more intimately acquainted with all these questions, because, he said, they would be in a position to judge better what had been accomplished.
Mr. Rothenberg was followed by Mr. William Edlin, of New York, who asked several questions regarding the shaping of Zionist policy and the responsibility assumed by the Executive Committee for that policy.
Persistent cries were heard now for the closing of the debate, while scores of other delegates were clamoring for recognition. Finally a vote was taken and the debate was declared closed. It seemed, however, to be the consensus of opinion of the large majority of the delegates that the Administration be given the opportunity to reply to the questions that were put forward in the course of the discussion.
Mr. de Haas was recognized. He said that he would confine himself to categorical answers, as seemed to be the wish of the Convention. He had made notes of all the questions and answered them in the order they were asked. On the question of policy, with regard to Palestine, he said that the Administration would submit its outline to a joint meeting of all the committees working together with the Committee on Palestine. Asked as to whether the Organization assumes responsibility for the Jewish political actions of its members outside of the Zionist Organization, he said that the Organization did not and could not assume such responsibility. As to the mistreatment of the Jews in Palestine by the Zionist Commission, he said that he himself had seen the statement printed in the London "Jewish Chronicle" and that in his judgment it misrepresented the attitude of the Zionist Commission in Palestine. With reference to the responsibility of the work done in Palestine, he said that the Zionist Organization of America as part of the International Organization assumed part of the responsibility. He added that the Inner Actions Committee, since January, 1919, is in control of all Zionist affairs. Other questions of minor importance, some touching on matters relating to local Zionist works, were answered in the same direct manner.
There was now an insistent demand for a vote on the acceptance of the report. A rising vote was taken and the report was declared accepted. Following the acceptance of the report Judge David, of Chicago, moved that Mr. de Haas be granted the floor to answer in a general way some of the charges that were leveled against the Administration. Mr. de Haas said that he had no intention of addressing the Convention at this time, but that he expected to make his address when the question of the work for the future will come up. He added, however, that he did not take amiss any of the criticisms launched against the Administration. He admitted that errors were made. It was no more than humanly natural that errors should be made, but that they were the kind of errors that easily gird people. While he agreed that criticism was a healthy thing, he deplored its tone and the lack of appreciation for the work done. He concluded by saying that in spite of this criticism he is determined to go on with this work to the bitter end.
On motion of Mr. William Edlin, Mr. Lipsky as a member of the Administrative Committee was also asked to address the Convention. Mr. Lipsky said that he felt satisfied that this agitation and feeling of restlessness which prevailed