The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 4 · April 1919
84printed page
scan 4 of 22
Facsimile · scan 4 of 22
Scan of p. 84
Text · transcribed from the scan

The Maccabaean

not been invited to deliberations in which Monaco and San Marino will have a part. But the fact is that he has not been invited.

And very recently the news has been reported from Rome that Pope Benedict has used words in connection with Palestine that seem to indicate a change of feeling. He is reported to have announced that the Vatican could not really consent to a control of the Holy Land by "infidels." The sources are not altogether authentic, the details are not quite clear or known. But if we assume for a moment that he did say just that, we can readily see that it would take no great casuistry to reconcile his present statement with his assurance to Mr. Sokolow that the Jews and the Church would be good neighbors. Control of the Holy Land may have been specifically control of the holy places,—a statement that leaves the interpretation of "control" and "holy places" open to the approved methods of chancelleries and tribunals.

But what we are primarily interested in is, not the possibility that the Pope’s encouragement of Mr. Sokolow may by interpretation come to mean something else than it was taken to mean, but whether there has been any change of heart in the Vatican, which would establish a desire to interpret it that way. Zionists have never put their reliance on specific words or declarations, but in the spirit that animated them. Has that spirit changed in the Vatican? And if it has, why?

That the spirit has changed in France, seems regrettably true. The original French adhesion to the Balfour declaration took care to safeguard the rights of existing populations, —rights that Zionism had not the remotest thought of attacking. But the tenor of the French statement was taken to be an endorsement of Zionism. That the present French government does not endorse Zionism is patent enough. We do not have to go far to discover the reason for it. France has interests of many kinds in the Near East and particularly in the Lebanon. These inierests seemed of secondary importance when the decision was in the balance, and England in actual military control of Palestine. But with a complete victory for the Entente, the aspect is different. Lovers of France as we are,—as every free man and every Jew must be almost by definition, —we cannot blind ourselves to the fact that certain elements of the existing government,— elements of which M. Pichon has allowed himself to be made the mouthpiece, have swerved far indeed from the heroism that roused the passionate admiration of the world, and are hasiening to adopt the outworn system of demands and concessions upon which diplomatic vultures have fattened for some three or four centuries. It is the confident belief of many that the real soul of France is very inadequately represented by these gentlemen, but they are the men who for the present are in indubitable control of the machinery.

Now, it is a curious fact that Clericalism, which up to the very year of the war, was in a decided eclipse in France, has in the last year been given an apparently new lease of life. The church of which the head was openly charged with pro-Germanism throughout France, of which the priests and dignitaries were found in every anti-popular movement of the last decades, which had been so completely discredited that a President of France abjectly apologized for the fact that his wife and daughter took part in a religious ceremony, has asserted itself with an unusual boldness in the last few months. It may be that in France Cler-

icalism has always been associated with reaction, and a certain temporary reaction is hardly avoidable when there is a strong sense of victory. The almost ludicrous lengths to which this feeling has gone can be shown by the fact that capital is sought to be made from the fact that Foch, who succeeded, is a devout Catholic, and Nivelle, who failed, is a froathinlar

Clericalism in France is further an international movement. It openly advocates the restoration of the Papacy to its former position in Europe. As far as the direct international relations of France are concerned, the economic interests of France in the East have been associated in a way not unknown to other hemispheres and other times, with the protection that a formerly Catholic France through the organization of the Catholic Church exercised over the so-called Latin Christians of the Orient. This protection France has valued for practical and sentimental considerations, both of which were much stressed in the recent Syrian congress held at Marseilles.

u > ine We find therefore certain forces at work which tend once more, as was done in times past, to associate the Vatican and France in a common work in Syria and Palestine. That such a partnership can be lasting is plainly impossible. And it is inconceivable that either of the two is unaware how precarious the bond of union is. France can not for the present do without her position as religious champion of the Maronites. The Vatican doubtless welcomes this opportunity of entering again into the field of practical international politics. But at Rome there must still be enough of the spirit of Rampolla in existence to prevent the Papacy from being jockeyed into the false position of being a sort of economic agent in the interests of a nation that has stood as the very type of an “infidel” and anti-clerical people.

For, that the mass of French people will submit to the situation that preceded the affaire is not really within the bounds of probability. It will take very little time before. with an impatient shrug, the man in the boulevard and cafe will find qu’il s’y mele irop de moines. The tiger can change his stripes or his appetite for cassocks as little as his leopardine cousin can perform a similar miracle. Can there be any doubt on that score in Rome?

Perhaps the recent visit of Cardinal Bourne, the primate of English Catholics, to the East, may not be without significance. Englishmen who are also Catholics doubtless have noticed with concern that their church is in danger of being manoeuvred into an appearance of conflict with British interests. Cardinal Bourne took pains to emphasize at Cairo and in Palestine that Catholic claims and rights are in his opinion fully guaranteed by the establishment of British control. His frequent references to this point have all the look of answers to a direct or inferred challenge and may serve to warn French clericals of the dangers inherent in the game they may be playing.

All this seems so evident that the doubt will not down that the Pope’s utterance against “infidel” control of the Holy Land may have altogether different objects in mind. Who are “infidels”? Turks, of course, and worshippers of Mahound and Termagant generally. But the Fathers of the Church were not wont to speak so of Jews. Or if in excess of zeal the “misbelieving” Jew was lumped with the unbelieving pagan, he was associated in that description with a variegated assemblage of groups that called them-

(Continued on page 99)