THE MACCABAEAN
2. THE BASIS OF INJUSTICE IN STATES AND HOW TO AVOID IT.
It is a truism that the semblance of democracy is compatible with a high degree of the existence of its actual opposite. The charge of Socialism against most so-called democratic states is that political freedom is a device for maintaining economic serfdom. Most students of American history are familiar with Charles Beard's disillusioning analysis of the casual motives behind the American Constitution, and the declaration and program of the British Labor Party are current great news of the attempt to get real democracy in the most democratic country in Europe. That economic democracy is the only sort of democracy which can be efficacious is a commonplace. The problem is primarily—how is it to be obtained?
It is not necessary to discuss the alternative theories that underlie the programs of reform of certain active parties. The state socialism of the Bolsheviki, the guild-socialism of the British Labor Party, the syndicalism of France and the Single Tax theory of the American Single Taxers. It is necessary to find the common point of departure and to get something more than a sentimental perception of the ultimate ideal they aim at.
That ultimate ideal they all call, of course, democracy. It postulates a certain equality in mankind which is splendidly summed up in the American Declaration of Independence. Thus: All men are created equal and are endowed by their creator with certain inalienable rights; among these rights are life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. To secure these rights governments are established among men resting on the consent of the governed.
The word “equal” in the declaration is, however, ambiguous. From the context the equality would seem to be political only, yet its implications are obviously economic. In fact that is, in view of the time, place, and circumstances of the Declaration—“equal” had only a political meaning. It is only by abstracting from these conditions of its formulation that the formula may be used as a Charter for Mankind. Its background is a certain theory of the “natural rights” of men. This theory declared that the differences between men are not primary but secondary; not internal but external. In “The state of nature” all men are equal and all men are alike. It is the superstructure of civilization that makes them unequal and dissimilar, imposing upon them as it does, the exploitations of the state, the church, industry and the society. As a consequence of this idea, much influential democratic thinking in both the economic and the political fields has identified democracy with equality, and equality with similarity. Current conceptions of democracy, particularly in America, involve the notion that all men are the same, and that any program or event is democratic which helps to render this sameness actual and evident. Such programs usually go by the name “Americanization.”
In effect, however, such an ideal only substitutes the tyranny of majorities for the tyranny of minorities. The imposition of internal or external sameness is 85 anti-democratic as the imposition of external or internal difference among men. Nor is it alone anti-democratic. It
is contrary to the principle of progress which, the biologists and the sociologists agree, governs the evolution of life and of human society. Both diversify. In biology similarity and uniformity characterize the lowest living organisms: the higher you go in the scale of evolution, the greater the differentiation and specialization of types, the more important become difference and individuality. In the history of societies the same principle holds true. Primitive societies are amorphous, undifferentiated, tyrannous to individuality. Progress from primitive to modern societies has meant differentiation—differentiation showing itself in the multiplication of social institutions, in the division of labor, in the liberation and protection of individuality. The individualities of men, their natural endowments, qualities, and characters are the most important things they bring each other. They are the basis of co-operation and community. In so far as men are the same, have the same natures, want the same things, do the same work, live the same lives, they are either indifferent to one another or enemies and rivals to one another. All competition, whether in commerce, industry, art, or thought, depends upon this sameness. When, on the other hand, men are different from one another, are possessed of non-interchangeable individualities or functions, or both, they are not rivals but team-mates. Baker competes with baker, not with butcher; butcher competes with butcher, not with shoemaker; shoemaker competes with shoemaker, not with carpenter. And so on. In so far as men are diverse, individual not merely in their vocations but in their natures, they need one another, are interdependent and co-operative. In so far as they are similar, they are competitors. The true meaning of democracy is the liberation, encouragement and perfection of differences among men, the increase of human individuality and spontaneity, and hence of human co-operation.
All injustice in states and other forms of organized society reduces itself to the wilful or accidental failure to accomplish this end. And the reason-is this. The world we live in is not one that was made for us; it is one in which we happened and grew. To live in it at all, not to speak of living in it well, men had to change it, and civilization is the name they give to the changes they made and continue to make in it. All their changes in the external world are intended to sustain the internal quality of the diversified total of human life. This sustenance consists of food, clothing, shelter, defence against enemies, natural and human. Where the defence is adequate, the inward quality of men manifests itself freely in the creation of those spiritual values that we call the cultures of peoples. The achievements of civilization fall, broadly speaking, into two classes—tools designed to use and to humanize the raw material of nature; and cultures, designed to utter and to elaborate the inward qualities of human nature. Tools tend to uniformity everywhere; a knife or a steam engine is the same in Russia as in America; cultures tend to diversity everywhere; languages, literatures, music, differ widely from Russia to America. Tools are inventions compelled by the necessity of adapting external nature to human uses. Cultures are free creations of the spontaneous spirit of men. Tools and materials are capable of being property, private exclusive possessions. Cultures are impos-
