The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 9 · September 1919
255printed page
scan 5 of 44

The Maccabaean

conscious Jewish nationalism which clung all the more desperately to the two inhibitions of "no baptism" and "no intermarriage," because it had very little else to feed on. As long as these two taboos were in full strength, they felt secure of their human boundaries—secure against internal disintegration and sure of the stability of the benefits of emancipation. This feeling of security was universal until about 1888 when it began to waver slightly under the first anti-Semitic onslaught of any force, thenceforth to decline by slow degrees. Seven years later, in 1895, wide Jewish circles in Vienna were "viewing with alarm." An epigrammatic utterance of this lastmentioned year has stuck to my memory, on account of its social significance. In 1895, shortly before my departure for America, the playwright Arthur Schnitzler said to me, in the course of a casual conversation about Jewish affairs: "It may be true that Eastern Jewish communities have their hysterias of apprehended attack, but the fact is that we of the West are the hysterical sleep-walkers of a fancied security!" What had happened between the years of 1888-1895 to awaken two celebrated sleep-walkers of Paris and Vienna—and thousands in their wake as well—out of their assimilationist trance?

II

Under the limitations of cramped magazine-space, I keenly feel the impossibility of answering this question properly—by giving a history of seven eventful years from the Jewish angle of interest. A few brief hints must suffice:

Thirty years ago, both Herzl and Nordau looked upon themselves as ambassadors of .South-German culture to the French Republic, and as interpreters of contemporary France to the newspaper-readers of Vienna. The German nationalism of Herzl was a quiet but all-pervading assumption, that of Nordau—in keeping with the difference in their temperaments——a rather swashbuckling, controversy-inviting sentiment which flared up into illumination during the Parisian Richard Wagner riots at. the Opera and'later on during the Boulangistic campaign of Revanche. That European society was about to.annul. the charter-rights of Jewish emancipation never entered their heads. . Both were young, both financially well-to-do, of handsome appearance, allied with some of the most powerful press-organs in Europe, far-famed and facile writers both—in brief, two typical members of the privileged classes whose Jewish origin was as completely submerged, in their own consciousness, as a persistent fact like race can possibly be. . The older of the two, Nordau, was ’a militant atheist, his younger colleague a quiet agnostic. In those days, they were never referred to in public print as Jews—until the advent of an anti-Semitic press in 1888, when they were restamped as “Zeitungs-Juden” and entered as such upon the social proscription lists of Continental anti-Semitism. Their first experience of the new anti-Jewish spirit informing European society was the success of Drumont’s “La France Juive” in 1886—a libel in two volumes of which 60,000 copies were. sold before the close of the decade. Lack of space precludes me from giving the reader an adequate idea of the atrocious imbecility of this classic of a nascent Jew-hatred in the emancipated West. Two typical specimens of its contents must sufice: according to Drumont, the blood thirst of the revolutionist Jean Paul Marat is explained by his alleged Jewish origin, and his Jewish origin is proven by the accidental assonance of his name to the Hebrew word mara (bitter). Prince Paris of Troy was a Jew, his abduction of Queen Helen a typically Semitic abuse of hospitality, and

the Siege of Troy a warlike Aryan enterprise, on a grand scale, against Semitic teaching. Of such stuff, the nation of Voltaire and the Encyclopædists absorbed 60,000 copies—a farcical prelude to rapid developments in Paris and Vienna, when looked upon in the retrospect. At the time of the occurrence, this success of an impudent blagueur was not likely to cause more than transitory misgivings to our fellow-correspondents of the Neue Freie Presse. But the next year brought the Rohling-Bloch controversy, a scandal of European dimensions, because it revealed the unsuspected fact that the town-rabble of Vienna in its thousands believed the mediæval story of a Jewish blood-ritual, and that ten thousands had the effrontery to affect a belief in it, without fear of disgracing themselves in the public opinion of the town. In the heart of Europe, in a capital renowned for its leadership in the sciences and arts, after a hundred years of Jewish emancipation, at the close of the nineteenth century, the monstrous beliefs of the Crusading Age made a parade of their renascence in broad daylight, with a host of priests, politicians and pamphleteers for their defenders. There was an icy, heart-gripping terror in this new experience—as if the ground had opened under the feet of the Jews of Vienna, disclosing the existence of paleozoic monsters long since thought extinct. Then came, in rapid succession, the blood-accusation of Xanten, and in the same year [1891] the election of thirteen anti-Semits to the Reichstag. It was patent now that Western Europe was reconsidering emancipation, thus forcing its Jews to reconsider their status in European society. All these preliminary tremors of an impending change were silently noted at the Parisian office of the Neue Freie Presse. They terminated in the final earthquake of the Dreyfuss affair which is directly responsible for Herzl's historical first step and his conversion of Nordau to the Zionist cause in the spring of 1897.

We have it upon Nordau's own assurance that he was not a Zionist for some months after the first appearance of the "Judenstaat" [October, 1896]. But in August, 1897, he appeared at the Basle Congress and early in the fall of 1897 he took the field as a Zionist pamphleteer. His conversion must therefore have taken place in the spring months of the first Congress-Year. All the silent self-questionings and heartaches of ten preceding years reverberated in his justly celebrated first Congress-Speech and in his controversy with Dr. Guedeman.

His journalistic encounter with Dr. Guedeman is a passage-at-arms [Schriften, p. 1-17] that should be studied by every propagandist of the movement, because it meets with classical argument an ever-recurrent stock-situation of militant Zionism. Note especially [Schriften, p. 4] the sober good sense with which he insists in the very infancy of the movement upon its strictly secular character. To Dr. Guedeman, every token of an incipient Jewish nationalism in the West was a portent of evil omen. He tried to crush the new birth of the times by exploiting the inevitable inconsistencies of the Talmud for the support of assimilationist doctrine. This strategy must have been especially provoking to Nordau who knew, of course, that Guedeman was acting as the literary minyanman of a community in which nineteen out of every score of cult-taxpayers had never seen a copy of the Talmud in their lives. He retorted:

"The Herr Ober-Rabbiner of Vienna would like to shift the battle-front against Zionism upon theological ground. On our part, it would be childish to consent to such a shift of front. Zionism has no concern at all with theology. It is not a religious, but a political, economic, ethical and