The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIX, No. 6 · December 1916
23scan
of 34

THE MACCABAEAN

lature hesitate as to granting the Jews the fullest civic and political emancipation; and, though it was true there was a dogma of his religion that God would restore all the Jews to Palestine, this dogma had no influence whatever upon his life.” Mr. Bentwich goes on to point out, however, that the writer of the article concentrates all his arguments on the struggle for the admission of Jews to Parliament. But emancipation was only the logical result of the right to settle which was given to the Jews by the Protection of the Commonwealth and confirmed by the Restoration. Instead, therefore, of asking “when the Jews in England were granted full political rights, what were the arguments used to justify the gift?” the re-

levant question is: When the Jews from abroad were allowed the liberty of resettlement, what were the arguments on which the claim to admission was based? The first argument, says Mr. Bentwich, was that the admission of the Jews to England was a necessary preliminary to the fulfilment of the Divine promise. The second was based on the great principle of religious liberty, and the third was the broader argument of benefit to the State. Mr. Bentwich quotes the action of such loyal Jews as Sir Moses Montefiore and the late Lord Swaythling, the former of whom had actually arranged the terms for the foundation of a new Commonwealth in Palestine, while the latter at a meeting in Mile

End on the occasion when a petition was being prepared at the instance of Lord Rothschild for the free admission of Jews to Palestine, said: “I am sure that only good will come from the action of Lord Rothschild, and that not only will Jews be assisted in colonizing Palestine, but practical shape will be given to their aspirations for the restoration of the Jewish Kingdom.” Of Zionism, Mr. Bentwich adds, it is not too much to say that it was innate in the demand for civil and religious liberty. With that left out—or, worse, surrendered—the emancipation of the Jews would have been but the exchange of one slavery for another, the slavery of the body for the slavery of the spirit.

GENERAL ZIONIST NEWS

A TESTIMONIAL TO MR. JUSTICE LOUIS D. BRANDEIS

Over one hundred guests were present on Sunday afternoon, November 26th, in the offices of Nathan Straus in the Aeolian Building, when a presentation was made to Justice Louis D. Brandeis on behalf of about ten thousand Jews, who thus desired to express their felicitations to tne Justice on his sixtieth birthday.

Dr. Stephen S. Wise acted as chairman in place of Nathan Straus, who was unable to be present, and who sent the following letter: „

Being unexpectedly prevented from extending my congratulations in person, I herewith offer all good wishes for continued health and success in whatever you may undertake. In commemoration of your sixtieth birthday, your admiring and devoted friends and co-workers desire to present to you a fund to be applied by you to some philanthropic pur-

We present it as a token of our admiration of your fine work and indomitable perseverance in keeping alive the spirit of Zionism when it was threatened with oblivion in the whirlpool of the war; our admiration for the patience you displayed in dealing with the many problems; our admiration for your unselfish arduous labors and the many personal sacrifices you made on behalf of the sacred cause.

Only the great honor which has been bestowed on you and through you on Judaism can reconcile us for the loss of your leadership.

Your noble Dissen, and example must be the guiding spirit of your worthy successors —for the blessing of Zionism and the welfare of Judasim all over the world.

(Signed) NATHAN STRAUS Mamaraneck, N. Y. November 26th, 1916. After brief addresses had been delivered by Judge Julian W. Mack, Dr. Harry Friedenwald, Dr. Wise, Prof. Richard Gotthell, Miss Henrietta Szold, Dr. David de Sola Pool, and Mr. Jacob de Haas, Mr. Justice Brandeis replied, visibly affected by the tributes paid to him. He said in part:

“The two years and more that cover my real activity in Zionist affairs have been rich in their gifts to me, bringing happiness and bringing me understanding. And this meeting to-day is in line with what I have before experienced. I might also say, in line with what I have always experienced in working with those in the Zionist Cause. I came into the ranks with the knowledge of what had always been sald of the dissension among the Jews, their unwillingness to work together and the impossibility of uniting them for a common cause; and in all the time in which I had the opportunity of presiding in the Provisional Committee, there was not a moment that I can complain in any way here of lack of loyalty to my work and to me, or the Cause which I was en- deavorine to further.

"The last seven weeks which separated me from that daily participation in the work of the Zionists, has not left me without knowledge of what is occurring. Through the various conferences with

Mr. de Haas, who was active originally in bringing me into the Cause and upon whose wisdom and devotion and experience I have relied so much—I have beun kept in touch, and the daily reports which I have received from the office have kept me in touch with what is going on, and while there are many details which I do not know with that accuracy with which I knew them when I was here every week and had Zionist conferences every day, I do feel advised in a general way.

“The aloofness of those seven weeks and the distance in Washington gives me some special ability to state what seems to me are our opportunities, and what are the necessities, and what are the dangers in our work. I feel more than ever, that the opportunities are very great, opportunities such as have not been in eighteen centuries. The world is with us—the non-Jewish world. The question is whether the Jewish world will be with us; and that, I take it, depends very largely upon the Zionists themselves. Those who are not Zionists, whether they be anti-Zionists or non-Zionists, are not the persons upon whom the responsibility rests. It rests upon those who become convinced of the truth of Zionism, and our success and failure will depend largely upon the loyalty and the wisdom of those who believe, as we believe.”

Mr. de Haas, on behalf of the special testimonal committee presented a volume containing over ten thousand signatures, and representing contributions to a fund, to be disposed of as Mr.. Justice Brandeis will decide.

The Testimonial reads: "To the Honorable Louis Dembitz Brandeis on his sixtieth birthday, November thirteenth, nineteen hundred and sixteen, imbued to the heart with American and Jewish Ideals and Indefatigable Worker in Translating them into Action. A testimonial of Gratitude for his services to the Jewish People and a Tribute of love and Loyalty to our Leader."

Ihe committee In charge oiI the Ttesti- monial were: President, Nathan Straus; Vice-Presidents, Dr. Stephen S. Wise, Dr. Harry Friedenwald, Rabbi Martin A. Meyer, Joseph Barondess, Dr. Max Heller, Judge Julian W. Mack, Rabbi Mayer Berlin, and Mrs. Joseph Fels; Treasurer, Eugene Meyer, Jr.; Honorary Secretary, Jacob de Haas: and Assistant Secretary, Adolph Hubbard.

Minutes of the Executive Committee Meeting I. A regular meeting of the Executive Committee of the Federation was held Thursday evening, November 9th, at the Federation offices, 44 East 23rd Street, New York City. There were present: The

chairman, Mr. Abel, Rabbi Raisin, Dr. S. Melamed, Mrs. Guggenheimer, Dr. Pool and Mr. Goldberg. Excuses for absence were received from Mr. Louis Robison, Mr. Charles A. Cowen.

Mrs. Guggenheimer moved to reconsider the action taken at the last meeting with regard to Madam Pevsner. It was decided, after the motion to reconsider had been carried, to refer the entire matter to a special committee to be appointed by the chairman. Messrs. Abel and Rothenberg and Mrs. Guggenheimer were appointed.

Intercollegiate Zionist Association—It was decided to issue to branches of the Intercollegiate Zionist Assn. charters, upon application, without the payment of charter fee, provided the applications are approved by the central committee of the Association.