The Maccabaean
Vol. 32
JUNE, 1919
No. 6
Industrial Franchise In Palestine
By HYMAN SEGAL
The task now confronting Zionists throughout the world and those responsible for Zionist policy is the development of a well-ordered Jewish settlement in Palestine. A full discussion of all phases of the problem is of first importance. The following article deals with but one phase of the question, the industrial. The writer presents what he believes will prove to be a practical step toward preventing in Palestine a repetition of those economic strifes which inevitably lead to “economic anarchy.” A series of articles is now being prepared for THE MACCABAEAN, which will deal with the industrial, agricultural, legislative, administrative and cultural aspects of the whole problem of Palestine settlement by such eminent authorities as Mr. Louis F. Post, Assistant Secretary of Labor of the United States Government (see announcement elsewhere in this issue), Dr. N. I. Stone, one of the foremost economists in the country, Dr. Max Heller (who will write on the cultural aspect) and others. In printing these articles THE MACCABAEAN does not commit itself to any policy except one in complete harmony with the principles enunciated in the Pittsburg Platform—THE EDITOR.
I.
AT this juncture of Jewish affairs it should not be amiss to consider how the settlement of Palestine may begin with the least delay and proceed at the best pace consistent with good results. The problem is not alone an engineering one. Economic and psychological considerations, at least, must be weaved into any comprehensive plan of settlement. At what point shall we begin?
There are some who believe in planning to accommodate an influx of, say, one hundred thousand settlers, and to proceed to make provision for their food, clothing, shelter, etc., in advance. Certainly, there is need for a great many things in Palestine—a need for houses, for example. But no sooner do we begin upon our task of providing for our imaginary unit of 100,000, than we are confronted by the problem, What part of Palestine will that 100,000 choose to settle? What will be its personnel?—will they be artisans, professional men, farm laborers, itinerant peddlars or merchants? What will be the special fitness, training and requirements of each? The further we pursue the inquiry as to the constitution and requirements of our working unit, the more clear it becomes that no provision can be made for it unless we are permitted to select its personnel and dictate its mode of life and movements which is hardly practicable.
It must be remembered that Palestine is not an uninhabited country. Population will naturally gravitate toward existing settlements here and there. These being the con-
ditions, it is further suggested that we begin with the construction of some public work, like a railroad, a bridge or a harbor and the like. Such a project, it is urged, would have the advantage of attracting and selecting by the very nature of its requirements the kind of settlers who would be suited to the work in hand, and our engineers would be in a better position to make computation of the requirements of the working force.
That public works should and will be built there can be no question. But there is a very serious question as to whether the building of them should be made the cornerstone of our settlement. The objections are several.
In the first place, every such undertaking involves considerable delay incident to the interminable public discussion of every public enterprise, the choice of the project, surveys, the flotation of very large loans, etc.
Secondly, the character of the work demanded by such operations—heavy labor, chiefly—is rather restricted, one-sided, and would not draw upon the rather sedentary abilities of the mass of our people. It certainly would allow but little room for that individual initiative and enterprise which are the breath of life in the nostrils of the Jewish race.
Thirdly, there is considerable question whether the energy and financial resources of the Jewish people should first be expended on public works in anticipation of population, when our real aim is first to intrench a Jewish population to whom public work might then become necessary. Settlements, as a rule, do not begin with public works, but
