The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXI, No. 3 · March 1918
80printed page
scan 12 of 24
Facsimile · scan 12 of 24
Scan of p. 80
Text · transcribed from the scan

THE MACCABAEAN

only on the Jews in Palestine; in a few generations all other Jews will depend upon them.

“As for (2), I am not a separatist. I am an internationalist by birth and by education, as a Jew. I believe with the prophets that humanity is one as God is one. Our life both in our own land and elsewhere has brought this home to us, as we have always mingled with many peoples, and probably always shall. But also with the prophets I believe that internationalism implies the existence of free, orderly, self-respecting nations, of which the normal Jewish nation is to be one. I believe not only in the brotherhood of man but in the brotherhood of nations, and I do not see why the Jew—who originated this idea—should believe in and belong to every nation except his own. As for the separatism of the Jews, it has existed ever since we lost our national independence, and, while I deplore its necessity, I see that it will have to continue until we are firmly and normally re-established in our own land. The long dispersion forced separatism upon us, as the only means of keeping our identity, of continuing to live. When our customs, laws and ceremonies again develop or change as naturally in our own land as those of all other peoples, the need for separatism will everywhere disappear.

“Our foes tried to destroy us and failed. But if you had your way, we should succeed better than our foes.

--אשסששת=ח=תתתם₪₪ “You misquote me in your third point. I never said we were a race, and, indeed, I have very little interest in the subject. To prove or disprove it has no effect upon my thesis. I say we are a people, a nation. This is a psychological fact in which race plays only a minor part. What other nation belongs to one unmixed race? It was only when, about a century ago, a section of our people in Western Europe began through oppression to lose their hold on their own Jewish identity, that their enemies, unable longer to persecute them for a washed-out nationalism and an emasculated religion, invented for them the Semitic race. Having lost every spiritual peg on which to hang their Jew-baiting, they invented the physical basis of Semitism. No wonder Jewish anthropologists find in necessary to disprove the existence of the Jewish race! But nationalism is based upon common history, traditions, sufferings, laws, language, race, land, religion, or any one or a few of these. Any section of humanity that feels itself to be a nation is a nation. And the Jews as a whole have never ceased to feel themselves a nation or to be so regarded by all the rest of humanity.

“Your fourth indictment is that Zionism is the result of anti-Semitism. When anti-Semitism made its peace-offensive about a century ago, there were several different reactions among Jews. The reaction of the loyalists later shaped itself into Zionism. The reaction of the frightened and semi-loyal was Reform Judaism, and the reaction of the terribly frightened and disloyal was assimilation. No, it is not quite so simple either. Some disloyalty was also caused by disgust at the antics of Jews themselves. There were the disgustingly servile and the hopelessly antiquated. Zionism and anti-Zionism are equally reactions against anti-Semitism. But Zionism acts because it has something Jewish to save, anti-Zionism because it has nothing Jewish to lose. The destruction of the Jewish state was an anti-Semitic act. When a just restitution is made, Zionism as a movement will no doubt disappear. The Lord made a promise to our Patriarchs in the land of Canaan. When did he redeem it? When anti-Semitism

called his attention to the Jews in Egypt. Yet no one would say that Pharaoh was responsible for the birth and the ideals of the Jewish nation.

"There are two answers to persecution, a negative and a positive.

"As for magnifying anti-Semitism, that I do no more than you—rather less. Zionists are normal in these as in other things. They vary as individuals. But their tendency is to disregard what others do to harm us, to believe that the greatest harm or good to Judaism comes from within ourselves. Zionism is strongest in those countries where the Jews are freest. It is one phase of Jewish emancipation.

“Why do you always misquote me? Am I not voluble enough to be understood? I do not—as you say in (5)— ask the allegiance of Jews in other lands to a Jewish State. I ask all Jews, citizens of many lands, to help with influence and wealth in the re-establishment of the Jewish homeland in Palestine. I ask only those to go there—no, I need not even ask them—who wish and long to go there and express the Jewish soul. Until the day they leave, their political allegiance will be to the land of their birth or adoption. There can be only one political allegiance. Americans of Greek, Irish, Polish, Albanian descent, who have worked for the freedom of their people in its old homeland, are never for that reason accused of disloyalty to America. No, their double proof of loyalty is doubly valued. Theirs is a chivalrous deed that wins admiration. Our government has said as much of Zionism. And many of our foremost Zionists are also among the foremost of American patriots.

EE “To belong to and work for the Zionist cause no more conflicts with the duties of American citizenship than to belong to organizations working against child labor and exploitation of women, or for industrial democracy, international education, scientific pursuits, or for any other purposes furthering human justice or well being.

"You say—in (6)—that I cause disunity in Judaism. But why I, more than you? Agree with me, and there will be unity. I can prove that my attitude toward the question long antedates yours. It dates back to the days of Moses. But life is more important even than unity. Indeed, the only hope for progress lies in disunity, in minorities. And today—considering the moribund state of some sections of Jewry—the only possible unity in Judaism would be the peace of death. If I disturb that unity, I am happy.

"But I do not—as you say in (7)—wish to reunite church and state. Nor could I, if I would. You are right that theocracy in that sense is a thing of the past. A Jewish autonomous state—no one can doubt—would be democratically governed, by representatives of all the inhabitants, Jewish and non-Jewish. But I do wish to reunite nation and religion—which are quite different things from church and state.

“In (8) you deal with religion, but you never define it. No wonder! Wiser heads than yours and mine have struggled in vain to find the proper terms. But evidently you mean by religion something which it has never meant to the Jewish mind—something I do not understand. You say we are not a people but a religious sect; then you say that our Zionist leaders are unreligious. In that case, to be logical, they are not Jews. Are they Jews? If Jewish religion is only a form of belief—your belief— then all who do not share it are not Jews. Is that true? If your premise is correct, how is it that different sections