The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXI, No. 9 · September 1918
80printed page
scan 18 of 27

The Maccabaean

economic, social and religious problems of Morocco, Algiers and Tunis under French direction, of Tripoli and Cyrenaica and Erythrea under Italian control, of Egypt and India under British protectorate and sovereignty, furnish a vast storehouse of precedent, analogy and illustration, persuasive if not authoritative, to which every student of Palestinian conditions should turn. The great skill displayed by the English in modernizing Hindu and Mussulman law in India and at the same time respecting and enforcing the established rights of the different religious institutions and all those quasi-religious legal institutions such as those relating to the family and inheritance, cannot fail to excite our admiration. It certainly invites our careful study.

A MORE EFFICIENT IUDICIAL ADMINISTRATION OF THE ORIGINAL CONTENTS OF THE PAPER AND THE ADDITIONAL CONTENTS OF THE PAPER AND THE ADDITIONAL CONTENTS O

There is one field in which an opportunity may present itself to the new settlers in Palestine to make a great advance over present European and American existing legal institutions and that is in the field of remedial law. One of the great problems of the modern legal world is that of the proper appointment, organization and procedure of the courts of law. Much of the criticism which is directed toward the law in modern days is due to the inefficiency of the legal machinery and upon examination it will be found that objection is made less to the law itself than to the manner and method by which it is administered. To what extent may the judicial system as developed in Jewish law be made the basis for a modern improved system of remedial law in Palestine? It is very likely that if due respect is paid to those branches of the substantive law which are more or less sacred to the people, that the Mohammedan as well as the Jew will welcome a new procedural system which shall insure the just, impartial and speedy administration of the law between litigants.

THE PROBLEM OF JURISDICTION

Another problem which suggests itself in this connection is the one raised by the race or religion of the litigants. Shall there be Mohemmedan courts for the Mussulman and Jewish courts for the Jew and mixed courts for causes in which the litigants are not of the same persuasion, or shall there be general courts for the administration of the general law with special courts in the nature of Ecclesiastical Courts similar to those with which we are familiar in English law, which shall have jurisdiction in those matters relating to the family and inheritance and to pure church problems?

These are interesting problems which invite speculation, for even during the interim in which Palestine is to be governed by military authority or Commissions, and even while British courts are actually administering the law, the problem of jurisdiction of the courts must be considered. Furthermore, there is the problem of jurisdiction where one of the litigants is a foreigner and a citizen of a foreign state. Is it likely that Palestine will permit the survival of the extra-territorial rights of foreigners and the extra-territorial jurisdiction of consular and other foreign courts such as exist as a result of the peculiar relation of western sovereignties in their exploitation of Oriental lands? Or will it not rather be recognized that the system of justice administered by the new Palestinian courts will be sufficiently modern and impartial to protect the rights of the foreigner in Pales-

tine even as such rights are protected by the courts of every modern civilized state?

THE LAND LAWS

Of fundamental and immediate importance is the question of the land laws of Palestine. To what extent should these be changed, to what extent can they be changed? It seems that under Turkish law Palestinian lands are held by five different tenures. Some are held in absolute ownership, others are State lands owned by the Sultan and leased for life to the tenants without right of assignment of the lease except by sovereign consent. Third, land held by the mosques and other pious establishments is leased in a manner similar to the State lands. Fourth, there are wild lands belonging to the Crown, open for settlement and cultivation and, fifth, commons such as roads, river beds, pastures and the like. The Crown and State lands would legally belong to the conqueror who succeeds to the title of the Sultan. These lands form the larger part of the Palestinian acreage. The disposition of these lands and the law concerning them will depend upon the economic policy which shall prevail. If the single tax is to be introduced, it is obvious that the land laws will be quite different than if the lands are thrown open to settlers and speculators to acquire title.

THE CRIMINAL AND COMMERCIAL LAW

The criminal law also offers many interesting problems. Shall capital punishment be abolished? To what extent shall modern principles of penology be introduced? The Jewish criminal law perhaps more than any other exists in a state of arrested development and the modern law of the Jewish State will necessarily show the widest departure from the criminal law as developed by the Talmudists which was very largely, if not entirely scholastic.

In the field of commercial law, we may expect a most advanced and modern view to be taken, for this law is cosmopolitan in its nature due to the fact that business conditions throughout the world are more or less alike and commercial intercourse today world-wide. The Biblical-Talmudic law furnishes principles basically sound but on the whole scarcely adequate to the new life of the twentieth century. The interpretation of legal conceptions is changing. Contract, property, liability are legal conceptions which will be interpreted more and more from the point of view of social solidarity rather than from the accepted and traditional point of view of the rights of the individual. The interest of the group in the contract, in the use of the property, occupies a greater segment of the juridical sphere than heretofore. Questions of liability tend to be determined by the social result of the tort rather than by the question of the negligence of the tort-feasor. It is the peculiar psychology of the groups that will occupy the land in Palestine that will determine the character of the legal conceptions that will become dominant. It is impossible to anticipate the result arising from the living together in the land, of people coming together from many other states of the world where they have lived under many different systems of law and society. The law of the Jewish State will arise as a group function and not as a deliberate creation and it is impossible to foretell how much of the resultant will be found ascribable to the traditional principles of Jewish jurisprudence.