The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 9 · September 1919
256printed page
scan 6 of 44

The Maccabaean

sociological movement. . . . If the Jews are aflame with the desire to erect the commonwealth of a new Zion, their inspiration is not taken from the Torah or Mishna, but derives directly from a need of the times, from their immediate, living impulses, from their resolve not to bear any longer their lot in the midst of other nations. The name of Zion is invoked, not for religious, but for historical reasons. It does not create the Zionist urge, it does not justify it, it only points to a certain direction and adds a mighty, energy-creating emotion by an appeal to recollection."

On a subsequent page [Schriften, p. 7] of the same controversy, he reminds his antagonist—and all the Guedemans of 1919—that if he will not avow his own nation, its adversaries will relieve him of the trouble:

"Dr. Guedeman insists that the Jews are not a people apart. Very well, let him attend then a meeting of Berlin anti-Semites, let him walk the streets of Vienna at a time when the "white carnations" [with which Jew-baiters were wont to decorate themselves] have taken possession, and he will find out whether folks will hesitate to see in him the representative of a people apart and treat him accordingly."

With a boldness of analytic insight and speculative foresight which leaves not only assimilationists but timidly groping Zionists as well, far in the rear, he continues:

“For argument’s sake, I will make Dr. Guedeman an extreme concession; I will accept his assumption that the Jews have ceased to be a people—an assumption which affords not a scintilla of evidence that they may not become one... . Admit, then, that the Jews of today are not a people, but genuine Germans, Englishmen, etc. Even Dr. Guedeman will concede that the Jews of England cannot possibly be better Englishmen than the “Pilgrim Fathers” who sailed on the Mayflower to America, fleeing from religious oppression. These indisputable Englishmen have begotten out of their loins a new nation opposed to the English in a stronger contrast than I could wish to exist among Palestinian Jews as held against European Christendom. .... If an enormous majority tells a well-defined national. minority: You do not belong to us, you are strangers in our midst! Then the minority has no choice but to accept the excommunication ... . therefore, even if it were true that the Jews of today are not a nation, anti-Semitism alone would be a suflicient nation-building incentive.”

To the "Jewish Mission" peddlers he pays this compliment early in his Zionist career [Schriften, p. 245]:

"Who are the people that are uncutiously sermonizing about a specific mission of the Jewish people? In many instances, they are hypocritical voluptuaries feeling the comfort of their present-day situation. For the ease they take in their exempt position they must find a sonorous name and a noble pretext. They are providentially called, forsooth, to preach fraternity to the nations and they begin their instruction by exhibiting hatred, contempt, or at least indifference toward their Jewish brethren. It is their 'mis-

sion’ to teach a higher ethical level by example—and they dishonor the Jewish name through their proverbial rioting in luxurious pleasures. But never mind these people—let us stick to the philosophy of the ‘mission’ idea itself.: Let us measure it against the trite realities of the day. The Jews have the mission to live in the dispersion so as to teach the nations in whose midst they live, through instruction and example. Fine. But how are the 260,000 Rumanian Jews to fulfill their mission? If they stay in the country, they will afford the Rumanians the example of starving to death —will they be inclined to imitate it? But if they leave the country, how are they to instruct the Rumanians? Through a correspondence-school? If so, they had better mail their letters of instruction to the Rumanians from Palestine .. . enough of this: such profundities about a Jewish mission are the merest twaddle, incapable of enlisting the attention of serionslv-minded neonle for one minnte!” 2

The high reputation which Max Nordau’s CongressSpeeches enjoy in American Zionist circles, is a fair promise of recovery from the infantile diseases of our American movement. As an antidote against an incipient habit of Napoleonic bulletin-writing which is to be observed just now in some of our leading Zionist circles, and as a preventive against an “optimistic” mishandling of yishubdifficulties, a re-study of the Schriften on a national scale is to be warmly recommended. From this collection of Nordau’s Zionist speeches and writings there emanates a disinfecting atmosphere of honest realism which never blinks or evades Jewish difficulties or minimizes the task of reconstruction. The Zionist Nordau never shouts or rants, never puts his trust in the picturesque appeal of exaggeration, never hesitates to probe the wounds of the Jewish body politic, knowing full well, as a wise physician, that diagnosis must precede cure. May I not be permitted, in this connection, to call the attention of my American fellow-Zionists to a little-considered aspect of the effects of anti-Semitism—or the mere apprehension of anti-Semitism— upon Jewish public opinion? It is true that anti-Semitism, or the fear of it, in a sense holds us together, exactly as the pressure of atmospheric air preserves our physical bodies from dissolution. But it is also true that this pressure, like that of an over-dense atmosphere, is clogging our pores and obstructing, in America, at least, that generous sweep of self-criticism without which no nation can hope to preserve its mental. and moral. health. The moral courage of the Zionist Max Nordau must be ours, before we of America can hope to attain to that leading position within the movement to which our numerical strength, all other things being equal, would entitle us. Let the classics of our movement do for us Jews what Homer and Plato did for the Christendom of the Renaissance. To drown the voice of a teacher by acclaiming him at the banquet-table is not the way to honor him. Let us study his message and do our best to transform thereby his individual excellencies into national traits. “Zionistische Schriften” are part of our national assets; let us get them in circulation.