The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 6 · June 1919
43printed page
scan 4 of 40
Facsimile · scan 4 of 40
Scan of p. 43
Text · transcribed from the scan

The Maccabaean

culminate in them; and instances are not wanting where communities have been retarded by undertakings too great for their strength. Expenditures upon public works in a poor country, which is not capable of recouping its investments in the near future through taxation, involves the dissipation of capital without return in any calculable period and without improvement in the status of the laborers engaged, public building being only a temporary means of employment.

Of course, all the foregoing are not insuperable objections; at best, these objections are only temporary; but they are objections, nevertheless, if it is our aim to open the gates to the people at the earliest moment with the certainty of making permanent homes for a goodly number and for all sorts and conditions of men. Public works in Palestine must and will be built —speedily and in our days, let us hope; at once, where possible and necessary. But the individual settler cannot and should not regard such undertakings as the mainstay of the pogrom settlement nor the arbiter of his destiny. To do so would be to impede and enfeeble the very movement intended to be aided by such means.

What other ways are open to us to meet the problem of settlement?

There is still the resort to industrial organization...

Even a superficial review of the industrial possibilities of Palestine would be sufficient to disclose that the land is a field for the development of quite a number of industries in addition to agriculture and viniculture. With the aid of raw materials such as may be imported from convenient outside sources the list of feasible industries could be further extended.

Clearly, every industrial enterprise developed in Palestine must create a demand for different kinds of service, both of a manufacturing and trading nature, and would call for the introduction of new elements into the country whose various needs would provide labor for still others. About this there should be no question. Nothing has been more fully demonstrated than the influence of industrialism in creating centres of population—often, indeed, at the expense of the rural population whose numbers have been depleted thereby. However, the latter is not the problem that need concern us just now. The chief point to remember is that, if we desire to blaze the way for settlement in Palestine, we must first stimulate and then follow in the wake of individual initiative expressing itself in terms of industrial enterprise. Be it understood, however, that when I use the expression “individual initiative” I mean initiative in locating and developing sources of profitable employment.

Thus, instead of thinking in terms of an arbitrary unit of settlers for whom to make provision, we should ask our engineers to think of as many different enterprises or industries as may be usefully carried on in Palestine, each calling for a working personnel as large as possible and capable of expansion with increasing local and export trade. So, for example, we might ask our engineers to suggest a hundred different industries each capable of employing, say, from a hundred to a thousand or more men; to indicate the most advantageous sites, draw plans of necessary buildings and improvements, detail the necessary equipment, machinery and materials, provide cost schedules and enumerate the number and kind of labor that would be required from the first step in laying the foundations to the delivery of the finished product to the common carrier; to indicate the

amount of capital that would be required for every such enterprise to insure a fair prospect of success; also, to furnish data as to the general market conditions applicable to each product in question, including sources of competition, etc.

Obviously, to make dependable information of the foregoing nature available to inquirers, it would be necessary to organize and maintain a central body of engineers specializing in different departments of the work, with headquarters in Palestine, who would issue their reports through the various Zionist organizations in different parts of the world for the benefit of interested parties.

The work of the engineers would have to be seconded by the organization and maintenance of a Palestine industrial bureau in every country in which there are any considerable number of Jews. The work of this bureau would have to be industrial promotion. Its task would be to organize or help in organizing every Palestinian industry in need of aid. Thus, this bureau would get in touch with individuals who might be interested wholly or partly in any industry and contribute their suggestions and participate as investors, as workers or as both.

II.

The underlying idea of Karl Marx's bulky book on "Capital" is that the capitalist gets ten hours of labor from his workers, pays for only five hours of work, sells the product at the price of ten hours and pockets the difference. The capitalist, according to Marx, does no service and is nothing but a shameless exploiter made possible under our capitalist system. For that matter, in the Middle Ages, too, the trader was considered either a fool or a knave; a fool if he sold his wares at cost or less than cost, a knave if at more than cost.

The fact is, however, that the capitalist (or trader) does not convert a lower priced article for a higher priced one as a man might change one wish for another. The matter is not quite so simple. The capitalist in his effort to dispose of his product at a better price than he paid for it must do so in an uncertain market, in competition with other capitalists anxious to be the first to glut the demand that may exist, must cope with a market interested in forcing down the price of his commodity and forcing up the price of his materials, so that his investment is always at risk. In other words, the capitalist works in a medium of instability in which everybody operates at cross purposes. Our present economic system, then, is not so much capitalistic as anarchistic. The service of the capitalist consists in causing a commodity to be taken from the place, form or quantity in which he finds it, to be delivered to the place, form or quantity in which it is desired, at actual or potential risk to his capital, due to economic anarchy.

For this condition of affairs the consumer, the laborer and the capitalist must all pay. The consumer pays in high prices due to the fact that his wants are supplied under conditions of economic risk. The laborer pays because he is a pawn whose interests are sacrificed in the interest of competitive values incident to economic strife. The capitalist pays, too, as is evidenced by the fact that 90% of all business enterprises fail.

This state of affairs we must try to avoid in the industrial upbuilding of Judæa, and, in the avoidance, be of some service in indicating a solution for the world at large. Inasmuch as we want the active or passive participation of investors in and out of Palestine by way of helping us to