The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXI, No. 5 · May 1918
45printed page
scan 23 of 24

The Maccabaean

Palestine Not a Gift

VERY Jew understands that Palestine is not to be a EL free gift to the Jewish people. As Charles Boissevain, the Dutch journalist, said in a recent article: “They (the Jews) have paid for it long ago and they are paying for it now in the war.” And they shall have to pay for it in order to hold it. Not as petitioners nor as beggars are the Jews to come back into their own national possessions. The pioneers entered Palestine on the title of their ancestors, by the rights accruing to the Jewish people through wrongs inflicted, but the pioneers established the title of the present generation by their labors. In the great war, the men who gave their lives at Gallipoli made their contribution in the name of the Jews, and now every man enlisting in the Jewish Legion places everything he possesses to the credit of the Jewish people, to hold the Palestinian frontiers. The Zionist Commission will have to earn Palestine for us before it actually becomes ours. The Medical Unit will be another capital investment. And more will be asked of us. England has opened the gate so that the Jewish people may enter freely and through work and sacrifices acquire a lastine title to the land in their own name.

The Mizrachi Convention

T the Mizrachi convention held in Philadelphia, a A resolution seems to have been adopted endorsing the single tax system of taxation of land, but it does not appear that there was much discussion or that the delegates seriously considered its implications. The question of land tenure in Palestine is to come up at the Pittsburgh convention, and will be discussed from every point of view, including the point of view of the single tax. A decision by the Pittsburgh convention, at which the Mizrachi is to be represented, will be the deliberate judgment of American Zionists, which will be transmitted to Dr. Weizmann for his guidance. The activities of the Mizrachi during the year, as reported at the convention, showed progress in every direction. There is still lacking sound organization, for the convention was brought together with a certain degree of freedom and absence of organization rules, but it was quite representative of Mizrachi strength, and the discussion showed a keen comprehension of the need for political foresight and disciplined action in the Zionist movement. Much emphasis was placed upon the peace that had been made with the general Zionist organization, and Rabbi Berlin is entitled to great credit for sagacity in his general handling of the whole subject.

Zionist Reorganization

THE feature of the reorganization plan of the American Zionist organization is the District Unit, which is to supersede the society unit. Actually, the District Unit will not take the place of the society. It is to be the unit representative of the organized Zionists of every community, irrespective of the number of societies. As the organization stands now, it is composed of social or educational groups actively engaged in Zionist affairs. To become a member in any one of these groups one must be in harmony, not with their Zionist aims, but with their social conditions. Thus, in a city where only Yiddish-speaking Zionists are organized in a society, the English-speaking Zionists cannot enroll in the Zionist movement unless they

too form a group of their own. Admission into such specialized groups depends upon compatibility of social habits, and not primarily upon Zionist interests. The District Unit will be the form that will unite all elements and varieties of Jewish personality without qualifications into one organization, which will bear the impress not of one social group but of all elements in the Jewish population of the community. The Zionist organization will thus become the channel through which all Jewish Zionist interests may easily and without obstacles express themselves. To be an organized Zionist will imply membership in the Zionist District organization, and not in the Dorshei Zion or Herzl Zionist Club; and the member will feel his allegiance not particularly to his club, but generally to the Zionist movement. The District Plan is being discussed with animation in all Zionist circles. Doubtless the plan as outlined may be improved, but in its general aspects it points the way to such a reorganization of the movement as will lead to notable results in membership when it becomes the fundamental law of the movement in this country,

Georg Brandes a Zionist

EORG BRANDES, the eminent literary critic and )2 historian, whose whole life has been absorbed in the literatures of the various nationalities of Europe, has announced his conversion to Zionism. Brandes was not an assimilator, he had been assimilated. Jewish problems never interested him, because Jewish life never affected him personally, and he had other interests. His interests were with the Poles and their literature, with the Germans and their literature, with the French and the English and their literatures, but of Jews and their literature he knew nothing. Everything Jewish was more foreign than Chinese to him. He first sensed the Jewish problem when he lectured in the United States and the indifference and criticism of Jews irritated him. When he returned to Europe, something Jewish in him had been stirred and he spoke out for the Polish Jews. Thereupon his Polish friends became his enemies. The world war has opened his eyes. It has taught him more than he ever learned from books. His conversion is openly and frankly stated in an article which has been published in this country by The American Hebrew. The bigness of Brandes’ character is shown in the way he speaks of his former ideas, and his unqualified approval of the Zionist cause.

Another Distinguished Convert

SOME years ago a book entitled "Let there be Light" appeared in the United States, written by a California merchant, who had retired from business to devote himself to public affairs. The book was an honest attempt to get at a new definition of Jewish religion, or to promulgate new views regarding religion. It was not very well received because it lacked the influence of individual religious experience, being merely an intellectual exercise, an attempt to reconcile Jewish ideas with Greek philosophy. Since that time the author, Mr. David Lubin, has been devoting himself to international political economic problems. As the founder of the Agricultural Institute at Rome, Italy, he has set on its feet an organization which aims to stabilize the prices of staple food articles. He has given a great deal of intelligent study to these problems, and is now regarded as one of the foremost minds in the fields of international