The Maccabaean · Vol. XXX, No. 5 · May 1917
37printed page
scan 15 of 24
Facsimile · scan 15 of 24
Scan of p. 37
Text · transcribed from the scan

THE MACCABAEAN

servative or moderately liberal men like the Octobrists would plead for the emancipation of the Jews.

---------- OR we BRE aN 8 >> 415 We iw aw lh ve The course of events proved that the Association was right in its defiant attitude towards non-democratic parties. It developed that the more democratic the party, the more certain was its stand with regard to the Jewish question. Those who based their scepticism toward democracy on the fact that it offered no guarantee against Jew hatred and that therefore the Jews should not let themselves be blinded by the democratic parties, neglected to take one important political axiom into consideration, namely, that of proportionateness. It is true that even democratic elements are not by any means free from prejudice against Jews; its true that in the radical ranks of the Russian people, strong anti-Semitic inclinations are evident. An examination of the Pogroms and their attendant circumstances will reveal numerous attestations to this fact. In the fall of 1905, when a. well-known Zionist accused the radical elements at one of the largest protest meetings in Petrograd of not having done their full duty during the horrible Jewish massacre, the fair-minded among them were forced to admit the justice of this accusation; although it is a historic fact that a number of non-Jewish intellectuals and workmen had fought and sacrificed their lives in attempting to stem the attack against the Tews.

An investigation of later date held among the students of a Russian Secondary school, brought to light the significant fact that 33 per cent of the Constitutional Democrats, 7 per cent of the Social Revolutionaries, and 4 per cent of the Social Democrats were against the emancipation of the Jews.

On the other hand this same investigation as well as Russian political life as a whole have proved that the denial of rights to the Jews received the strongest support, relatively, from those who were politically most retrogressive. The further one looked to the “right,” the greater was the percentage of those who favored special legislation for the Jews; at the extreme wing of the “rights” there were scarcely any who desired to grant more extensive privileges to the Jews, whereas even among the Octobrists the supporters of Jewish emancipation were extremely few in number. Even the so-called “Progressists’—a party which must not be confused with the progressive Duma block, but which forms a large part of it—were formerly not to be relied upon when it came to the Jewish question. Although they were outspokenly opposed to the old régime, and, especially in time of war, energetic in their demands for comprehensive reforms, for instance, for a responsible cabinet, etc., they expressed themselves as being in favor of a slow and gradual emancipation of the Jews, and adhered to their principle for years, in that they were careful not to be stigmatized with the reproach of befriending the Jews.

It was only the democratic parties which really took every opportunity, even during the reactionary periods, to protest against Jewish persecution, and to demand that the status of the Jews be changed. Their resoluteness corresponded to their radical stand in general political questions. Thus, it was not the absolute but the relative attitude toward the Jewish question which served as a measure of trustworthiness at the Duma elections, and these political experiences will surely be repeated to a certain extent when the question of national rights will be regulated. The occurrences of a former day will echo through the glorious world of Russian freedom time and time again.

The idea of national autonomy found its most radical expression in a Jewish group composed of Zionists with a certain admixture of germane elements, which according to statistics, numbered 15 to 16 thousand adherents in 1906. These were the so-called Seimists* who made the most comprehensive demands for Jewish autonomy, basing these demands on the principle that Russia was necessarily a state of many nationalities. To the contention put forth by the various peoples of Russia as well as by the socialists or democratic parties, that Russia should become a federative state, they replied that the federation should be not of a territorial but of an ethnic nature. They maintained that the territorial principle was not practicable for any of the other nationalities of Russia. For in Russia the peoples are so dispersed that no single nationality forms a majority. According to the statistics of 1897, in eight governments with a population of twenty-two millions, there was no one nationality which could claim to be considered the dominant one numerically; in twelve other governments, the preponderant people did not constitute seventy per cent of the population. A sincere believer in national autonomy could not content himself with a system which laid down the federation principle, even ostensibly, if it did not include the provision that every nationality whether it live segregated or dispersed should have the right to its own national development.

This ideology which at one time boasted energetic and sharp-witted adherents and which should undoubtedly crop up again under present circumstances had a hurtful influence on the Jewish nationalist principle. The new autonomists confined themselves to the Jews of Russia and divided the Jewish nation into two parts by nonchalantly ignoring its other half, which in reality is far more than half. However, after they had established the premise that a nationality could lead a national existence independently of its territorial disposition, this division of the Jewish people should not have found the least justification in their eyes. Moreover, they were necessarily inconsequent since in practice their nationalist principles could be carried into effect only in those regions where considerable masses of Jews live in close contiguity; for this reason, the claims put forth in their platform failed to include considerable portions of the Jewish people, for they could not demand autonomy of language for schools, courts, etc., in any regions but those where the Jews constituted at least a certain percentage of the population. Thus the territorial principle was once more in the danger of going astray. In fact, these very Seimists, being aware that their solution of the national Jewish question was inadequate, were finally constrained to state that one of the aims of the Russian Jewish Parliament which they advocated was to be the regulation of Jewish migration, so as to bring about a territorial concentration.

The courage of the Seimists manifested itself in that they evidently did not hesitate to announce the state within the state as an open claim of the Jewish people. Bereft of its halo, however, this Jewish parliament did not signify anything further than obligatory adherence the solution of the most important to the Jewish nation through constitutional provision and national-economic problems by the Jewish parliament which was to meet from time to time. It goes without saying that these aims which constituted a sort of watchword could have no more than an abstract significance in the actual political life of Russia. Many active Jewish politicians were violently opposed to these aims for

* From Seim, the Polish word for parliament.