The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 6 · June 1919
48printed page
scan 9 of 40

The Maccabaean

Semitism. And if the organization of the Jews as a national minority reduce the points of contact with the Poles, it will also reduce the possibilities of friction, and both nationalities will then be able to co-operate more efficiently in the upbuilding of the new Republic. The Polish National Committee at Posen has already recognized the Jewish People’s Council of that city. In the Ukraine the recognition of the Jews as a national minority, with a Jewish Minister, is an established fact, and in Czecho-Slovakia and Lithuania a similar system is to be introduced. It is only by the adoption of some such scheme, not by assimilation or emigration, that the Jewish question in Poland can be solved. Assimilation, at best, is the work of time and good relations; and as for emigration, Palestine, the only land in question, is haralv H,ikalv Anrino tha nert faw vears tn he ahla in ranaiva

Jewish settlers in such numbers or at such a rate as to produce an early relief in the situation.

duce an early relief in the situation. But the grant of Jewish national rights alone will not ensure the reign of domestic harmony in Poland. The miasma of anti-Semitism, which lies so heavily upon all classes of the population, upon church and school, press and commerce, should be relentlessly swept away. M. Roman Dmowski, the self-confessed author of the boycott gospel, should recant his pernicious heresy and unite with M. Paderewski in purging his fatherland of the evil spirit that he has conjured up. Greater statesmen than he have confessed their errors; few are now faced with a more urgent and momentous task. For upon the contentment of a united Poland will depend the peace of Eastern Europe, and there can be no contentment there without justice to the Jew.

The Period of Transition

THESE are the days of waiting. All the world is counting an Omer from Passover to the giving of the Law. And just as from the passage of the Red Sea to arrival at Mount Sinai the Jews had to experience a painful transition, so now, too, all Jewry is suffering from anxiety and the effect of transition. It is to be presumed that when the professional historian misses his accustomed breakfast, instead of viewing the incident philosophically, he is just a plain ordinary grumbler who proceeds to put the blame somewhere in a tense and personal way.

Almost none of us are historians; few of us are philosophers. Where we are personally concerned we maintain an aloof attitude. We do not watch a process when we are part of it. We enjoy the sensation of great events provided our meals are served with accustomed regularity. We want to eat the cake and still possess it. That is the difficulty of transition. We are trying, however slowly, to get the Jewish mind ready for a new condition in Jewish affairs.

There is a new Palestine—new in the sense of opportunity and condition of development. That new Palestine demands a new Jewry—new in the sense of thinking in terms of national effort, new also in the ability of thinking in the terms of a new life. But not all of us are capable or willing to take even the moderate plunge demanded of the transition process. To change the metaphor, you cannot strive eastward and cling to the most westerly post. To apply the metaphor: We cannot create the new Palestine and at the same time revert to the methods and manners of the Chaluka and the institutions which it bred. The war put a temporary end to the Chaluka and the Jerusalem begging letter writer, whether he was begging for an institution or an individual. That was one of the benefits of the war because it exchanged haphazard, individual relief for the poor of Jerusalem, by orderly, systematic and regulated relief.

Let us put this fact down in cold print. During the war, year by year, and since the armistice was signed more

June, 1919

money has been sent from America for the relief of the Jews in Palestine than was received in Palestine for Chaluka and for all the other institutions. This statement is based on the information of the best informed and most accurate observers in Palestine. The offset is that prices went up in unheard of proportions and exchange went down. But that was in varying measure the experience .of people everywhere. The cold fact remains that the Jews in Palestine had more without the Chaluka than they would have had if the Chaluka had reached them under the same conditions. And those who want to face both ways, support both weakly, and endeavor to create a storm in so doing.

Education in Palestine too is passing through a new phase. Since the Zionist Commission began to administer affairs there an attempt has been made to provide for the education of all Jewish children out of a common purse, and of course on some common basis of need. Naturally the setting up, not of a general standard of education, but the cost of it interferes with everyone’s pet educational hobby. All those aggrieved can of course make out a case, a very good case, for special treatment and consideration, and it requires a good deal of hardihood to ignore one by one all these human elements; but unless one thinks in terms of the whole operation no attempt can be made to discover a working basis for the financing of the education of Palestinian Jewry—a problem that will be much bigger and more complicated a year hence if it is not tackled in this post-transitional stage.

We must face new responsibilities in a new way and measure up as best we may to new circumstances. Thinking in new terms is admittedly painful, for none of us is traditionless; the placing of new tasks in the foreground admittedly implies some displacement of new things. But exactly that must happen in transition. The practical Zionist must think politically. The political Zionist must undertake practical tasks. The hobby rider is the obstacle in the road to progress.

One Forty-seven