The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 6 · June 1919
53printed page
scan 14 of 40

The Maccabaean

Yet the emotional coloring under which the ideas are to be presented is as essential as the ideas themselves.

There seems no better suggestions at hand than to leave to the personality of the teacher and of the other members of the pupil's human environment the stimulation of the emotions that make education veritably and properly Jewish. The other task of such an education—the imparting of the necessary ideas—is something that the technique already established can be trusted adequately to perform, if a full and fair opportunity is given.

If we find, therefore, that in the democracy of America there is room for a Jew, we mean that there is room for a man trained by the acquisition of Jewish ideas and colored by a Jewish temperament. And for the acquisition of Jewish ideas the primary requisite is a knowledge as full as may be of the great body of historical facts which make up the record of what Jewish ideas have already accomplished.

Are ee A EN eV ee et EP a A It is too much to expect that the average man, engrossed by vocation and avocation, will be able to acquire more than a small amount of this knowledge. How much is the minimum? That is where the other, the incalculable, non-ponderable part of education enters. A little may suflice if it is presented with that tenderness, that intimacy of feeling that makes it Jewish. In the generations that immediately followed legal emancipation in parts of western Europe, a little did suflice, when it was associated with a vitual endeared by memories of childhood. But the very generations that remained Jewish by reason of this modicum of Jewish knowledge and feeling, gave birth to other generations to whom they neglected to impart even as much Jewish knowledge as they possessed and whom they deprived of ihe childhood association that they enioyed.

A generation, sprung from Jewish parentage, untrained in Judaism, can make no group contribution to American democracy. And yet this same generation not only takes no steps toward dissolving its group but vigorously resists conscious attempts to do so. What can such a situation produce but a condition of internal conflict that must exercise a harmful effect upon the individual soul and its effectiveness in life?

That is why Zionism claims to have an indefeasible claim to organize the Jewish education for a newer and more self-conscious democracy in America. We have taken an inventory of our resources and we know the springs of our spiritual strength. One of them is the conscious contribution of a distinct, unamalgamated group of Jews. But unless that group is to be merely a mechanical mixture, it needs the infusion of something that can stimulate the feeling of intimacy and tenderness to which reference has already been made. Zionism provides an unfailing and inexhaustible fountain of such a feeling, a fountain of living waters.

One Fifty-two

It has been held that those to whom Jewish religion, its ritual, its dogmas, its aspirations, make an immediate emo tional appeal, do not need the stimulation of Zionism. That is a grave error. It seems to be forgotten how large a part of the longing for Zion and the memories of the ancient Palestinian commonwealth play in the older ritual— a ritual of which the emotional appeal was strong and undeniable. But a rationalized and simplified ritual, one carefully stripped of these very elements that contain emotional potency, surely will not be equated in this respect with the picture of that city of which glorious things are spoken. I cannot follow those who would deny to Reform Judaism any spiritual sincerity. But the deliberate ideal of its founders was a sober rationalism. That has been somewhat modified in later times, but it still clings to the atmosphere and spirit of Reform. It is obviously not there that we can turn.

The intimacy of feeling that gives Jewish education its cachet, is almost as characteristic a sign of true democracy. The most ingrained of American Junkers call themselves democrats and no doubt honestly believe themselves to be such. But the essence of democracy is the ideal of social justice, the insistence less upon the rights of the individual than upon the claims of the disinherited. That ideal is ‘slowly becoming the foundation of a new democracy, but its hardest and bitterest fight is yet to come. And this fight the Jewish democrat enters with a fervor and a passion that few others can bring. Where, if not in Isaiah, in Amos and Hosea is the bitter cry of the disinherited expressed with greatest poignancy and soothed with profoundest compassion? Where, if not in the unnamed prophet quoted by Isaiah and Micah, is the ideal of a peace of justice stated with most glowing passion? It is not indeed likely that the corpuscles that flowed in the veins of Isaiah, of Micah or Hosea, could be recognized in the blood of all modern Jews—perhaps not in any modern Jew. But a Jew trained to think of these sublime manifestations of the human mind as in a deeper sense his own than they are any one else’s, enters upon his task in the great democracy of which he is a member, with the keen consciousness that he brings to it what no one else can bring.

"The righteous shall live by his faithfulness." This phrase of Habakkuk has, it is said, become the motto of Judaism through the ages. The steadfastness of the Jews has extorted the unwilling admiration of many that hated and feared them. But steadfastness without a definite consciousness of what it is we are steadfast in, is not a valuable, nor an admirable quality. Steadfastness in the essential democracy of Judaism is, on the contrary, the best, because the oldest, foundation for the democracy of America. And in the production of it lies the goal of Jewish education.

June, 1919