The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXI, No. 4 · April 1918
8scan
of 29
Facsimile · scan 8 of 29
Scan of scan 8
Text · transcribed from the scan

THE MACCABAEAN

sible unless they are commonly held and uttered. But in the possession of tools and material rests the indispensable condition for that liberation of the spontaneous energies of men which create cultures. The injustice of all societies derives from the limitation to a few of this possession and its benefits. Most ownership consists in preventing the other fellow from using what one cannot use oneself. Already in the beginnings of civilization we see the bulk of the tools and materials of life as the private property of a few peoples and of a few individuals among those peoples. And we see as a consequence of this limitation of ownership the rank and file of mankind dependent upon and subject to the minorities of privilege, starved in their needs and repressed in their creative powers. It is precisely this condition that the prophets of Israel denounced and fought. And the history of democracy is largely a record of a similar fight, on the part of the expropriated everywhere to recover control of the necessary external conditions of life without which freedom and happiness cannot come to be. The success of this fight is marked by the progressive, everextending application of the principle of “eminent domain,” by the socialization of what is private in the material and tools of life. An excellent example of this process is the history of the law of the United States concerning public carriers. And the name of additional ones is legion. In sum—the equality with which all men are created and to which all are entitled is not similarity. It is an equality not internal, but external; it is an equality of condition, not an equality of nature. Where it exists the inner diversities, the individualities among men, have the widest possible opportunity for creative self-expression and vigorous growth.

Hence when we say that each individual has an inalienable right to life, we mean that he has an inalienable right to social insurance of the best external conditions of life—the best food, clothing, shelter and defence against disease, old age and accident, against crime and war. In this consists the property right of each individual. In this and no more. When we say that all men, again, have an inalienable right to liberty we mean an inalienable right to the free and creative self-expression in living, to the "liberal life," which is the consequence of the economic security of life. This self-expression has many and various elements. Basic are freedom of movement, of association, of conscience and worship, of the choice of employment, of speech, of pen, of publication. These elements are usually called the constitutional rights of individuals.

3. THE NATURE AND FUNCTION OF THE STATE.

It is the function of the state to keep these rights secure. This function is highly specialized and very definite. It cannot be mistaken for any other. Yet there exists a very potent and to democracy highly dangerous conception of the nature of the state which has its most impressive incarnation in Germany and of which the ideals of the orthodox socialists, no less than of military imperialists, are promulgations. This conception sees the state as a synthesis of all associations of men, a whole greater than the sum of its parts, including society and ruling it. It sees the political organization coincident with every other, and administering all in its own association. From its point of view every individual, every association of individuals, would be a servant of the state and government would be the seat and source

of all social power. The effect of such a condition on individuals may be observed in the history of Germany since 1870, and in the history of democratic states since the beginning of the Great War. The historic record is in itself a denunciation of this centralist conception of the nature of the state and its function. Nothing has shown itself as more repressive of the spontaneous individuality of men than states to which society has surrendered all its prerogatives and powers. Socialism of the extremist type needs no completer refutation than this record.

No. The state is one form of human association among many other forms of association. Men are not merely and exclusively citizens. They are Jews, Arabs, Armenians, Englishmen, Slavs, Turks, sons, fathers, farmers, teachers, religionists, musicians, athletes, scientists, philosophers. Each of these words stands for a form of association with other men. Each association is defined by the particular purpose it serves, by the function it exercises. Nationality, vocation, profession, avocation, church are, as forms of association, the peers of the state. They possess each intrinsic and autonomous function in the realization of their several purposes. The state possesses its own unique function in the realization of its purpose.

This function—to keep secure for men their inalienable rights—may be called the administration of justice. It is a negative rather than a constructive function, preventive rather than active. The best conceivable symbol of a truly efficient democratic state is the traffic policeman. What does the traffic policeman do? Regulate the movement of pedestrians and vehicles. Why? So that each may move as freely and swiftly as possible. Fancy a busy crossing without such regulation: a hundred vehicles of different sorts going in every possible direction; a thousand pedestrians of different sorts going in every possible direction; and each intent upon his own special way and purpose. Without regulation collisions and conflicts would be inevitable. With collisions and conflicts would come the complete paralysis of all movement. It is the business of the trafic policeman to keep the ways open, to facilitate the free movement of each vehicle and each pedestrian to his chosen destination. That is his business and only that. He is not concerned about where they are going, or why. He is only concerned that they shall go freely, without interfering with or blocking each other. ,

So also with the state. The function of the state is as definite and as limited as that of the traffic policeman. It is to keep the ways of life open to the free movement toward the expression and fulfilment of their natural capacities by individuals and groups. The state has no business with what these social units are, what they want, how they get what they want. Its sole business is to facilitate their being and getting, by keeping the ways open, by preventing collisions, conflicts and blockades. Private ownership in community values, privilege of any sort have been the greatest historic causes of collisions and blockades, of the arrest of the vital movement of the masses of men, of its dispersion and reduction to impotence. It is the state’s most important function, where these exist to abolish them; where they do not exist to prevent them from arising. A state is a Commonwealth.

(To be concluded in the next issue.)