The New Poland and the Jews
By ZEVI SCHARFSTEIN
NEVER in the martyr history of the Jewish People has a larger section of Jewry been in so dangerous a position as the Jews are at present in Poland. Three million Jews in that country are at this moment face to face with any possible calamity, ranging from economic ruin to deliberate massacre. And simultaneously with the existence and aggravation of this terrible menace, Poland itself, that is to say, the Polish people, has entered upon the happiest development of its history. Poland has been restored to nationhood, and is receiving the support and blessings of the major part of the world. It is on the road to becoming one of the world's great powers.
How does it happen that Poland, whose old dream has now become a reality, offers so dreadful a menace to so large a minority of its population, a minority which has contributed so much, not only to its material progress but to its cultural and political progress as well? How does it happen that the hitherto hunted and oppressed have become such implacable hunters and oppressors? And in the face of this implacable course of oppression and suppression, what remains to the Jewish people to attempt?
The struggle of the Poles for national freedom dates from the first division of Poland, that act of international brigandage in 1772 when Russia, Austria and Prussia each appropriated a portion of the Polish domains. Russian Czarism ruled over its portion of the loot with an iron fist and drowned in blood every attempt aiming at independence. Prussia with characteristic brutality and thoroughness proceeded to Prussianize its section by suppressing the Polish language and taking into her own hands the education of the Polish youth. At the same time the soil was bought out by the government and the Polish landowners were displaced by real Germans. Only in the Austrian part of Poland, in Galicia, the Poles were successful in securing autonomy in their internal affairs.
The Jews driven by persecution from Germany ‚egan to settle in Poland in the early middle ages. Their history in that country presents many elevations and depressions. The highest spot in this history is undoubtedly the Vaad Arbah Ha-Aratzoth, the Council of the Four Countries, through which the Jews in all the lands controlled by Poland enjoyed complete cultural autonomy or, as we might term it these days, national rights. The misfortune of the Jews in Poland was their superior intelligence. The rulers made them their intermediaries between themselves and the masses, usually in capacities disagreeable and dangerous, in those for example, of tax gatherers. Later when the huge Russian markets were opened to Poland the Jews became the merchants or middlemen. They were a necessary element in the country and enriched it. They developed large industries in Warsaw, Lodz, Tomashov, Lublin and other places. They established hundreds of large and small factories for the manufacture of cloth and all kinds of articles. Their agents, also Jews, marketed these products in the farthest nooks and corners of Russia.
Thus, economically, the Jews became one of the indispensable elements of the country. They became the Polish middle class. And for a long time they enjoyed this position without molestation. Furthermore, they were even
encouraged and protected in this position by the Polish rulers and the reason for that was a very simple one. The Poles themselves had no middle class of their own. Polish society was divided into two classes —the nobility, or as they were called in Polish, the Shlachta, and the peasantry. The Jews, therefore, for centuries were in indisputable possession of all middle-class positions. They were without competitors. For a long time, therefore, the Jews in Poland enjoyed comparative security and on the basis of this security they built up a life of their own with institutions of their own. They built up a culture of their own. They were always exposed to the irresponsible whims and caprices of the nobility on the one hand and owing to the position in which they were often placed by this nobility to the resentment of the peasantry on the other hand. But on the whole, anti-Semitism as an organized menace did not exist.
At the present time, the outstanding feature in the physiognomy of Polish social and political life undoubtedly is anti-Semitism. Hatred of the Jew has embraced every section of the Polish population; a hatred which is expressing itself in the ugliest forms that anti-Semitism has ever assumed; a hatred which is menacing the very lives of three million Jews.
What are the underlying causes and motives of this virulent hatred? We must understand them if we are to be in a position to come to the assistance of our threatened people in Poland.
The principal cause or motive of Polish anti-Semitism is undoubtedly economic. The economic, however, is not the only motive. There is also a political and cultural motive and there is still another which we might call psychologic.
The economic factor, however, is the strongest. Simultaneously with the economic enrichment of Poland by the Jews the Polish aristocracy began to decline. The peasants were no longer the property of the squires or “pritzim.” The Russian Government which hated the aristocracy because of their national pride and nationalistic aims, endeavored in every way to bring about their material ruin. And it must further be noted that to bring about the material ruin of the Polish aristocracy was not a difhicult matter. On the whole the members of the Polish nobility were not people of strong calibre and the power to adjust themselves to economic changes. Most of them lived in the capitals of Europe and pursued lives of dissipation and pleasure. Thus many of them were themselves the accomplices of the Russian Government in bringing about their material ruin. When they found themselves deprived of their peasants and their land, the impoverished Shlachta entered the cities and endeavored to establish themselves in the small industries and the liberal professions. Naturally, ‚therefore, they came into conflict with the Jews who practically monopolized these fields. And these aristocrats, lacking in creative energy and resourcefulness, made no attempt to create new positions for themselves. They found it easier to drive out the Jews from the positions which they, the Jews, had created. And in this work they enlisted the support of every class in the Polish population: the communal workers, the priests, the journalists, the intelligenzia. And wherever
