The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 6 · June 1919
52printed page
scan 13 of 40

The Maccabaean

have learned to apprehend most thoroughly the entire spiritual resources of the community in the form in which these resources have been most fully embodied.

For, be it remembered, there is no virtue in the names, democracy, or Jew or American, as such. Whatever virtue or efficacy the names possess is derived from the spiritual implications they hold; or rather, they have no meaning at all apart from the ideas they contain, the emotions they give rise to. And these ideas and emotions are essentially historical facts discoverable principally in the literature and art they have produced and susceptible of being investigated principally in books. One may conceive abstractly of peoples that have expressed their culture in another and non-literary form. Such peoples have indeed existed. But it is an unescapable fact that the great groups associated in the Mediterranean culture have not done so. Their culture is a literary one.

An education that does not recognize that, may still be an admirable drill for a highly specialized function. It may produce excellent polishers of round brass No. 42 nuts. It may fill the community with efficiency experts and executive directors—before which priests of the new dispensation I trust I have a becoming reverence—but it will not educate them for a position in a democracy, because it will not acquaint them with the ideas which constitute the democracy, nor the experience necessary to deal successfully with these ideas. For a bureaucratic absolutism, such as the Diocletian monarchy, such as the governmental ideal of Bismarck or Treitschke, it is enough that every unit should be fitted to the particular plug-hole for which it was designed. For our democratic ideal, our historical, booky, garrulous democracy, it is lamentably insufficient.

The form of democracy that is being developed in America cannot but be the resultant of all the forces existent here. One of these, doubtless, is the physical condition of the country itself and the economic situation largely dependent on that fact. And the other forces are the endowments and conscious or unconscious contribution of the various groups that make up the American people.

There are in America a number of groups of population that have maintained themselves in greater or less isolation from the others. There is one group, the negro, that has unfortunately been almost wholly excluded from communion with the others. Others, while mingling freely in the common life of the people, have felt themselves none the less as a group apart from the rest. That is true of the Irish in a certain measure, and of the Jews in a much larger measure.

Now, in the case of the Irish and others like them, it may be said that it is contemplated that the group shall, as rapidly as may be, cease to exist as a group and be lost or welded or ground into a resultant nationality. Whether there are some who contemplate a like thing for the Jews, may be disregarded. We are concerned at present with those that do not contemplate it, who assume that in some form the Jews shall continue to exist as a separate group. The part that Jews are to play in the democracy that is taking form here, will inevitably be conditioned by the fact of belonging to such a group. They can, by apostacy in one of its many kinds, seek to escape that fact. It may be even that they can succeed in that attempt—at a price that most honest men are not willing to pay. But for those who do not seek to escape it, do not wish to escape it, it is plain that everything they contribute to the building up of

June, 1919

our democratic civilization, will be a group contribution and will have value if the group as such is a spiritual corporate unit of value.

I suppose it will be admitted that if the Jews do not constitute a spiritual corporate unit, it is hard to say what they are. Indeed, if they are not that, they will soon cease to be anything at all, because they are certain to be quickly absorbed physically into the mass of their fellow-citizens. The question is what form that spiritual unit will take.

It may take the form of a religion, of a religion pure and simple. That is, the corporate bond may be the performance in common of certain ceremonies, the common belief in the efficacy of these ceremonies, the common reliance on certain transcendental promises set forth in a definite body of doctrine, the common fear of certain supra-mundane sanctions. Of the majority of Jews all over the world, it may unquestionably be asserted that this is precisely the case. But I think it must be admitted that in America this majority is decreasing, that there is an increasing minority who are held by no such bond, and yet by their own will and in actual fact are members of that spiritual unit which the Jews constitute.

There is accordingly something else, something beside the religious bond, that exercises a spiritual cogency over those who are classed as Jews. It is hardly possible that it can be anything else than the complex of ideas and emotions that, as a matter of historical fact, have made up Judaism.

As far as citizenship in our American democracy is concerned, it may be said as Goethe said of Hellenism, that everybody may be an American in his own way, but he must be one. That is true of any fully constituted political national unit. But as far as the Jewish corporate unit within the American community is concerned, membership in it ought to mean a definite thing. That does not presuppose a dull uniformity among Jews any more than among the larger group of Americans. It merely means that the limits of variability must necessarily be greater among one hundred millions than among three millions. The common nucleus must be present and recognizable, and its nature has already been indicated. A man is a member of the corporation of Jews—the commune ludaeorum, as it would have been officially phrased in the Roman empire under strikingly analogous conditions—if he possesses a certain knowledge, principally a literary, a book knowledge, and if the possession of this knowledge produces upon him an emotional effect of a peculiar intimacy—I had almost said, of tenderness.

Now, the ideal of Jewish education will be, of course, to impart this knowledge and stimulate these emotions. But, when we speak of education, we generally do not mean education in the larger sense, but in the limited sense of the education effected by means of the visible machinery of schools. And the experience of thousands of years has stood us in little stead, if we have not yet realized that the second part of this education, the emotional side of it, cannot be produced by that machinery in any direct way. One reason is that we are not so sure as we formerly were that we quite know what "emotions" are. The division of the mind into three neat departments is, of course, as discredited as the popular terminology that assigns a different physical seat for these supposedly different forms of mental action. Whatever emotions or feelings are, they seem to be the resultants of more complicated and subtle processes than any we have so far been able to isolate and systematize.

One Fifty-one