THE MACCABAEAN
days even that was something new and appealing, for whatever clubs and organizations of Jewish boys and girls existed, were everything but Jewish in spirit. But as time went on the Y. M. H. A. and a multitude of other organizations gradually caught the spirit of our renaissance and introduced the study of Jewish history, the celebration of Jewish holidays and the discussion of Jewish questions—to be sure, in a very mild and perfectly innocuous form—in their programs. The demand then arose in Young Judaea to make the organization openly Zionistic. There was a strong and determined opposition to this, but the point was finally carried after some stormy scenes at an annual convention.
Nevertheless, many felt that Young Judaea had not gone far enough yet—that it was not occupying its proper position in the scheme of the Zionist movement. Only last year the writer had occasion to voice a widespread demand for greater intensivity, in an open letter addressed to Young Judaea leaders and delegates!
“The first mistaken notion which should be mercilessly attacked is that Young Judaea’s work should be extensive rather than intensive. The usual line of thought is this. The Hebrew Schools and Talmud Torahs do not, apparently cannot, reach all or even a majority of our boys and girls. Here Young Judaea should supplement the work of the Jewish schools by attempting to give a ‘smattering’ of Jewish knowledge and sentiment to the thousands who would otherwise be entirely uncared for. It is therefore not to be expected of our clubs that they should ‘show results’ such as classes would. Whatever they do, it is ‘better than nothing’ provided they keep the children off the street and occasionally let them hear a Yiddish vort.
“This is, I believe, an erroneous and mischievous attitude to assume, if for no other reason because Young Judaea has not the means for undertaking such a stupendous task and doing it well. We cannot hope to organize in the near future the hundreds of thousands of children whom we should reach. Our task should rather be intensive. We should work with small numbers to the end that these few may become the standard-bearers of the Jewish renaissance. We should strive to train an efficient, though small, army of Jewish nationalists, rather than fritter our energies in doling out occasional tea- spoonfuls of diluted milk—and water Judaism. A limited number of clubs, each with a small membership, but well knit and doing intensive work—that should be our program.”
Events since the time those words were written lend them additional emphasis. Already Zionism—that is a sort of pale, diluted and attenuated Zionism has been accepted by many organizations hitherto “Jewish” or “Hebrew”—organizations with more means at their disposal than Young Judaea can at present command.
Can Young Judaea stand still or mark time? No. It must step into the place that the logic of events has created for it. Its function in the body politic of the new Jewish nation must change. It must provide us with the right kind of human material, properly trained and equipped for the peaceful conquest of Palestine after the war.
Space will not permit us to consider here in detail the methods to be employed. That there will have to be a great readjustment is evident. The attack will have to be made first of all psychologically, because of the reluctance on the part of a certain section of our people to emigrate to Palestine is not due to economic or rationalistic considerations, but to the psychological
remoteness of the Holy Land. Palestine with its parks and its deserts, with its beauty and its desolation, with its blue skies and scorching sun, with its prosperous Jewish colonies and slattern Arab villages, with its joyous songs and its grim conflicts, with its sturdy Jewish settlers and its overwhelmingly larger Arab population, with its beating seas and parching droughts,—the real Palestine, as it is, with its lights and shadows, must be lifted out of its corner in Asia and transplanted into the hearts of our future pioneers.
It may prove best to organize uniformed troops of Pioneer Boys and Pioneer Girls, who will do a great part of their work in the open and help to bring the members nearer to the soil. It will be necessary to produce a new type of literature for them. Efforts will have to be made to so influence them in choosing their vocations or professions, that they will prove of real value to our Yishub, as experts in the various branches of agriculture, industry and commerce.
But the objections to this plan—.
Yes, of course. Has there ever been something worthwhile accomplishing that was not bristling with difficulties? They will have to be faced. Already I can imagine some that are likely to be met. How, for instance, will the American government look upon this effort to remove a few thousand young people of the best calibre from its population?
My answer is that America is great enough to spare them—especially since they are Jews who, we are constantly assured, constitute a problem for assimilation. America spares thousands of young people annually who choose to settle in foreign parts. Its missionaries alone are considerable in number.
Will not this plan take years to work out?
Most certainly. Palestine cannot be built in a day any more than Rome was. But—“prepare at leisure, repent in haste.”
What if Palestine is not turned over to the Jewish people at least for colonization immediately after this war?
Even if we should be doomed to such a crushing disappointment, we will never for an instant lay down our arms. We must simply go on preparing, toiling patiently, and waiting for future developments. We must continue our training of pioneers for later eventualities.
But—and this is the heavy artillery pitilessly trained on so many of our fond schemes—but your plan will demand money, large sums of money!
Aye, it will. But a better investment could never be made by any nation. These pioneers are to be, if you will, our army. Consider the crushing burden of armaments for even the tiniest of states.
We will have to cease thinking of the problems of Young Judaea as merely a question of Jewish education, and consider them as a question of Jewish statecraft. Young Judaea is not a toy, a plaything to be regarded with indulgent smiles by a complacent administration. It is a movement fraught with the greatest significance for our national regeneration, and merits the most serious and painstaking consideration.