The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXI, No. 3 · March 1918
81printed page
scan 13 of 24
Facsimile · scan 13 of 24
Scan of p. 81
Text · transcribed from the scan

THE MACCABAEAN

of Jewry differ as much in belief as Catholics from Mohammedans? How is it that some practically agree in belief with Unitarians? Or perhaps your conception of religion is that it connotes a series of forms, ceremonies and set prayers? This conception I have often heard among Jews, who mean, by 'being religious,' the scrupulous observance of Jewish religious forms. If they are right, they can be only partly right, since the observance of forms and ceremonies has always only a relative value, relative to the conception which they express. What is that conception? How is it that Orthodox Jews and Reform Jews, who deny true religion to each other, when they happen to be anti-Zionists both accuse Zionists of being anti-religious? And yet there are Reform Jews and Orthodox Jews among the Zionists.

"Having asked you all these questions, which I shall not permit you to answer, I will now tell you my conception of the relation of Jewish religion to Jewish people.

“Religion is based on historical developments, hence only history can explain it. And since I take it for granted that you believe the Jewish religion to be based upon the Jewish Bible, I will deal with history as verified or interpreted in that book. Religion in ancient times was among the heathen peoples a national matter. Their god or gods were the protectors or ancestors of the people, who had made that nation and who for its sake would willingly destroy all others. When two nations fought, the stronger god prevailed. Israel brought a new conception into the world, that of a universal God, a God of all nations. No doubt this conception grew out of a still earlier primitive belief in the Lord as the deity of Israel alone. But Israel was chosen from among the nations to recognize in its tribal deity the one God of all the world, who was not for one nation and against another, but for righteousness and against injustice, wherever found. Israel was superior only so long as it held to and practiced that belief.

"The Bible, like the bulk of mankind since its time, accepted the fact of nations as spiritual entities, as collective individuals, but moralized that conception as it moralized the relation between man and man. And the place of Israel among the nations—according to the Bible—is as a nation, a people, that shall carry out the laws of God in its national life and so be a constant historical spectacle—a sort of morality play—for the nations of the world until they, too, shall walk in the way of the Lord. It is this conception of justice, as applied not only to individuals but to nations, to international as well as intranational affairs, that makes the greatness of the Hebrew prophets and of the Hebrew people. So much for our 'mission,' as expressed in the Bible. I will not here stop to indicate to you the prophecies of its fulfillment through Zion, which form part of the traditional Jewish religion. I want to sketch rapidly the way in which this conception worked in world history throughout postbiblical times. Religion is a national matter. All ancient peoples took that for granted. When the Roman Empire came into power, it acted consciously and unconsciously on that assumption. All ancient peoples yielded their gods to the Roman gods, and Rome, the tolerant, magnanimously allowed them to exist side by side. But Judaea would have no 'side by side.' It alone stood out for the right of complete national autonomy, against imperialism, for the 'rights of the small nations.' When Rome set up emperor worship, as a means of unifying the empire, Judaea alone refused this uplifting Kultur of unity. And

what was Christianity? Paul, the Jew, the Roman citizen, at last created a Roman religion worthy to give unity to the great Roman Empire. It was a religion of personal submission to empire, a 'universal' religion for a universal empire. And Roman Catholicism, with its lust of conversion, was the spiritual and political heir of the early Roman Empire. What was the Protestant Reformation but the rebirth of nationalism in northern Europe and the breaking away from that empire? These are suggestions based on known facts, not original with me and too obvious for argument. One of our modern students of religious science* has said: 'Religion is the soul of a people.' If today religious conceptions are in a turmoil, it is because conceptions and developments of nationalism are also in a turmoil. Religion is the deepest concern of the individual because it is his relating bond, first with the community, and through the community with the universe, with God. But it is not an individual affair. A savage in an African jungle, no matter how moral or how wise, could not be a monotheist. That is a conception worked out slowly through the experience of peoples. One can no more be religious alone than one can be political alone.

"The Jewish position is clear—at least to Zionists. We are unshaken by the modern turmoil in our conception of nation and religion. It is the religion of our nation to remain a people dedicated to the service of God through the justice and universal validity of our national and social institutions. This we can fully express only in national life. Hence we have held on, through two thousand years of torture and discouragement, to our national identity, to our national duty. We have used all means to that end—except only murder and apostasy, which are forbidden. Our ceremonials, our prayers, our literature, our communities, our separatism—all these are to be measured and judged by their relation to this passion for the service of God and humanity through national life. We must distinguish between means and ends.

"And that end is the end for which the nations now say they are fighting, but in which the Jewish people lives and has its being.

"Our prophets taught the moral obligations of all peoples, and international lawfulness —freedom within self-acknowledged law.

"Now I can answer you, sentence by sentence.

"(8) We are a religious nation. It is our mission as a nation to teach, or show, righteousness and justice to the nations. Unless we believe in this religious mission of the Jewish nation, we relinquish the Jewish religious idea of all time. Our leaders are not unreligious, since this is their conception and since they act and live for that end. Belief and ceremony are only means to service. And individuals alone cannot be 'missionaries' of a religion whose scope includes every phase of national life.

"(9) Our religion is universal. But being human, it must have a dwelling place in the heart and hearth of a people, whence it can have the freedom of the world. Today Judaism is everywhere provincial because it is everywhere separatist. The God of the whole world is also the God of every tribe and child who recognizes him.

"(10) If our ethics and religion could not stand the strain of politics and politicians, then they could have no spiritual, no 'missionary' value in a world of politics and politicians. The Jewish religion is not a delicate household

* Dr. M. M. Kaplan, who is responsible for this theory.