The Maccabaean · Vol. XXX, No. 6 · June 1917
85printed page
scan 43 of 70

Young Judaea and Jewish Statecraft

A MONG the innumerable lessons taught by the great cataclysm there is one which has found expression in a terse and forceful epigram: "Prepare at leisure, repent in haste." We Jews, more than any other people have learned to appreciate fully the bitter truth contained therein. We had but hastened our preparations, if we had organized and mobilized our national resources earlier, if instead of the hundred thousand pioneers whom we had in Palestine in August, 1914, we had had a half million—how much more secure would our position have been to-day!

We must not repeat the mistake: We are not repeating it. We are carefully planning to meet the exigencies of the historic moment when the fate of Palestine is to be settled, and there is certainly good cause to feel optimistic about the outcome of our political activity.

There is, however, one weak link in the chain which we are forging. Granting that a way will be found by the powers to make possible the realization of Zionist hopes and granting furthermore that there will be no lack of financial support, the Jewish millionaires and the millions of Jews will combine to provide the vast sums, hundreds, if not thousands of millions of dollars, which will have to be made available for colonization on a grand scale—granting that we succeed thus far, what then? More important than either of the above two requisites is a third indispensable essential, one, moreover, that cannot be bought by gold or created at a moment's notice—men!

For let us not delude ourselves. The Palestine which will be thrown open for colonization at the conclusion of this war, will not be one to attract the ordinary immigrant seeking merely economic opportunities. If Palestine is to be settled, fructified and made attractive, if it is to be prepared for a mass immigration in later years—it will have to be done by a selected few, by pioneers.

Moreover, the dynamic energy liberated by grinding persecution exerted over a large, dense multitude of Jews in Russia, will be greatly abated with the spread of the Jewish population over the whole Russian Empire and their growing economic and political strength. We will be compelled then to fall back upon the idealistic strain of the Jew's character—a strain, thank Heaven, still strong and virile. Not merely Russian Jewry but every large Jewish community will have to produce its quota for the colonization of the Holy Land, even as Jerusalem was repeopled from the population of provincial towns in the days of Nehemiah.

But who shall be the pioneers? Who shall be the young men and women to leave behind them the ease and comfort of urban life in the advanced civilizations of Europe and America to rear a new civilization in Palestine? Who is to brave the hardships of a new climate, of a strange soil, of primitive environments,

June-July, 1917

of probable difficulties with untractable neighbors? Who is to be content to toil physically so that Palestine may be built up not only for the Jewish people but also by the Jewish people?

No doubt we have a large number of idealists in our midst who will be prepared literally to sacrifice themselves for the cause. Already young men and middle aged men have begun to band themselves together for this very purpose. But we, as an organization, as a nation, cannot rely upon these haphazard, sporadic and spasmodic efforts of individuals, no matter how well intentioned they may be.

Surely we have not forgotten the lessons of the early years of our colonization work in Palestine. Can we afford to repeat those ghastly blunders? Shall we dump into an unknown country an unorganized and untrained mass of eager enthusiasts? Can we repeat the mistakes of Hedera and of Sedjera? Can we spare the money, the energy, the lives, likely to be wasted through such efforts?

There is only one possible answer,—one inevitable conclusion. We must begin at once to train our future Palestinian pioneers. We must begin with boys and girls still in their adolescence and educate them (1) to regard this pioneer work as the goal of their personal ambitions, and (2) to prepare rationally and systematically for this national service. We must have an efficiently conducted agency which shall keep this object steadily in view, and coordinate all its activities with this central and supreme purpose.

The logical agency for this most important piece of work is Young Judaea, which is at the present moment both the junior department and the education de- Federation of American Zionists. omité and its branch organizations and financial aspects of our treet Young Judaea train the pioneers. in line with the growing tendency among the Zionist Organizations. patriot will deny the assertion that people should, as far as possible, be its best powers for the next few upon this one gigantic task: the he Jewish Homeland:

Such a modification in the purposes of Young Judaea would also result in tremendous good to itself. It would introduce a new heroic strain in its appeal and invest all its activities with a new, direct, and tangible meaning. In fact, Young Judaea must progress to this advanced position. Ever since its inception there has been a steady, irresistible drift toward a more intense and more zealous conception of its mission and place in Jewish life—a Jewish Drang nach Osten.

In the beginning—this should be known—Young Judaea was merely a "Jewish" organization. In those

EMANUEL NEUMANN Editor, Young Judaean
Two-eighty-three