The Maccabaean
newest authoritative views. This is illustrated in the most conservative of existing institutions, the Catholic Church. The oldest authoritative rules are laid down in the Bible, but no Catholic is orthodox if he bases his views upon the Bible. He is orthodox if he accepts the very latest statement of Papal authority on any question of dogma and faith. He is a heretic, in the Catholic sense, who believes what the Church taught in former years or will teach hereafter. An Orthodox Catholic is one who believes what the Church teaches today.
THE BIBLICAL LAW AND EVOLUTION;AN ILLUSTRATION
The Jewish Orthodox view today is obliged perforce to rely on older authorities because there exists no contemporary authority of such dignity and universality as to command acceptance of its views. Orthodox Jewish law will, therefore, demand the creation of an Orthodox Jewish tribunal or legislature before it will accept change in the law as it now.exists. But, events cannot and will not wait for the establishment of such authority. Life in Palestine will create economic problems, economic conditions will create social problems, social conditions will create legal problems and these problems will have to be solved in a rational manner. It is likely that a new common law will be developed in the new Jewish life in Palestine and that when in the course of time the state will come to consider the question of law, it will find that to a large extent the law is already made by the society that found the inevitable need to express itself. The Jewish authority which will ultimately arise will be engaged very largely in codifying the then existing new common law and thus giving to it the sanction required by Orthodoxy. To use an illustration from the Biblical and Talmudic law of damages for personal injuries. The Biblical law laid down the rule of retaliation, an eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth. The Talmudists in handling the law academically were suddenly confronted with an extraordinary dilemma because they found that the common law of the land did not recognize the Biblical law of retaliation. Instead of allowing the injured person to put out the eye or break the tooth of his aggressor, the law gave him compensation in money for the damage which he sustained. Rabbi Eliezer was the only one of the authorities who was historically right in his view that when the Biblical law said, an eye for an eye, it meant an eye for an eye and not money for an eye. But the common law prevailed. The difficulty was to reconcile the God-given Biblical law with the prevailing common law. If the Biblical law is immutable, then the law of retaliation must be enforced, but society refuses to recognize the law of retaliation and is enforcing a law of compensation in its place. The Rabbinical authorities were practical lawyers and, in the face of the necessity of preserving the law as it actually existed and the equally strong necessity of preserving respect for the unchangeability of the Biblical law notwithstanding the fact that it had been changed, they resorted to the universal expedient of interpretation in such cases and by process of reasoning reached the conclusion that when the Biblical law said an eye for an eye, it had always meant money for an eye, and could not have meant anything else. Such reasoning, though obviously historically false, is logically defensible, and its importance lies in the fact that consciously or not it recognizes the principle of evolution in the law.
LIFE THE COURT OF LAST RESORT
The changes that have taken place in the evolution of the Jewish law have been profound and due to many different causes. Ancient and local custom, legislation, judicial interpretation, foreign law and practice, academic opinion have all left unmistakable marks of their influence on the growth of the Jewish law and all of these factors together with others unnamed may be summed up under the general title of “conditions of life” and it is to them that we must look for the supreme authority, from the rulings of which there can be no deviation or appeal.
It is necessary for us to recognize the movement in the law corresponding to the movement of society and to endeavor to ascertain the trend and direction of such movement and to select those principles of the law which are applicable to the prospective change. The principles thus selected will be the permanent ones; the outgrown ones will be discarded. But it is not to be dogmatically asserted that principles once discarded may never be revived. The course and flow of the great river of life cannot be mapped out in advance and no man can with certainty declare that it will not turn in its course to come back to a place or level from which it has long departed and to which it seemingly would never return. Prophecy, or rather the tendency to indulge in it, is indeed a fatal gift. With an eye to the past and an effort to see into the immediate future, we can do no more than guess but vaguely at the events that are to come. Our visions are only our present day hopes projected by us into the future. Recognized as such they may stimulate to valiant effort but they can hardly be made the basis, in the same sense as ascertained and demonstrable facts, of a theory of life and society.
PRECEDENTS
We are not entirely without precedent as to the probable course of events in the new Palestine. They begin with a military conquest. Military authority is supreme and the law is to be found in its decrees. Then follow commissions looking to the restoration of civil rights, commissions invested either by the military authority or by the government of the conqueror with more or less legislative and administrative authority. When peace is restored, such commissions become the basis of the normal legislative authority and eventually are organized into local legislatures.
In the Spanish-American War, the Philippine Islands were subject to a military occupation. The orders promulgated by the military governor had the force of law. The Philippine Commission was appointed by the President with ample legislative and administrative powers, with the object of establishing self-government, and when peace was fully restored the Philippine legislative assembly was organized and is now the representative authority in the Islands. In this Assembly there may be found representatives of all the varied racial and religious groups that populate the Islands. It is engaged in the great task of stimulating and directing the blending of ancient local and national customs, of Mohammedan law, of Spanish law and of American law, a process not to be forced but to be studied and perhaps in a moderate degree directed. A similar process of amalgamation of apparently conflicting legal elements may be seen in all of the states in which European powers have acquired and now control large groups of Oriental peoples. The