The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIX, No. 6 · December 1916
97printed page
scan 1 of 34

THE MACCABAEAN

DEVOTED TO ZIONISM AND ALL JEWISH INTERESTS

VOLUME XXIX.

ESTABLISHED OCTOBER, 1901

DECEMBER, 1916
No. 6

Published monthly by The Federation of American Zionists, a corporation under the laws of the State of New York, 44 East Twenty-third Street, Publication office, 44 East 23rd Street, New York. Entered at New York Post Office as Second Class Matter. Subscriptions for one year $1.00, payable in advance. All foreign countries, including Canada, $1.25. Single copies, ten cents.

Subscribers are advised to notify us at once of any change of address.

VIEWS AND COMMENTS

THE NATIONAL FUND

TO THE credit of the Zionist movement must be ascribed the introduction into Jewish life of a number of invigorating ideas and institutions. Before the advent of modern Zionism, self-emancipation sounded like the outpouring of dreamers. How could one expect the Jewish people. scattered in every land, to bring about their own emancipation. The prevailing idea was that an outside force would liberate the Jewish people. They were dependent upon miracles, upon the goodwill of the enlightened statesmen, upon the sense of justice of those who were their persecutors and belittlers. Zionists struck the clear note of self-help, and immediately out of the oppressed and scattered people there emerged ways and means wherewith the emancipation was to be effected. The Congress brought corporate form to the inchoate desires of our people. It offered a platform whence the Jewish voice issued. It introduced methods of organization which were to unite the Jews of all lands. Then came the National Fund and the Jewish Colonial Trust; the one spoke of the redemption of the land, the other spoke of the revivification of the commercial and industrial springs of life in Palestine, and the employment of large means to affect the larger purpose. The National Fund was to be like the fund left by the Wandering Jew, an everlasting fund, continuously augmented, into which the Jews were to pour their wealth in order that the national soil might be redeemed. The fund was to have everlasting life, and its operations were to be conducted in an impersonal way, so that no matter who passed away, the Fund remained as the everlasting possession of the people. And with proper spirit, the Jewish people responded to the appeal of the National Fund. It has become the institution best beloved by non-Zionists as well as Zionists. In spite of its prosaic daily operations. the Fund contains within its meaning a bit of the romantic spirit which has been lacking in Jewish endeavors hitherto. There is something fascinating in the gradual increase of the Fund, how it has entered Jew-

thousands who have given daily of their interest and of their means. In the celebration of the fifteenth anniversary of the Fund, emphasis should be placed upon the far-reaching features of the institution, and less upon the means employed in augmenting it. We recommend to our readers a careful reading of the interesting articles on the National Fund appearing in this issue, and we hope that every Zionist will participate in the Flag Day of the Fund which occurs on Sunday, December 24th.

RELIGIOUS AUTONOMY IN POLAND

THE recognition of Jewish religious autonomy in Poland by the German government—following the reorganization of Poland and its recognition—will not satisfy the nationalist demands of the Jews, unless it is clearly intended to grant an extensive nationalist autonomy under the designation of religious organization. Some of the reports coming here indicate a broad application of the term, for the program includes the maintenance and supervision of schools, institutions, etc. But there is no suggestion of political recognition of Jewish National rights. It is to be regretted that Germany has taken this step at a time when the inference can be made that it was influenced by military or political considerations. The internal affairs of Poland should be discussed solely from the point of view of the interests of the various nationalities in it. Any program now promulgated will necessarily be subject to revision when peace is negotiated. A judicial revision will be produced by administrative reforms introduced in the heat of the conflict by one of the parties to the struggle.

AN ENGLISHMAN OF THE JEWISH FAITH

T HE trouble with the Englishman of the Jewish Faith who writes in the Fortnightly Review on Zionism is that he is beset with explanations of terms that have lost their old meaning. He is bothered by emancipation, by religion, by assimilation, and cannot conceive of Jewish life in which

December, 1916

there is a revaluation of the terms employed in the polemics of the past thirty years. The assumption of the emancipationists was not false. They believed that emancipation would bring full liberty to the Jewish spirit. But emancipation proved to be an impracticable panacea. It did not lead to liberty but to confusion and deterioration. It freed the Jewish body, but brought anemia to the Jewish spirit. Finding that emancipation did not work, that it could not work. the policy of reintegration was adopted by a large body of Jews under the influence of the Zionist ideal. Necessarily, the new policy discards not only the assumptions of the emancipation, but gives new meaning to the pre-emancipation aspirations of the Jewish people. It realizes that the Jewish problem must be dealt with in the modern spirit. It feels that religion alone—given an alien environment—is bound to suffer in vigor, clearness and carrying power: it is bound to become the sort of thing it is in France, in Italy. The question of double patriotism does not en ter into the problem, even if it were based on well-grounded fears. The problem of the liberation of a peop'e, to set free all its faculties, cannot be made dependent upon an exaggerated fear. It must act from its own axis, for its own interests, and forge ahead regardless of what phrases are destroyed in the operation. The writer in the Fortnightly Review will probably get his bearings when once he begins to understand the aims of the Zionist movement. As it is, his article sounds like the utterances of a Rip Van Winkle when his bewildered mind began to deal with the realities of the day.

DR. MAGNES' REPORT

A GREAT deal will have to be said about the report of Dr. Magnes on conditions in the occupied territories. In a sense, it is not an official report, but merely the impressions of a hurried trip through Germany and Poland. These impressions may be correct, but it is clear that official action based upon such impressions would not be judicious. Natur-

Ninety-seven