The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 10 · December 1919
341printed page
scan 43 of 82

The Maccabaean

manent chairman. After several motions and counter motions were made, not without considerable excitement, several delegates demanding that a chairman be elected for each session, it was decided that the Convention elect one chairman and two vice-chairmen. Thereupon the following were unanimously elected: Judge Julian W. Mack, chairman; Dr. Stephen S. Wise and Mr. Louis Lipsky, vice-chairmen. On motion, it was decided also to elect three secretaries, for English, Hebrew and Yiddish. The following were elected: Messrs. Bernard G. Richards, Abram Goldberg and Senior Abel.

The election of chairman, vice-chairmen and secretaries disposed of, Dr. Wise rose to offer the following two resolutions, which were adopted unanimously by a rising vote:

I.

This Convention of the Zionist Organization of America regrets the absence of Nathan Straus, a greatly loved figure in American and world Israel, who has been one of the pioneering furtherers of the Zionist cause:

We, the fellow Zionists of Mr. Straus, rejoice to hope that the Jewish homeland which is to be, may be for years served by his continuing devotion and generosity; and we ask the officers of the organization, in our name, to send a message of affectionate greeting to Mr. Nathan Straus, and to his helpmeet, our honored friend, Mrs. Nathan Straus.

II.

This Convention of the Zionist Organization of America, in Chicago assembled, at its opening session, of Sunday, September 14, 1919, expresses its deep appreciation of the help and cooperation in the establishment and maintenance of the work of the Zionist Medical Unit in Palestine, rendered by the Joint Distribution Committee, in addition to carrying on an extensive and beneficent relief service through Palestine.

We rejoice in the readiness of the Joint Distribution Committee to continue its generous support of the enormously important work of medical healing and prevention by the Zionist Medical Unit, as an earnest, moreover, of the desire of all Israel to have part in the rebuilding of the Jewish land.

On motion of Mr. Neaman of Pittsburgh, amended after considerable discussion which lasted almost an hour, it was decided that a Committee on Committees, consisting of fifteen, be chosen on tlie basis of one representative for each regional conference and selected by the chairman of the respective regional conferences, with the privilege that those States which did not have any regional conferences be also represented on the Committee on Committees. The members on the Committee on Committees as later announced were as follows:

Morris Neaman, Pittsburgh, Chairman; Isaac Carmel, New York, Secretary; Miss Sarah Kussy, Newark; Dr. Alexander Wolf, St. Louis; Rabbi James Heller, Philadelphia; Marvin Lowenthal, San Francisco; Dr. J. G. Gordan, Minneapolis; Dr. L. M. Palitz, Savannah; Jonas A. Rosenfeld, Dallas; Morris Zeldin, New York; Harry Kahn, New York; Charles Cohen, New Haven; Emanuel Neumann, New York; Samuel Waldstein, Boston; Harry Shuldinger, Detroit; B. A. Antonow, Chicago; A. B. Goldman, Rochester; J. Saks, Norfolk.

This was followed by a motion of Mr. Abraham Goldstein, of New York, that the second session of the Convention be devoted to a discussion of the report of the Executive Committee. The motion was adopted. The chairman then announced that the Lithuanian Council of Chicago had sent a delegation of four to the Convention to express the heartfelt sympathy of the Lithuanians of Illinois with the Zionist movement and wishing success in the realization of its national aspirations. Thereupon at 7 P. M. the first session of the Convention was adjourned.

SECOND SESSION

MONDAY AFTERNOON, SEPTEMBER FIFTEENTH

With Mr. Lipsky in the chair, the second session of the Convention opened. The chairman read the list of the names of the committees that have thus far been completed and then introduced Rabbi Yodelevitz, who greeted the Convention in the name of the Harabonim V'hamatifim of America. The keynote of his address was that at this juncture of Jewish history, when our dream of ages is about to be realized, the Jewish people must put forth a united front and not be divided into contending camps. His plea for a united Jewry was greeted with loud applause.

The chairman recognized Dr. Stephen S. Wise to offer the following special resolution:

This Convention of American Zionists desires to record its satisfaction in having had a part in the founding and summoning of the American Jewish Congress. The Congress of Philadelphia, of December, 1918, dealt in wise and statesmanlike fashion with Jewish problems, and made a profound impression upon public opinion at home and abroad. Because its mandate came from the vast majority of American Jews, its representatives appointed to the Peace Conference, acting in close co-operation with the democratically chosen representatives of European Jewry, were enabled to secure from the leaders of the Allies and associated powers those charters, the attainment of which through treaty guarantees is to mark the beginning of a new era in the history of our people. We look forward to the reconvening of the American Jewish Congress promptly after the peace treaties shall have been ratified, to the end that there be submitted by its delegation to the Peace Conference a complete and authoritative report of its deliberations and actions. We speak for the largest number of American Jews in giving utterance to the faith that out of the reconvening of the Jewish Congress there may develop the creation of some such instrument which shall organically express the collective counsel and will of American Israel.

In view of the importance of this resolution, it was suggested by Mr. Emanuel Neumann, of New York, to refer it to the resolutions committee. It was pointed out by Mr. Morris Rothenberg, of New York, and supplemented by the mover of the resolution, that inasmuch as there was no difference of opinion with regard to the resolution itself and that the Convention was in hearty agreement with the purpose of it it would be unwise to postpone action. Thereupon Mr. Neumann withdrew his suggestion and the resolution was unanimously adopted.

DISCUSSION OF REPORT

In accordance with the decision made at the previous session, the chairman called for a discussion of the report of the Executive Committee. The first to speak on the report was Mr. Neumann, who interpolated several questions as regards the policy of the organization. He was followed by Dr. S. Melamed, at Chicago, who asked whether the Administration was responsible for the political activities of its members and whether the rumors current that Palestine Jewry is mistreated by the Commission, in that it is deprived of its voice in matters Palestinian, are true. Another question was whether the Administrative Committee assumes responsibility for the Zionist work done in Paris.

At this point some of the delegates not familiar with parliamentary procedure became impatient and asked for the "order of the day." The chairman informed them that the order of the day was the discussion of the report and that the questions asked were relevant to the matters under discussion. Seeing, however, that this interpretation was likely to evoke endless questions and that a large number of delegates had made their way to the platform, adding to the fifty odd speakers that were already listed, the chair-