The Zionist Movement
A Monthly Review of Zionist Activities
Readers of The Maccabaean are asked to send news of Zionist activities for publication in this department. All communications should be addressed: Managing Editor, Maccabaean Magazine, 44 East 23rd Street, New York.
NEWS FROM PALESTINE
Official information has been received by the Provisional Committee that the Zionist bank, 'The Anglo-Palestine Company, has reopened all its branches in Palestine. At the outbreak of the war, the Anglo-Palestine Company, being an English institution, was closed by the Turkish Government: The Provisional Committee is not as yet in a position to make public all the facts that lead to the reopening of the branches of the Anglo-Palestine Company in Palestine. At one of its recent meetings, it voted to relieve the depositors of the Anglo-Palestine
Company to the extent of $60,000, paid in monthly instalments.
Cultural Work for Women in Palestine Is is encouraging to note the splendid work conducted by the “Jewish Womens’ Society for cultural work in Palestine.” In spite of the limited propaganda possibilities and the difficulty in maintanng steady communication with its members, the society continues its work in Palestinee The lace-workshops in Jerusalem and Jaffa are able to give steady employment to a number of young girls, assisting them thereby in supporting their families. The European sale of the laces
has decreased; the amount in 1914 being 16,483 francs, as against 6,700 francs in 1915.
Turkish Government Opens Food Stores Djemal Pasha, military governor of Syria and Palestine, has been asked by the Jerusalem municipal government to establish municipal stores for the sale of vietuals. The government has on hand at present a store of beans, lentils, peeled- barley, sesame, and sugar. The establishment of the victuals-offices is intended for all the quarters of the city and will relieve the impoverished Jewish, as well as non-Jewish.,. population in Jerusalem.
ZIONIST NEWS FROM ABROAD
BULGARIA Bulgarian Zionists Active The official Zionist Organ “Hamishpat” reports activity on the part of the Bulgarian Zionist Federation. Meetings are being held frequently in various towns and the Palestine Relief Action is being propagated very successfully in spite of the war. The Federation has published a Calendar for the year 5677, which contains a number of valuable contributions.
DENMARK Danish Press on Zionism Since the Conference of Scandinavian Zionists held at Copenhagen last May, the (Scandinavian Press has been devoting considerable attention to the Zionist movement and its aims. Danish papers, such as “Hejemmet” and “Politiken” have printed articles on “The History of Modern Zionism and the Jewish Colonization in Palestine” and “The Task of Zionism.”
ENGLAND Chief Rabbi Replies to Attack on Zionism In the November issue of the “Fortnightly Review,” there appeared an anonymous article on Zionism by “An Englishman of the Jewish Faith.” The article is an attack on Zionism and Zionists. The author of the article, whose identity can very easily be traced, advances the theory that Jewish Emancipation in England was the result of a bargain under which the Jew obtained justice in return for his renunciation of the Jewish nationality. The author further denounces Zionism as a dangerous movement. Zionist aspirations, he says, are incompatible with the loyalty of the Jews to the country of their birth. The article has called forth a storm of protests on the part of Jews in England. In the December issue of the “Fortnightly Review” there appear two answers to this article, coming from Dr. Hertz, Chief Rabbi of England and Herbert Bentwich, a well known English Zionist leader. The article of Dr. Hertz is dignified, and official. It is a complete refutation of the inferences contained in the article, while the one of Herbert Bent-
wich is more of a controversial nature. We give here summaries of the two articles: An article, “Zionism: by an Englishman of the Jewish Faith,” appeared in the November issue of this Review which, I feel, calls for a solemn protest on behalf of the community which the author of that article directly and inferentially maligned. In his desire to discredit Zionism, he brings by implication the charge of faithlessness and dissimulation against the Anglo-Jewish leaders who achieved Jewish emancipation in this country; and, further, he openly denounces Zionism as a dangerous movement, and Zionists as necessarily unpatriotic and disloyal to their country. “When the Jews in England were granted full political rights, what were the arguments used to justify the gift?” is his opening question. And he proceeds to tell us that the battle for the removal of religious disabilities was fought by Jews on the plea that their belief in Israel’s national regeneration was merely a “pious dogma” which had “no relation to action and life.” Now the history of the emancipation struggle does not justify any such version of the case as the one suggested by the writer in question. The Jewish and non-Jewish advocates of emancipation for the most part based their appeals on grounds of religious toleration, freedom, and humanity, but above all on those of justice. . . . Four representative leaders of the emancipation period were that noble philanthropist, Sir Moses Montefiore (1784-1885), whose life-long devotion to the Holy Land was the admiration of his age; Baron Lionel de Rothschild (1806-1879), who ever maintained that civil and social equality for the Jew would indeed be dearly bought if they entailed the weakening of the religious bond of brotherhood; the Rev. Professor Marks (1811-1909), minister of the orthodox contemporary, the then Chief Rabbi, the erudite and universally venerated Dr. Nathan Marcus Adler (1903-1890). These are not men who either tacitly or impliedly would have entered into any such contract as the contributor to this Magazine intimates. ... . The main contention, however, of this anonymous assallant of Zionism, is that it is a dangerous movement. Few Jews, and still fewer non-Jews, will agree with “An Englishman of the Jewish Faith,” in the fear that this conscious striving for the renascence of Israel on the soil of even a British Judaea is “dangerous.” We have long known that there were absolute duties, for the fulfilment of which a mother sends her only child to an almost certain deat. In this Holy War, waged on behalf of the weaker and smaller nations of the world, the Allies are battling for the enthronement of the principle, as a governing idea of European Policy, that there also are rights—human, cultural and political —which are absolute, which cannot be with-
held from any human group yearning for them. . .. It is not my intention or my desire to expound or to defend Zionism (proceeds the Chief Rabbi, in conclusion). Zionists, however, form a considerable proportion of my Empire-wide “parish” ; and, if among them are to be included those who sympathize with the main objects of the movement, I have no doubt that the larger portion of those under my spiritual care are involved. It is, therefore, necessary for me to repeat that the ends which Zionism is striving to accomplish are absolutely consistent with both the sacred ideals of Judaism and the utmost devotion to the country of which the Jew is a citizen. Sabbath by Sabbath and Holyday by Holyday, Jews pray in their synagogues for the welfare of the rulers of the State whose subjects they are, in the same breath in which they express their undying hope in the Restoration.” . . . And in the very struggle in which our great and beloved country is a protagonist, the majority of the Jews fighting in the Allied Armies are of those who “pray for the peace of Jerusalem.” Zionists are doing their part side by side with their fellow-Jews and their fellow-citizens in the grin and awful duty that war has cast upon them; and the final test of patriotism is the willingness to fight for your country, to die for it..
Extracts of Mr. Herbert Bentwich’s Reply The world-war, says Mr. Bentwich, with its trumpet-call to the small nations, has roused apprehension of the immediate success of Zionist aims.” They have endeavored to counter the appeal to Jewish Nationalist sentiment by a manifesto, addressed this time not to the students or the intellectuals alone but to the whole Jewish people, but their attempt to turn back the wheel of time has failed—the projected manifesto has fallen flat for want of support in the most influential quarters. And so they have put forward an anonymous writer in a leading organ of English opinion, the Fortnightly, to declare the faith of Englishmen of the Jewish persuasion, to defame the opponents of the anti-national creed and policy, and to threaten the community, who are in danger of going over bodily to the cause of Zion, with the loss of hard-won privileges secured to them in a past generation by the champions of emancipation. Mr. Bentwich goes on to deal with the “burden of the attack” by the “Englishman of the Jewish Faith.” This is that “The claim of the Jews to have granted to them full political rights was based on the representation that it was only certain religious doctrines and practices which separated them from their Christian fellow citizens; the Jewish race was a matter of antiquarian genealogy; it did not affect his loyalty to his fatherland; the religious differences were not of a kind to make the Legis-