The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIX, No. 6 · December 1916
98printed page
scan 2 of 34

THE MACCABAEAN

ally, a great deal of what Dr. Magnes reports must be regarded as confidential. It remains with the Joint Distribution Committee to act for the best interests of the Jews in Poland after it has given due consideration to Dr. Magnes’ impressions. In the meantime, Dr. Magnes has seen fit to correct various comments that have been made upon his reports, one delivered in the Manhattan Y. M. H. A., the other before the People’s Relief Committee. He thinks that the article in The Maccabaean of last month on “Relief in Poland” revealed a lack of information. I do not want to be technical. Nor should Dr. Magnes be technical. When I used the words “moneys for the Jews in the occupied territories” I meant, as my readers could readily see, relief moneys. Dr. Magnes admits that public relief moneys for the Jews in the general government of Warsaw could be sent through the American Consul at Warsaw, but he does not think it advisable to do so. Even the sending of money to individual Jews by the Provisional Zionist Committee through the American Consul and Polish Jewish Committees he disapproves of. His report is intended to strengthen the position of those who believe that the German Hilfscomite should be the medium through which all American Jewish relief funds are to be sent. What difference does it make, therefore, whether I used the word “could” instead of “should” and “moneys” instead of “public relief moneys.” He proposes that under the circumstances, all moneys, public relief as well as individual, should be sent through the German Hilfscomite. At the same time, he admits that something is not altogether right about this proposed arrangement, for he emphasizes the fact that the new name of the committee indicates that it is to distribute American Jewish relief moneys. Was this not the fact before? Was it not known that the funds distributed by the Hilfscomite came from America? He also admits that new members may be added to the Hilfscomite in Berlin, and that it is his hope ultimately to place full responsibility in local committees in Poland and Lithuania. Why should there be fuller responsibility if the German committee is so efficient and so desirable ?

HIS DRIFT

D OES Dr. Magnes realize his position when he comes to us as an advocate of the German Hilfscomite? He knows— for he has seen the documents—that the Hilfsverein, since the outbreak of the war, presented the German government with a statement from its agent in Palestine, Ephraim Cohn, which it sent on to the Turkish government, in which the government was advised why and how it should rid Palestine of Zionists. On the basis of this advice, the Ottoman government ordered the expulsion of well-known Zionists and the closing of the Anglo-Palestine bank. The persons who acted for the Hilfsverein in this matter were Dr. Paul Nathan and Dr. Bernard Kahn, both of whom are in the Hilfscomite. Dr. Magnes states that relief has nothing to do with the political interests of the Jews. This is not clear. One thing is certain: The conditions of the

Jews after the war are being created by us during the war. If the leaders of the relief in Germany are assimilators, they are strengthened in their position by the fact that Jews of America entrust them with relief funds, and no matter what we may do after the war, they will have impressed high political circles with their views of Jewish policy, which it will be almost impossible for us to eradicate. Dr. Magnes says that it is only through the men in the Hilfsverein that the German government may successfully be approached. It is evident, therefore, that when these men do approach the German government it will not be possible for them to suppress their political ideas. By adding one Jewish socialist and one Zionist to the Hilfscomite nothing is accomplished. The control remains with the men who are represented by Kahn, Nathan and Simon. They are the virtual administrators. They have the office, they conduct the correspondence, they represent the Hilfscomite before the government. It was to have been expected that when Dr. Magnes returned from Europe, he would report that a German committee must be employed, but if a German committee who one headed by men like Simon, Kahn and Nathan? Are there no other German Jews,

men who are not such outspoken assimilators who could become the leaders the relief? Especially so when Dr. Magnes himself admits that the necessity that compels the employment of a German committee is deplorable. But instead of doing this, Dr. Magnes comes back with but one conclusion: Give the control of the relief moneys for Jews in Poland, the gifts of American Jews, to assimilation. This could have been expected from an assimilator, but not from a man who at one time worked hand in hand with Zionists.

THE PEOPLE’S RELIEF COMMITTEE

THE People’s Relief Convention at Boston was wholly under the influence of nationalistic ideals in relief. The declaration adopted by a unanimous vote should please every Zionist, for it contains in brief form a statement of policy which ought to guide the relief work in the United States. The relief of the victims of the war should not be regarded as charity. It must be considered as a national obligation. Not only elementary relief, but relief so organized on a constructive basis that it will not be necessary for long to continue the sending of relief from this country. The Boston convention revealed a healthy state of mind, enthusiasm combined with intelligence. It is to be hoped that as a result of the work done at Boston, a new note will be struck in the relief work. Those who so eagerly attacked the combination made between the Zionists and socialists in relief work at the Manhattan convention will repent of their attacks, when they read the proceedings of the Boston convention, and note how strongly in every particular the nationalist spirit broke out in effective resolutions. The question was not one of control of the Relief Committee, but the control lies in the hands of nationalist Jews. The question was how to maintain the national spirit in the People’s Relief Committee without breaking it. The Peoples’ Relief Committee is now stronger than ever, and the transformation has been effected without loss of prestige. There are many anxious that the nationalists in the Committee take notice of the tactless and insulting speech of Congressman Meyer London delivered at the Boston mass-meeting. We have no doubt that Mr. London will act in accordance with the policy he adopted in Congress. Whenever he overstepped the limits of propriety he forthwith apologized. In view of the protests that have been made against his Boston address, he will doubtless apologize and promise never to transgress any more. Certainly, it is not worth while to make a party issue of an address delivered by a speaker who quite frequently offends the sensibilities of his friends and outrages the feelings of those who are not of his party. The work of relief cannot be halted to take notice of an address delivered by a man who does not remember what he said. Among gentlemen, resignation follows a breach of the spirit of the organization with which one is connected. Should Mr. London be inspired with a desire to benefit the Peoples’ Relief Committee, his voluntary resignation ought to follow as a matter of course. The Reviewer.