The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 6 · June 1919
47printed page
scan 8 of 40

The Maccabaean

without in any way infringing the interests of the State. They wish to live and act as Polish citizens of the Jewish nationality, and they are asking for the same rights that the Poles are demanding for themselves in the Ukraine. A member of an Allied Mission in Poland with whom I recently discussed the question, observed that as the Jews had the right to vote and to sit in Parliament they would be able, as in Western constitutional countries, to exercise Parliamentary pressure in order to secure the fulfilment of their demands. The recent elections have shown the futility of this hope. The constituencies were carved out in such a manner that by the amalgamation of urban districts with a Jewish population with far-spreading rural districts with a Polish population, the Jewish majority of the towns was often converted into an electoral minority. Thus Oswiecim, with its sixty-five per cent. Jews, Chrzanow with sixty per cent., Biala with forty per cent., Javorzno (where the Jews were terrorized by two opposing Polish parties into abstaining from the polls), and a fifth town were combined with 156 hamlets and villages, so as effectually to swamp the Jewish vote. Besides, in some districts Jews were not allowed to vote unless they signed a declaration that they regarded themselves as members of the Polish nationality, and in others the speaking of Yiddish was forbidden at meetings. The return of nine Jewish members (one of whom died and has not yet been replaced) affords a very feeble weapon for securing Jewish rights in a Parliament of 400, who are all, irrespective of party, united in opposition to Jewish demands. The Polish Government must therefore make the grant of Jewish national rights its own concern. It will then effect not only the conciliation of the Jewish people but also the consolidation of the Polish State.

What are these Jewish national rights? They comprise, in the first place, the right of self-government in all affairs of religion, education, culture, charitable organization, public health, and economic betterment. The right of the Jews to administer their own religious affairs is such a cardinal principle in Western countries that it may safely be accepted without discussion. The Jews wish to administer their own schools, because the Polish schools are conducted in a de- nominational spirit, animated by Catholic teaching and impregnated by anti-Semitic prejudice. Moreover, the Polish schools are open on the Jewish Sabbath and festivals, so that the Jewish children either violate their religious principles by attending or provoke the resentment of teachers and fellow-pupils by staying away. The Jews wish to cultivate their national tongue, Hebrew, and they must also reckon with the fact that the language of the masses is Yiddish; but they are quite willing and determined to teach the Polish language, and also Polish history and geography, to the same extent that these subjects are taught in the other schools. They also wish, as a community, to have the right of using Hebrew and Yiddish for the purposes of literature, the press, the theatre, and public meetings, though every individual can use Polish to his heart’s content. They desire to have the unfettered control of their own boards of guardians and other eleemosynary institutions, and likewise of their own hospitals and dispensaries, where Jewish patients will be assured of sympathetic treatment and of regard for their religious observances and ritual requirements. They also wish to have the right of organizing measures of economic betterment, such as co-operative societies, sick insurance, and training schools in arts and crafts that will tend to divert the young Jewish generation from shopkeeping to

One Forty-six

industries and agriculture. Furthermore, they claim their quota from the communal and State revenue, to which they contribute so handsomely in taxation, for the upkeep of their communal and national institutions, such as schools and hospitals. Thus, it is manifestly unjust that the 300,000 Jews in Warsaw, which has a total population of only 800,000, should contribute more than half of the communal revenue and yet receive practically nothing in return for their own institutions. Moreover, the Jews demand proportional representation in Parliament, so that their 15 per cent. of the population shall elect a similar percentage of the deputies; and they also claim proportional representation in the Government and municipal services (it being understood that Jewish candidates shall possess the requisite technical qualifications), so that they may be sure of equal treatment an the nart of exerntive ofheials.

In order to exercise these rights of a national minority, it is proposed that the Jews in Poland should be organized upon a new basis. The Jews of each town should form an organized community for all the aforesaid purposes, and not for religious affairs only, and the community should be governed by a Council elected upon a popular democratic basis. The Communal Councils should be under the control of a Central Council, which should likewise be elected upon a democratic basis. This Central Council should act as the supreme representative body of Polish Jewry. It should administer the Jewish institutions serving the needs of the whole country (such as teachers' seminaries), represent the Jews to outside authorities, express its views on all questions connected with Jewish life and activity, publish regulations and ordinances on the basis of its constitution, distribute the amount due to the Jewish community from the State revenue, and draft new laws within the limits of its competence, which should not receive the force of law until after confirmation by Parliament and the Government. It should also be one of the functions of the Central Council to supervise and regulate the emigration of Jews to Palestine. The official link between the Jewish people and the Government should be a State Secretary of Jewish Affairs, who, upon nomination of the Central Council, should be confirmed by the President of the State, and who should likewise be the head of the administration of the Central Council. It is not suggested that this State Secretary should be a member of the Cabinet, only that he should take part in those of its meetings in which Jewish affairs are discussed.

Such, in broad outlines, is the scheme of organization of the Jews in Poland as a national minority, which has been adopted by representative conferences of Jews in Congress Poland and Galicia. It will be seen that it is not the dreadful bogey that it has generally been made out. It is simply a constitutional safeguard for the enjoyment of civil equality. It does not encroach by a hair's breadth upon the prerogatives of the State; on the contrary, it forms a system of devolution which should be welcome to the legislators and administrators of Poland, who must find their hands heavily laden with other problems. It would enable the Polish Government to deal directly with the responsible heads of the organized Jewish community, and thus assure itself not only of its good-will but of its collective intelligence, industry, and resources in the manifold tasks of reconstruction. If it be urged that such a scheme would tend to keep Poles and Jews apart, let it be pointed out that no scheme could keep them apart so effectually as the omnipresent spirit of anti-

June, 1919