The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXI, No. 5 · May 1918
24scan
of 24

The Maccabaean

economic relations. All his life, Mr. Lubin has been an outsider, with few connections with Jewish life. All his work has been outside of Jewish life. Whenever he has spoken on Jewish affairs, the distance from the subject was apparent. Now, honest thinker that he is, he comes out openly with the confession that his views on Zionism must be revised. Formerly he thought the Zionist program impracticable. He is now convinced that it affords a practical solution of the Jewish problem. His further participation in the Zionist movement will be awaited with interest. Mr. Lubin is too active a man to be satisfied with platonic Intaracte

Dr. Hirsch on Zionism

RESPECT for Dr. Emil G. Hirsch’s intellectual attainments and oratorical qualities should not blind one to the peculiarities of his opulent mind and of his position as a rabbi in Chicago. He is a scholar with an imagination. He is not confined to the study of ancient manuscripts, although his knowledge of ancient lore is encyclopedic. He is keenly interested in everything that happens in modern life, and is a part of the intellectual and social circles of the Middle West. But he has spoken an awful lot in his time. The most sought-after speaker in the rabbinate of the west, he has spoken on special occasions, at weddings, at funerals, sometimes impromptu and sometimes from manuscript, and a great deal of what he has said has gotten into the general press, as well as in the Jewish press. The result is that he now has a tremendous record back of him. He has already given his opinion on every subject that has troubled the conscience or the minds of his hearers. And having given expression to so much opinion, it is difficult for him, we imagine, to take an inventory of the things he believes in, and the things he is opposed to. No reform writer has written so much criticism of his own colleagues. No reform writer has spoken such kind words of orthodox Judaism, as well as so many unkind words. He has come perilously near being a Zionist several times, and then with vehemence drew away from pollution with drastic attacks. It seems part of his peculiarity to refuse to bind himself to any “ism” or any cause, and to remain until the end of time wholly himself, without entanglements or definite commitments. He wants to be a free lance. He is a rabbi and a scholar with artistic temperament. That is why it is difficult to assay the value of his most recent opinion on Zionism which appeared in the Reform Advocate on May 4th. In that article he seems to approve certain features of Zionist activity. But what of his next article?

The Zionist Medical Unit

THE sending of the Zionist Medical Unit to Palestine is the first undertaking involving a personal attempt on the part of Jews living in one part of the world concretely and physically to affect Jewish life in another part of the world. It is the projection of Jewish flesh and blood and intelligence to bolster up a weakening part of the Jewish national body. You will not find another such attempt in the history of the Jews since the beginning of the exile.

The records show the giving of money, the use of political influence, the sharing in spirit of the grief and wretched-

ness of fellow-Jews, but never an effort physically to affect Jewish life elsewhere.

7-77 saved 1116 - + LEU Le 0 0 _ Think of some of the incidents of Jewish life you know of in the present generation, and note what the Jews did to help, and you will see that more than the sending of money was seldom thought of. Occasionally, an emissary went with the money, but in the main the money was sent forth and the contributors’ went through no other experience than that of giving of their means. American Jewry raised for the victims of the Kishineff pogroms a fund of one million dollars. The money was sent to Russia, but no personal authority was exercised over the fund after it left this country. The Jews of this country derived no personal experience out of the great relief work. They were not enriched by their altruism. They knew no more of the Russian Jews after than they did before. The incident had no bearing upon the development of international Tewish relationshins.

So, too, in the general war relief work. A tremendous emotional appeal was made, and the results were registered in the millions. At first, any direct interference in the distribution of the relief was discountenanced. Expression was given to a fear that such an exhibition of direct personal interest in the distribution of relief might arouse that international feeling, which the controllers of the relief fund wished to deny. When a personal commissioner was sent to Poland, he went there with a sub-conscious feeling that the less interference there was with the distributing agencies the better. Then a few commissioners were sent to Holland, but they returned with the report that over there they could do the work much better without the untutored advice of the American contributors.

What has made the Red Cross so powerful in humanitarian work? It is its personal service. The money power it represents is the lesser of its qualities. The Red Cross is represented by the nurse, who brings succor and comfort. The consolation it brings is not in the money it possesses, but in the personal service it gives.

We take pride in the fact that the Zionist organization is the first to introduce into Jewish life the idea of the value of personal beneficence and service. The one who gives his money must also be taught that personal service and sacrifice may also be part of the gift. To alleviate Jewish conditions what we need is not so much the money to work with, but the experienced men and women capable of doing the work, and of giving up personal interest for the common weal. The barriers of political boundaries are being removed. We are making Jewish life transposable to those places where service may be rendered and where the needs of Jewish life require protection and building up.

The same principle applied elsewhere produces the Jewish Legion. It produces the Zionist Transfer Bureau. It will produce when the need develops the Zionist Engineering Corps. It will produce the Labor Army, and the regulated immigration that will emerge when the pathway to Zion is cleared of its martial incumbrances.

The Zionist Budget

T the Baltimore Conference in December it was voted A to raise one million dollars as the first instalment of the Palestine Restoration Fund. It was calculated that one million dollars would be required of American Zionists to meet obligations in sight, but there was no intimation as to how long it would take to consume that