THE MACCABAEAN
Ito-Zionist. Huntington Park, Cal., October 17, 1916. Gentlemen: I am in receipt of your communication. In reply shall state to you that I am a Zionist to the extent that I should like to see a refuge (Palestine preferred) for our persecuted brethren; a home where they can enjoy full freedom. There are no Jews living here in this city. Kindly send me some literature and oblige
Yours fraternally, SIGMUND FREY. * * * Will Study Question.
‚Allentown, Pa., October 16, 1916. Gentlemen: I am not a Zionist in that I do not believe in the establishment of a state in Palestine or anywhere else for the purpose o! advancing or effecting the political or cultural status of the Jew. I am a national. ist in the sense of believing in the establishment of a religious, social, and psychological unity among all the Jews of the world But I do not feel that the latter can be accomplished or should be accomplished except by the concerted efforts of the Jewish communities in their respective coun tries. I have never agitated strongly against Zionism, although I have neve:i failed to express my disapproval of i wherever the occasion demanded it. I can not say that I have made a thorough stud) of the subject, although I intend, during; the coming year to give it complete con sideration, and then take a most definit and aggressive stand on the question. fully realize, I believe, its growing powe and influence, but I am inclined to thinl that this new enthusiasm is only a passing phase of Jewish life, arisen out the unpre cedented war conditions. I shall be happ! to receive any literature on the subject tha you may see fit to send me, and I assur: you that such literature will be given th deepest consideration. I hope at all time to be fair and equitable to the cause o Tinnism.
Trusting that my reply has been definite enough for your purpose, and emphasizing that the above has only been a statement of my beliefs on the subject, and not a brief of argument against it, I am,
Yours very truly, JACOB TARSHISH. * * *
"A Hurtful Influence."
Waco, Texas, October 14, 1916. Dear Colleagues: In answer to your circular letter of October 10th, permit me to say that I cannot join the Zionist movement because I consider it impractical. To sympathize with the movement because it has stirred up some few among those who heretofore had been entirely indifferent to Jewish interests, does not sound to me to be good logic. At best, such a stimulus is artificial and accomplishes nothing. You are aware of the fact that I am always ready to co-operate with intense earnestness in all activities that promises to help the Jewish cause; but I am of firm conviction that political Zionism, instead of helping, is a hurtful influence. With kindest regards, and wishing you
every possible success in your field of activity, Yours very faithfully
Yours very faithfully, I. WARSAW. * * * Is with Us. Cincinnati, O., October 13, 1916. Dear Colleagues: I suppose you know my position on the question from many articles I have published in the course of the last twenty years or so, some of them quite recently. Very cordially yours, D. NEWMARK. * * * Will Render Service.
Williamsport, Pa., October 24, 1916. Dear Colleagues: I beg to acknowledge receipt of your esteemed favor of the 10th inst., and in reply will say that I am not a Zionist, but have never been antagonistic toward the movement, on the contrary, have always looked upon it favorably. I shall be pleased, whenever opportunity offers itself to speak on the subject in the Temple and other public occasions and shall be glad if I can render any service to the cause. With fraternal greetings, I am,
Yours very sincerely, E. ELLINGER. * * * Impartial. Dayton, Ohio, October 25, 1916. Gentlemen: In response to the circular letter sent out
I Dr. Max Raisin, I beg to say that while I cannot see my way to champion the cause of Zionism, I have always tried in the past and shall continue in the future to present the cause fairly and honestly and I believe sympathetically to my congregation. Very sincerely yours, DAVID LEFKOWITZ. * * * Is Interested. Lincoln, Neb., October 25, 1916. Gentlemen:
e T’m in receipt of the favor of 10th inst. 3 of your committee and desire to assure you t of my interest in the Zionist movement. a While not affiliated with your Federation, I'm willing to study its claims and literature in order to be fair to its position. Any literature you may desire to send which is not accessihle T shall oladiv receive.
TACOB SINGER.
x * %* je Strict!y Neutral. t Pittsburgh, Pa., October 14, 1916. I Gentlemen: e In reply to your letter of October 10th, d I beg to assure you of my sincere apprecia- e tion of your very cordial letter. It was - very good of you to draw my attention to d this matter, and I am grateful to you for ithe friendly spirit you manifest. e Yours very sincerely, y J. LEONARD LEVY. A *x* %* I- Keeps the Peace. n Jackson, Tenn., October 13, 1916. is Gent'emen: I am not a Zionist, but I am not an anti-u 7Zianist TI have never ahuısed nor spoken
an ill word against your association. If I disagree with you I claim the right to my own opinion. The cause of Judaism is dear to my heart, and I devoted in America forty odd years to that cause. But I do not believe in political Zionism as it prevailed a few years ago and is, perhaps, yet rampant among many; therefore I have kept my peace.
I am a man very far advanced in life, and my health is rapidly failing, hence I can no more take an active part in any enterprise, and only attend to my routine work. I gladly admit that you have done good work, and wish you further success. Most cordially yours,
JOSEPH BOGEN. * x* *
Four "Ifs." Baltimore, Md., October 13, 1916. Gentlemen:
NALAISLILAKILAL . Your communication has been received. I am not a Zionist because I am not a politico-nationalist Jew. If the Zionists would come out with a four square statement defining exactly what their hopes and claims are, if the Zionists would repudiate the establishment of a political entity in Palestine, if the Zionists would repudiate a politico-nationalistic interpretation of Jewish history, and if, on the other hand, they would declare that their sole intention is to encourage settlement in Palestine and further Jewish life there, they would probably have the co-operation of great numbers of American Jews who are at present their opponents. Sincerelyv vours.,
MORRIS S. LAZARON.
* * * "Zionism Firm." Los Angeles, Cal., October 17, 1916. Dear Colleagues:
Dear Kolleagues: After a careful perusal of your circular letter, I beg leave to reply that my attitude toward Zionism has been and is the same as yours in every stated particular, and so I do not in the least hesitate to give an affırmative answer to every one of your questions. In fact, I have found Zionism firm in its very inception, whenever and wherever opportunity offered I have invariably championed its cause. I have always believed, and frankly avowed, that it is the duty of every loyal and faithful Jew to labor with all his might and main towards one and the same ideal, aim and end: “Building up Palestine as a refuge of safety and the center of a many-sided Jewish renaissance,” but under the suzerainty of some safe occidented power, under stronr international euarantees.
Indeed from the very start of the movement I have been and still am of the same opinion, that for the final success of Zionism a Jewish cultural basis is absolutely necessary. Needless to add that you may address me again on the subject if occasion demands, and that I shall be only too glad to serve the Palestine interests in the future as I have done in the past. With fraternal greetings, I am trustfully yours, MICHAEL G. SOLOMON.