The Maccabaean
and Lilienblum, led to the organization of a number of societies in various cities. Towards the end of 1884 the delegates of these societies met at a conference in the Prussian border-town Kattowitz, such a conference being impossible in Russia on account of the danger of police interference. By 1890 the Chovere Zion organization was able ın earnıra laralizatinn fram the Rıccian (.nvernment.
Eee > ee A question that occurs to the reader of this volume is this: Should some historian of the future write a continuation of Dubnow, would the events chronicled therein be very different from the heart-rending ones here described? Russia is Russia; and recent events would seem to imply that for Jews it will always remain the same sort of sten-motherland.
Polish Ambitions and the Jews
The White Eagle of Poland. By E. F. BENSON. New York. George H. Doran, $1.50.
TO Jews in America that “White Eagle of Poland,” which forms the title of an account of Polish national aspirations by E. F. Benson, seems today a very dirty and foul sort of bird, with an evil leer in its eye and with cruel beaks and talons. Mr. Benson is the well-known British novelist, author of “Dodo,” “David Blaize,” and numerous other tales, mainly of so-called high society in England. In the present volume he indulges neither in epigrams nor in attempted brilliant writings; he aims to give a clear, straightforward account of what the Poles desire, and how far their desires are legitimate. He carries his argument up to February, 1918, with a few details of later events up to June, 1918; and it is obvious, therefore, that his plea is not exactly contemporaneous. His tone is judicial and his conclusions, with an exception to be noted later, fair.
The book is divided into two parts. The first is mainly concerned with the necessity for the reconstruction of a Polish State after the close of the war. Mr. Benson shows that Poland will form an indispensable link in the cordon of free states which will for all time prevent Germany from penetrating eastwards at will until finally she reaches Egypt and India, and breaks up the British empire. In the second part is an account of internal conditions in the Russian kingdom of Poland from the outbreak of the war in August, 1914, down to (roughly) the end of February, 1918. This is based mainly on such information as has reached England from Polish, German, Austrian, and Russian sources. Mr. Benson feels that the eventual solution of the question of Poland will supply a fair and adequate criterion as to which group of belligerents may be considered to have won the war.
Despite his great friendliness for Poland and his feeling that Poland must in the future form a bulwark against Germany, a goodly part of Mr. Benson’s discussion is devoted to a refutation of the exaggerated claims of the Poles, especially as regards Lithuania. As some very recent outgivings of the Poles have proved, they are fond of exaggerating the proportions of Poles in the population of any given section. Thus Mr. Benson reduces the number of Poles in the new Poland from 26,600,000 to 21,000,000 or 22,000,000 at the utmost, out of a total population of 38,000,000 to 40,000,000. He shows, too, that the Poles claim districts in which the proportion of their people is negligible—Minsk, for example, with 10.3 per cent of Poles, and Volhynia, with 9.97 per cent. The Polish idea is that if a district once belonged to the ancient kingdom of Poland, it should be comprised in the new republic—a claim which, as Mr. Benson remarks, would give Calais to England. They urge, too, that if a people, like the Lithuanians, practice
the same faith as the Poles, that gives the Poles a right to the territory—and as to this claim Mr. Benson suggests that a similar one would give England the right to annex Dratactant (ormanır
ETF ER EEE Du A It is, of course, in what Mr. Benson says of the Jews that one is most interested. There are, says Mr. Benson, four or five million Jews in Poland. He states regarding them that they “cannot possibly be expected to support the union rather than the disintegration of Poland, and the cause of this is so simple that it hardly needs to be pointed out. They have no natural affinity for Poland at all, nor is there the smallest reason why they should have. Racially, they were detested by the Poles, and they were abhorred and persecuted by the Russians during the century in which Poland was under Russian government. But since Germany has been in occupation [This was of course before the downfall of German militarism] their lot has been vastly ameliorated and their yoke lightened. She has given them greater liberty and rights than they ever enjoyed in Russian Poland before; she has admitted them to the Council of State, she founded Jewish schools, and above all she has given them “business.” In both Poland and Russia she has employed the Jews on the mission of disintegration with the success that up till now has always attended the policy of Mittel-Europa, and today the Judaic interest in the question of Poland cannot, in the very nature of things, be proPolish. For the interest of their nation, they support the German interest here, there, and elsewhere, on patriotic erounds.”
eo un Yet this leads to no outburst of anti-Semitism, be it said, on the part of Mr. Benson. He urges, on the contrary, first, that it is necessary to convince the Jewish element in Poland that it would be more advantageous to adhere 10 the Entente rather than to Germany—that, to use his own metaphor, they have bet on the wrong horse. As to this 1here is little to be said at the present stage of the game, —a game in which the stakes are now passing to the hands of the winner, ourselves and the rest of the democratic world. But in the second place, Mr. Benson argues that for Poland to become a united independent state, not fearing German penetration, it is essential that a liberal policy towards the Jews should convince the latter that their interests are cared for and appreciated by the national government. He maintains that the Jews are formidable not only in numbers, but also in position—before the war 80 per cent. of the total trade in Poland and Lithuania passed through their hands. The Jews must be shown that Polish prosperity is involved in their well-being. This will be in accordance with the famous proclamation of the Grand Duke Nicholas to the Poles on August 14, 1914, that “Russia only expects of you the consideration due to the rights of those nationalities with which you became allied through past history.”
Only one point need be urged against Mr. Benson. He lays stress, and from all informatıon available to him, rightful stress, on the fact that the Jews, by their past history and their present treatment, were drawn to the Germans, although he goes too far perhaps in drawing any conclusion from this that they were anti-Entente. The reaction of the Jews everywhere in Russia and Poland to the Balfour Declaration showed conclusively where their hopes lay. On the other hand, again, it should not be forgotten that many Poles were just as pro-German as the Jews are alleged to have been, and that nevertheless, this fact is not being laid up against Poland. Pilsudski, as Mr. Benson shows, joined with Germany against Russia. At Warsaw, in 1917, at least a part of the Polish population celebrated the anniversary of the German entry in August, 1916. Moreover, others besides the Jews are anti-Polish—Mr. Benson states that a very large percentage of Roman Catholics in supposedly Polish territory are “bitterly and violently anti-Polish.”
