The Maccabaean · Vol. XXX, No. 5 · May 1917
36printed page
scan 14 of 24
Facsimile · scan 14 of 24
Scan of p. 36
Text · transcribed from the scan

THE MACCABAEAN

oft-renewed conflicts, but bore witness to earnest desire and aspiration. There were many who, believing that the era of the prophecies was at hand with its unlimited opportunities for the exercise of justice, bickered about the conception and limits of this justice, and separated into a kaleidoscopic variety of individual parties struggling with one another, all belonging to a higher category despite their exaggerations.

higher category despite their exaggerations. And, notwithstanding the insupportable terror which rendered the surrounding atmosphere oppressive, a miracle was wrought, in that all these political differentiations, and the groups which were divided by a hair's-breadth of opinion, animated and stirred not only the intellectual cream of the Jewish population, but great masses of the people as well. How boundless was the energy which moved these elements that had undergone misery in every shape not only to cling to the scant possibility of existence which brutality had left them, but to soar into the realm of abstract ideas! Thus it was that the Jewish political parties were called into existence or reorganized.

We called into existence or reorganized. Doubtless, the Jewish parties which are now forming for a second time will, practically without exception, present a continuation of the former ones. An outsider would be inclined to inquire, not without displeasure: Is it really necessary that the Jews be divided into so many factions? Were all the differences based on principle, or were personalities involved? A thorough analysis reveals that the minute distinctions existing in the Russian Jewish parties of the year 1906 were not due to personal considerations, but wholly to differences of opinion, which often existed despite personal intimacy.

These differences were the result of the various attitudes assumed toward the following three questions, which were of special moment for the Jews, namely: The Jewish territorial question; the scope of national demands, and the social question. In the year 1906 the answer of the various Jewish elements ran as follows:

To the first: Palestine; any territory; recognition of territorial claims; rejection of territorial claims.

To the second: National recognition ; cultural autonomv: complete national autonomy.

To the third: Socialism; capitalistic development combined with social reforms.

If all the possible mathematical combinations of these answers had been accomplished, the number of Jewish parties would have been far greater than actually was. Fortunately Russian Jewry, without taking small groups and local organizations into consideration, consisted of only ten political parties, at that unique moment when it had the possibility of taking part openly in the general struggle, namely, when elections for the First and Second Duma were in progress. These consisted of five bourgeois parties (Zionists, Territorialists, Popular Group, National Popular Party, Association for the Granting of Equal Rights to the Jews), one social reform party (Democratic Group) and four socialist parties (Jewish Workingmen's Association of Poland and Lithuania, Socialist Zionists, Poalei Zion, and Jewish Socialist Workingmen's Party, or Seimists).

Of all these parties, the Association for the Granting of Equal Rights to the Jews had the most comprehensive platform, for this organization included the whole of Jewish bourgeois society, in addition to the Zionists and certain democratic and social-revolutionary elements. However, every organization which is composed of widely diverging elements must necessarily adopt a general program, made up of com-

promises, and thus eliminate all minor differences of opinion. The Association, then, was in the nature of a block of different political tendencies with diverging ideals, whose purpose it was to influence the political life of Russia. There was only one point on which the Association was united, namely, the demand for national recognition for the Jews. However, this minimum did not suffice to keep the Association in existence for any length of time. The Association, which, when it inaugurated its work, had aroused the hope and the vigorous approbation of the Jewish communities, was dead even before the Russian government had an opportunity to dissolve it. In spite of having been a loose organization composed of parties already in existence or in process of formation, the Association had a definite influence in the electoral campaign for the First and Second Duma, and determined, through its administrative body the Jewish policies not only of the Jewish deputies but of all the parties that sided with the Jews in the First Duma.

particles that sited with the Jews in the First Duma. Of course it cannot be said that the discussions regarding the tactics to be employed took place without violent conflicts. The closed sessions of the administrative body of the Association and of those deputies of the First Duma who were invited to be present, reflected the feverish excitement of the times, whenever a decision was to be reached. Years later Russian Jewish journalism was still engaged in controversies regarding internal events, which caused no small dissention among the participants. And yet this was the direction which a considerable part of the First Duma should have followed, that is to say that part which concerned itself with the Jewish question, and at the same time made provision for other questions as well.

questions as well. It gives me pleasure to recollect that we Zionists, who were members of the administrative body of the Association, were almost always at one with the democratic elements, in that we urged that the Jewish question be considered in its entirety, regardless of attendant circumstances. But it was a rare occurrence at these restricted meetings that our demand was upheld by the majority, for the retrogressive forces had a stronger representation.

At the open meetings of the Association, however, the situation was quite different, for there the Zionists with their national claims generally triumphed, as they did in the winter of 1905-1906, on the third day when the Duma was sitting, in demanding a Jewish national assemblage; and in May, 1906, on the fourth day of the session, when after stormy debates they succeeded in forming a faction of the twelve Jewish deputies in the First Duma.

When, in the winter of 1905-1906, political passions were rampant in Russia, the Association for the Granting of Equal Rights to the Jews, was confronted by the question which political tendency it should favor in the elections. In the Pale of Settlement it was taken for granted that a Jew would perforce cast his vote with the “left” parties, or possibly with the Constitutional Democrats; it would have been incompatible with Jewish ideas and Jewish interests had a Jew identified himself with a conservative or Octobrist group.

The Association for the Granting of Equal Rights to the Jews accepted this point of view, although certain of the delegates opposed a definite disposition of the Jewish vote, since they thought it was illogical to accept without question the principle that none but democratic parties would further the cause of equal rights for the Jews; it was not impossible that con-